Ondskaben

Looking at the WWS Skellionz posted it backs up what i was seeing (apart from a few extra wipes i didnt remember)

Crit rates:
B1-2: Fast wipe, not enough data (0 raid damage done / 330k raid damage done)
B3: steady 32% auto 46% (3.4M raid damage done)
B4: steady 25% auto 25% (2.7M raid damage done)
B5: steady 31% auto 20% (900k raid damage done)
B6: steady 22% auto 35% (3.4M raid damage done)
B7: steady 34% auto 28% (6.3M raid damage done)
B8: steady 29% auto 34% (4.4M raid damage done)
B9: steady 35% auto 29% (7.4M raid damage done)
B10: steady 38% auto 36% (7.4M raid damage done)
B-death: steady 34% auto 33% (10M raid damage done)

Average steady crit: 31.1%
Average auto crit: 31.7%
Expected average: ~41%

Same numbers for Ulgrag:
B1-2: (see above)
B3: steady 26% auto 30%
B4: steady 41% auto 26%
B5: steady 33% auto 18%
B6: steady 35% auto 35%
B7: steady 32% auto 31%
B8: steady 35% auto 39%
B9: steady 29% auto 30%
B10: steady 30% auto 30%
B-death: steady 36% auto 33%

Average steady crit: 33%
Average auto crit: 30.2%
Expected average: ~38% (as far as i remember asking him his buffed crit - he had LotP)

Ofcourse it might just be a very bad streak of RNG, but it does strike me as really odd.


Edit:
Looking at Gofa's WWS they certainly did not seem to have any crit issues.