|
Don't know if this helps or confuses you, but these lines are from a Patchwerk /combatlog. The tank here uses Thunderfury. Note that many normal melee attacks have a (resist) portion, some of them are crits, and many are glances/blocks as well. I am merely assuming the resisted portion is from the elemental damage, as I've never seen this on any other melee weapon personally. Clearly the resistance check on the elemental portion is done independent of any "outcome table".
To make sure I am being absolutely clear here, I am talking about the "+16-30 Nature damage" portion of the weapon stats, not the proc. The proc shows up as "Olo's Thunderfury was resisted by Patchwerk." or "Olo's Thunderfury hits Patchwerk for 270 Nature damage.". The +16-30 appears to be added to the melee swing damage, but is indepentendly checked for resistance if it lands, regardless of whether it was hit/crit/glance/blocked. Against patchwerk, it appears as if roughly 18% of *landed* attacks suffer a partial resist of some sort. They seem to be mostly 25% partial resists, with the occasional 50%.
(I only included lines that show resisted attacks. There are roughly 125 succesful hits that have non resistance, I left that out for size and clarity)
[1160014031.062] Olo hits Patchwerk for 79. (6 resisted) (46 blocked)
[1160014033.015] Olo crits Patchwerk for 235. (15 resisted)
[1160014048.250] Olo hits Patchwerk for 111. (glancing) (20 resisted)
[1160014064.890] Olo hits Patchwerk for 163. (14 resisted)
[1160014082.406] Olo hits Patchwerk for 140. (glancing) (6 resisted)
[1160014118.531] Olo hits Patchwerk for 109. (glancing) (12 resisted)
[1160014120.328] Olo crits Patchwerk for 323. (6 resisted)
[1160014126.046] Olo hits Patchwerk for 112. (glancing) (7 resisted)
[1160014127.328] Olo hits Patchwerk for 101. (glancing) (5 resisted)
[1160014143.046] Olo crits Patchwerk for 296. (12 resisted)
[1160014148.140] Olo crits Patchwerk for 365. (5 resisted)
[1160014154.843] Olo crits Patchwerk for 338. (10 resisted)
[1160014176.968] Olo hits Patchwerk for 214. (6 resisted)
[1160014185.187] Olo hits Patchwerk for 179. (6 resisted)
[1160014199.031] Olo hits Patchwerk for 106. (glancing) (6 resisted)
[1160014206.500] Olo hits Patchwerk for 99. (glancing) (18 resisted)
[1160014236.187] Olo hits Patchwerk for 95. (glancing) (7 resisted)
[1160014243.468] Olo hits Patchwerk for 174. (6 resisted)
[1160014268.984] Olo crits Patchwerk for 396. (12 resisted)
[1160014275.390] Olo hits Patchwerk for 165. (15 resisted) (46 blocked)
[1160014277.234] Olo hits Patchwerk for 186. (8 resisted)
[1160014295.265] Olo hits Patchwerk for 123. (glancing) (6 resisted)
[1160014305.203] Olo crits Patchwerk for 440. (7 resisted)
[1160014307.109] Olo hits Patchwerk for 126. (6 resisted) (46 blocked)
[1160014310.093] Olo hits Patchwerk for 101. (glancing) (5 resisted)
[1160014326.890] Olo hits Patchwerk for 125. (6 resisted) (46 blocked)
[1160014335.656] Olo hits Patchwerk for 110. (glancing) (7 resisted)
[1160014382.875] Olo hits Patchwerk for 133. (glancing) (14 resisted)
|