Elitist Jerks
Register
Blogs
Forums


Go Back   Elitist Jerks » Public Discussion

Closed Thread
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
Old 07/02/07, 11:51 PM   #151
 nivfreak
Too Serious
 
Tauren Warrior
 
Frostwolf
Ahhh, that makes perfect sense. Thanks for the clarification.

Offline
Old 07/03/07, 3:56 AM   #152
Quigon
Bald Bull
 
Quigon's Avatar
 
Tauren Warrior
 
Kil'Jaeden
I could be wrong but it says you only landed TC twice, and demo once. Maybe the wws is just completely wrong.
Still his mainhand attacks appear greatly sped up - are you sure you don't have pets/allies or some terribly unlucky parries in there? Numbers seem completely crazy... like crazy as azgalor parse that sebudai just posted.

You're taking almost twice the damage of some warriors that not only did phase 2 but killed the entire fight over a longer period. Your avoidance is really high 62.4%, but the incoming damage is severe. All I can guess is your armor is way too low (add ironshields, change your gear for more armor and less avoidance). Because while it is fantastic you dodged 10 things in a row, it is worthless, since as always (and very evident by this post) avoidance is worthless if you can't survive the worst case scenario.
If demo wasn't down, or tc, or ironshields, or another 1-2k in gear in armor... and you add that in, that 22k in damage shrinks magically down to maybe 14-15k. Plus I still think you had parries in there.

If you're going into a fight where the worst case scenario can kill you, you need to change something up; gambling isn't the way to go.

Offline
Old 07/03/07, 10:51 AM   #153
 nivfreak
Too Serious
 
Tauren Warrior
 
Frostwolf
Yea, Demo Shout and Thunder Clap were down when this happen. I was too focused on infernals and sheild block spam, and didn't renew them. I won't make that mistake again. Curse of Weakness had faded just before this as well.

My unbuffed armor is 14.5K, then add the stoneshield pot I had up, taking me to 16.5K, plus a bit of a boost from kings.

My pally healer respec'd for improved devotion aura, so I should get a nice armor boost from that the next time as well.

Offline
Old 07/03/07, 11:41 AM   #154
Mem
King Hippo
 
Mem's Avatar
 
Orc Shaman
 
Blackrock (EU)
I have taken the liberty to check your armory. Your gear is definitely on par with the one I wore when first killing the prince. Of course the streak you took was pretty tough. I think you can forego using Ironshields if you keep the debuffs up all the time during P2 which is imho a weak spot in your performance atm. However two ironshields for P2 have a great return on investment ( I see that you used stoneshields but I presume they were down as well, otherwise those hits would 've hit for less). Another hint: save your trinkets for P2 and pop them there preemptively. Also ask the shaman to drop a GoA totem, it might help as well (at least if your healer don't need the manareg from the shaman).

Also your healer should spamheal/abort their heals instead of reacting to damage. At least your priests only seems to react to damage which is a bad thing in a scenario like the prince fight. Finally i get the impression that your dps could and should improve a little bit. Your fight is taking too long and long fights just ask for desaster either due to burst damage in P2 or to faster spawning infernals in P3.

Offline
Old 07/03/07, 4:30 PM   #155
Silmeria
I am a nice guy
 
Silmeria's Avatar
 
Silmeriah
Blood Elf Paladin
 
No WoW Account
Don't bother with curse of weakness from the warlock if you're going to use demo shout, it doesn't stack generally, and it's a complete waste of the curse slot. Exceptions apply if the warlock is using improved CoW and you don't have improved demo shout.

On the other hand, if you can't keep demo shout up for whatever reason, it could probably be viable. But less than ideal.

United States Offline
Old 07/05/07, 10:50 AM   #156
Fellwraith
This ain't no place for a hero
 
Fellwraith's Avatar
 
Mulack
Orc Warrior
 
No WoW Account
Originally Posted by Mem View Post
Also ask the shaman to drop a GoA totem, it might help as well (at least if your healer don't need the manareg from the shaman).

Also your healer should spamheal/abort their heals instead of reacting to damage. At least your priests only seems to react to damage which is a bad thing in a scenario like the prince fight.
GOA is an air totem, it shouldn't have any impact on being able to drop mana tide or mana spring. It also adds a bit of AC in addition to the extra dodge. If you need some survivability, it's one of the better buffs to get (I generally prefer devotion aura, but we used both when I first tanked Maulgar in blues/kara gear).

One of the things I learned early in TBC raiding was that re-stacking my debuffs when they only had about 12 seconds left was very important. You don't want a resist at an inopportune time. Your survival is more important than threat generation - dps can always give you a second to catch up if it's absolutely necessary.

United States Online
Old 07/05/07, 11:10 AM   #157
snape
Great Tiger
 
snape's Avatar
 
Human Mage
 
Destromath
Originally Posted by nivfreak View Post
Yea, Demo Shout and Thunder Clap were down when this happen. I was too focused on infernals and sheild block spam, and didn't renew them. I won't make that mistake again. Curse of Weakness had faded just before this as well.

My unbuffed armor is 14.5K, then add the stoneshield pot I had up, taking me to 16.5K, plus a bit of a boost from kings.

My pally healer respec'd for improved devotion aura, so I should get a nice armor boost from that the next time as well.
You might want to try using Ironshield instead of Stoneshield - the mats are far easier to get (although the recipe isn't). You should almost always have Imp Devo, so it's a good thing he's respeccing for that (although I can't fathom why a healing Paladin wouldn't have it in the first place - unless he's fond of trying to go mid-tree Ret).

Offline
Old 07/05/07, 12:27 PM   #158
thaen
Von Kaiser
 
Blood Elf Paladin
 
Frostwolf
You might want to try using Ironshield instead of Stoneshield - the mats are far easier to get (although the recipe isn't). You should almost always have Imp Devo, so it's a good thing he's respeccing for that (although I can't fathom why a healing Paladin wouldn't have it in the first place - unless he's fond of trying to go mid-tree Ret).
He's actually had it for a while. What he didn't have was the 40-yard aura talent.

Offline
Old 07/06/07, 8:15 AM   #159
Mem
King Hippo
 
Mem's Avatar
 
Orc Shaman
 
Blackrock (EU)
Originally Posted by Fellwraith View Post
GOA is an air totem, it shouldn't have any impact on being able to drop mana tide or mana spring. It also adds a bit of AC in addition to the extra dodge. If you need some survivability, it's one of the better buffs to get (I generally prefer devotion aura, but we used both when I first tanked Maulgar in blues/kara gear).

One of the things I learned early in TBC raiding was that re-stacking my debuffs when they only had about 12 seconds left was very important. You don't want a resist at an inopportune time. Your survival is more important than threat generation - dps can always give you a second to catch up if it's absolutely necessary.

Agree on the latter point, check your debuffs regularly and also try to stagger them, if you have to reapply them, you don't want to loose both of them due to inopportune resists. Regarding the first point: yes, GoA is on another element but if the shaman is dropping GoA he will be moved from the caster/healer to the melee group which won't benefit from the mana gain.

Offline
Old 07/09/07, 6:58 PM   #160
Rinced
Von Kaiser
 
Troll Rogue
 
Alexstrasza (EU)
Parry & DW (Prince)

Recently i was healing with my twink in karazhan and our MT went down in less than 1 second (~15k dmg)
So I had a short look at the combat log and i found out that it seems like there are some sort of "double hits". First idea was, there must have been some parry … and I found a parry :

http://ace.pastey.net/70564

--> 7/10 00:05:19.667
--> 7/10 00:05:20.269
--> 7/10 00:05:22.807
--> 7/10 00:05:23.430

A few seconds later the tank is dead.

Yes of course, it might be a bug in the combatlog, but our MT was actually getting that dmg.

Looking in older looks I found more occurances :

http://ace.pastey.net/70565

--> 7/2 21:32:38.630


Then i found 2 parries in a row - and everything seemed to be normal again :

http://ace.pastey.net/70566

Only 1 parry & everything ok :

http://ace.pastey.net/70568


Now I can't find any good explanation for this … yes of course it might be just very bad luck … but I just pointed out a few examples … it actually happened several times.
Maybe someone can give an easy explanation. Otherwise Blizzard has another bug to fix.

Night 1: http://www.lossendil.com/wws/?report=qn3a1s4zanq3o
Night 2: http://www.lossendil.com/wws/?report=mxuft1ypprpim

Offline
Old 07/09/07, 7:09 PM   #161
Grayson Carlyle
Take what ye can;
 
Grayson Carlyle's Avatar
 
Tauren Warrior
 
Turalyon
Immediately after the last patch, my healers kept telling me that Prince was hitting a lot harder than before. We went from one-shotting to the tank dying in less than a span less than 2 seconds sometime during phase 2. It happened every fight we attempted. I was far more geared than our first Prince kills, so things should have been getting easier. When I went through the log, it was always the same thing: Double block followed by a double crush before my shield block was back up. Having never looked at Prince logs before, I figured him hitting twice with each attack was normal, I was just getting unlucky with him burning through shield block charges. Our solution was for me to drink an ironshield at the start of phase 2, but this only meant the spike damage was reduced to 13k instead of 15k (out of my 18k pool), not something I could've lived through when I was tanking at 15k buffed.

If this is a bug, and my healers are correct, then it's only new as of 2.1.2.

/ 人◕ ‿‿ ◕人 \

Canada Online
Old 07/09/07, 7:15 PM   #162
Bryne
The Treachery of Forums
 
Bryne's Avatar
 
Orc Warrior
 
Mal'Ganis
Is it just me, or are your combat logs all screwy and out of order? I'm not even sure what I'm looking at there.

Anyway, there's already a thread about this if you want to beat the horse further: Prince Tanking

Offline
Old 07/09/07, 7:22 PM   #163
Xerophyte
King Hippo
 
Xerophyte's Avatar
 
Awnh
Tauren Warrior
 
No WoW Account (EU)
Mallie does have a thrash ability in P2 which lets him randomly hit several times in a row, however that should show up in the combat log as "Prince Malchezaar gains 2 extra attacks through Thrash" followed by two melee hits a few milliseconds after. I'm not spotting that in your logs, but the simplest explanation is probably that you're just not logging mob buff gains for one reason or the other.

If you're sceptical about this thrash ability existing, see this random WWS log entry.

Sweden Offline
Old 07/10/07, 9:47 AM   #164
Rinced
Von Kaiser
 
Troll Rogue
 
Alexstrasza (EU)
Originally Posted by Xerophyte View Post
Mallie does have a thrash ability in P2 which lets him randomly hit several times in a row, however that should show up in the combat log as "Prince Malchezaar gains 2 extra attacks through Thrash" followed by two melee hits a few milliseconds after. I'm not spotting that in your logs, but the simplest explanation is probably that you're just not logging mob buff gains for one reason or the other.

If you're sceptical about this thrash ability existing, see this random WWS log entry.
Hmm where to enable this ? I have turned on all options in the combat-log chatframe.

Offline
Old 07/10/07, 10:45 AM   #165
Jarhead
Glass Joe
 
Human Warrior
 
Durotan
Originally Posted by bryne View Post
Anyway, there's already a thread about this if you want to beat the horse further: Prince Tanking
That's the thread you're posting in now, so all you did was link it back to itself. Did you mean to link a different one?

Offline
Old 07/10/07, 10:54 AM   #166
Jarhead
Glass Joe
 
Human Warrior
 
Durotan
Originally Posted by Rinced View Post
Hmm where to enable this ? I have turned on all options in the combat-log chatframe.
Was it possibly out of range of you? Have you set it to the max log range of 200?
The options/settings for the combat chatframe have no effect on the combatlog. Combatlog records everything you're in range of.

Offline
Old 07/10/07, 12:22 PM   #167
Rinced
Von Kaiser
 
Troll Rogue
 
Alexstrasza (EU)
Originally Posted by Jarhead View Post
Was it possibly out of range of you? Have you set it to the max log range of 200?
The options/settings for the combat chatframe have no effect on the combatlog. Combatlog records everything you're in range of.
Well i have AutoCL and Recount which are both set to max range - but actually in the config.wtf a range of 100 is indicated.

EDIT - my thread got merged into this one

Offline
Old 07/10/07, 1:14 PM   #168
Agren
Piston Honda
 
Agren's Avatar
 
Dwarf Warrior
 
Gorgonnash
Originally Posted by Jarhead View Post
Was it possibly out of range of you? Have you set it to the max log range of 200?
The options/settings for the combat chatframe have no effect on the combatlog. Combatlog records everything you're in range of.
Boss buffs and debuffs are not affected by any of the known combat log range settings, so you won't see the thrash line if you are out of the normal limited range (40 yards I think).

Offline
Old 07/10/07, 3:27 PM   #169
Jarhead
Glass Joe
 
Human Warrior
 
Durotan
Originally Posted by Rinced View Post
Well i have AutoCL and Recount which are both set to max range - but actually in the config.wtf a range of 100 is indicated.
Some people in this thread: Getting the most out of WoW Web Stats
mentioned having problems with AutoCL not setting the range to 200, so they switched to LoggerHead.
That thread also shows how to set the range in the config.wtf manually or via ingame commands/macro.

Offline
Old 07/10/07, 6:04 PM   #170
Jokie
Piston Honda
 
Jokie's Avatar
 
Tauren Shaman
 
Gurubashi
Originally Posted by vorda View Post
Both the pala spamming FoL and the shaman using low ranked LHW wont work in p2 either. Get one of them (actually, I'd just ask both) to use HL/HW. They had a shadowpriest so mana shouldnt be an issue.

<clip>

You died because your healers didnt output enough HPS during p2 to cover spikes. I remember chaincasting 3k+ heals in p2 back when we were learning prince.
As a paladin healing Prince I agree 100% with this statement. I learned to chaincast downranked Holy Light 7 to keep the tank up during prince with some max-ranked Holy Lights when needed. Of course, I also have another healing pumping similar heals into the tank as well and we seem to do fine (one-shots mixed with some multi-attempts here and there).

Offline
Old 11/16/07, 6:05 AM   #171
Krieger_Ho
Glass Joe
 
Blood Elf Priest
 
Tichondrius (EU)
Question about parry against mob

I have a question about parry. Maybe it fits not perfektly in this thread. But i do not have posting priviledges for new threads. Don´t know with whom i have to go to bed to get this priviledge.^^

The chance that a boss parries ist always quoted to be 5% + 0.2 per level.
I looked at some WWS-parses. For example one of yours:

Click Me...

this is a Mororgrim-fight. Why is Morogrim parrying more often. About 10-15 percent. (I only looked at the parrys against Paches - not the ones when Moro turns around to do his water graves).
We first thought about Moro as a dualwielder parrying ´with both hands 5,6% *2 =11,2%^^
don´t know if this is accurate. Any ideas?
I saw similar parses from Bosses like Gorefiend, Leotheras, ....

sry for english grammar mistakes I´am not a native speaker.

Thanks in advance.

Offline
Closed Thread

Go Back   Elitist Jerks » Public Discussion

Thread Tools

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
[Tanking] Java Tanking Simulator Twid Class Mechanics 12 05/08/07 5:50 AM
Prince Malchezaar and Blizzard's random encounters Vazu Public Discussion 51 02/28/07 10:46 AM
TBC Tanking Movies - Druid Tanking by Athinira Athinira Public Discussion 139 02/05/07 11:14 AM