Originally Posted by Grizzly
A problem i didnt see mentioned would be the issue with people having to sitout raids.
In the current system you can award sitout DKP to appease those not able to actively get loot that day (or take into account their attendance for when they next raid in loot council). Whereas a full badge system means every raid you have to sitout means falling behind your peers.
This could lead to much more disgruntled players after being told to sitout and certain classes gearing up faster than others due to there being less competition for raid slots.
|
This issue already sort of exists, depending on the level you're raiding at. As a guild that's just pushing into 25-man content now, we constantly have to battle to keep people from getting too upset when we fill two Karazhan groups and there's still people sitting on the bench wanting to raid. There's really no elegant solution to the problem no matter how you drop the loot, because unless you have exactly 25 raiders that are always online at the exact same time every raid, someone is going to be left behind, and they are going to miss out on something.