Originally Posted by galzohar
Wouldn't 10% str and 15% seal/judgement of righteousness damage deal more threat than 5% damage via 1h weapon spec, assuming you can drop the points from parry and still be crush immune via blocks? (note that being crush immune via blocks rather than via parry actually deals a bit more threat as well).
As for the rotation, remember that when redoubt is active you can actually let your holy shield wait for a concentration+judge+reseal. Depending on what portion of your threat is from holy shield blocks this might be a TPS loss, although I highly doubt it after glancing again at the OP's TPS from spell damage values. Figuring out redoubt's uptime to calculate actual TPS is a big problem, but figuring out whether you gain or lose tps by delaying HS when redoubt is active shouldn't be.
|
A poor choice given that our white damage is a very very small source of threat, and 10% strength when you only have 130ish is a very minuscule amount of block value. Imp SoR is more for Holy Paladins who want to solo farm as holy, not for protection. The 15% bonus occurs on the base damage of the ability, the effect is not calculated with your spell damage, which means it doesn't scale at all with your spell damage/gear level.
Also, dropping points from parry like you mentioned is definitely not something I would recommend for any tank. Avoidance is a wonderful thing, and while I prefer the consistency of blocks as a tank and as a healer, it's not something you can overlook gaining 1% avoidance for 1 talent point.