Originally Posted by Twinky
A simple test for this would be to have a Rogue CoS and test, then the same with evasion up. I know hits and resists are subject to change in pvp but it should give you an answer as to what kinda of hit system the judgement uses.
|
Someone in this thread did 3 trials of that test. All 3 tests resulted in a hit. The chances of those results for an ability based on spell hit are somewhere around .1% to .01%.
|
I beleive, it would be as a hunter shot they cannot be dodged/parried but they are subject to block and miss (so perhaps a warrior/prot pally would be a better candidate for the melee hit test), but going by the available information in the WWS logs this also wouldn't seem likely, is it partially resistable?
|
It seems unlikely that JoB would block/miss. All of the Alliance damage judgements are hit/resist.
Partial resists would be a different can of worms than spell/melee hit. SoC and JoC can both be partially resisted, but one uses melee hit while the other uses spell hit.
That's a good question though - Does JoB have partial resists? If not, that sounds like the ability skips the resist check, much like debuff judgements.
|
If they both end up being in-conclusive as to what hit table or roll sysem it uses, then surely it must be a bug. (one i hope blizz never fixes)
|
Until it's changed, just accept it as a perk of being a BElf. = P