Originally Posted by kalbear

It's selfish one way or another, isn't it? The original suggestion was whether he should sit one feral druid or two. That's pretty selfish in favor of the warriors. I thought it only fair that the suggestion be made to sit one prot warrior or two, especially since the ferals shine in the Brutallus fight. If you're talking min-maxing I still believe two feral druids will do more damage than a war/druid will for tanking, even if some other dps warrior has to keep up tclap. This is based on experience in the game more than hard numbers, but talking with a fury warrior he estimated that it would hurt but not severely so. It probably isn't a huge difference - maybe a few hundred dps + whatever group buff the feral provides. But it is better. I wouldn't advocate it personally; I'd try and get everyone in if at all possible. But sometimes it's not, and it's better to down a boss while sitting some people than it is to not down a boss while pleasing everyone.