Originally Posted by Erongg
Compare different classes, not the same class. If rogues/warriors gain more from a shaman, they'll get him. If mages gain more from a shadow priest, they'll get him.
|
Its not always only "who gets it".
As of TBC, the hunter also gives back.
Have dps group1 consist of:
1x feral for 5% crit
1x warrior for battle shout
1x melee shammy for agi, earth, 10% AP and bloodlust
1x maybe a rogue, who gives nothing but gets a lot
Would you want to give the 5th spot to a rogue who gets (theoretically, never did the math) more out of a shammy totem then a hunter, or would you give it to a hunter, who gives 3% damage and 110 melee AP to a total of 6 members for optimal synergy?
Second part of that question is, did you check the skill level of the players and do you know the full potential of both classes and how close they are on reaching it?
Does it help to put bad player A in the group, who gets more out of the buffs in theory then player B, who profits a bit less, but plays twice as good?
I'd say perfect group composition cant be done by simple numbers and should be examined on a case by case basis for perfection.