Originally Posted by Machinator
I have to agree that doing this defeats the whole purpose of the spreadsheet. If we know what items are better ahead of time we wouldnt need the sheet. All items that are reasonable for a warrior to have access to should be in the sheet. What is best in slot to one person is not to another so that is not a valid reason to not include any item.
|
I have to agree with all here. I was wrong and I apologize. Thats why we have the discussion. There are certain leather items that are not reasonable, however, we have all seen those and those are the ones that I will
NOT include in the sheet... Also, SEP values always change when you substitute gear, so one item at one point might not be better than one item at another point (might be an interesting theory to play with). Which is why we use the sheet, but DEFINATELY if anyone can say "hey this leather item will be reasonable for a fury warrior" using the method that I have displayed then it will be added within the day.
The reason we use spreadsheets is to be able to make careful decisions on gear setup, say if you were using a DKP system or some kind of system where you would be penalized for making an incorrect decision. We have all made bad decisions here and there, heck I had even done it months ago when I baught
[Onslaught Gauntlets] to upgrade
[Destroyer Gauntlets] instead of
[Grips of Silent Justice] allowing another DPS warrior to take
[Dreadboots of the Legion] over me, which happens to be the best upgrade I could get...
We dont use spreadsheets to know the obvious, like omg is
[Dreadboots of the Legion] better than
[Warboots of Obliteration]? But we do use it to know the no-so obvious like, are
[Nyn'jah's Tabi Boots] better than
[Warboots of Obliteration] with the correct gems?? By how much? Is double mongoose better than executioner and mongoose when I have 1350 ArP fighting a boss with 6600 armor and a set number of raid buffs? By how much? Do I want to wear a leather chest and lose 1300 armor to gain X theoretical DPS only when I am in a raid?