Originally Posted by Bluefish

I had no such issues on my alt using a 35/something/22 build. I OT'd an entire ZA run, sometimes tanking the first mob to be killed, and while it certainly wasn't full Prot, it was by no means *that* abysmal. I didn't try to MS every cooldown, I just used it to bleed off excess rage -- there's no including a 30-rage instant in your 6-second cycle unless you're tanking bosses.

Despite the name of this thread, I would definitely be pleased to see a "tanking as non-Prot" reference that I could read myself and point others to.