Valendil

Did some limited testing last night and this morning:
Could not get any procs off of any reflective dam(BoSanc, Ret aura, Holy Shield, shield spike), tested 1 at a time with 6+ mobs beating on me for 5min for each ability.
As stated earlier, no procs off of consecration as well.
Couldn't get a proc off of Avengers Shield or Hammer of wrath either(only aprox 30 hits of each so not extensive testing, but would seem to indicate that if it can proc off of them its using the melee proc rate).

Tests done on lvl 64 humanoid mobs so no parries/dodges/misses:
Melee - Aprox 1000 hit test yielded nearly 4ppm while auto-attacking(no seals, no judgments, no haste effects).

Melee+Judgment of Righteousness - Aprox 600 hit test(judgments+melee hits) also yielded 4ppm, but confirmed that deathfrost will proc off of the judgment, but seems to be using the melee proc rate. Wasn't able to confirm ICD on judgment procs as that test would need to be done on undead/demon to see if exorcism would proc immediately after a JoR proc.

Pally talent 1h spec does increase the dam of the proc and zone wide buffs(for instance the +5% dam buff for controlling the pvp towers in terrokar) also increase the dam of the proc.