 |
02/05/08, 7:15 PM
|
#496
|
|
King Hippo
Blood Elf Hunter
Mal'Ganis
|
Originally Posted by Brakar
Are you referring to S1 in pve gear? It's wildly different now, and you very much can and will get gibbed w/o decent pvp gear, even at the 1500 level now. There are enough people that saved for a season to get a s2 weapon or what have you it's horrendous w/o a decent amount of resilience and stam.
|
My 30 resil, 9k hp hunter alt is sitting at 1564 rating in 2's, on a relatively large battlegroup, with a fire mage for a partner, on her first week of arena. Five of our losses were to outgearing by SL/SL warlocks. I am by no means an amazing PvPer, but those of you whining that you're completely nonviable in arenas without 150+ resil really need to consider what else you're doing wrong.
That said, the current PvP grind is stupendous - I can't take grinding over 1k honor a day, so being able to sub in the blue PvP pieces until I slowly gear up via a mix of arenas and casual BGing is a great design decision, and it'll certainly help with being stunlocked 100-0 by rogues with s1 maces.
On another note, has it been specified which pieces are available for purchase? If I'm not crazy, there was a blue neck and ring in s1 as well, so if those are buyable, that'd bump up available PvP gear still further.
|
|
|
|
|
02/05/08, 7:43 PM
|
#497
|
|
Von Kaiser
|
Originally Posted by Taantric
Most of you are looking at this from a jaded prespective of having BT/HY level gear for your main character or spec and see this as an easy way to experiment with a off-spec or gear an alt. But for a vast majority of the playerbase which also happens to be casual, the grind for honor gear remains the worst grind in the history of MMO's. Of all the mind-numbing, soul crushing, tedious grinds the blizzards devs have thought up, the honor grind is the king of them all. And the simple fact is that this HWL gear off rep vendors does nothing to allievate the pain.
|
I have to completely disagree that the honor grind is the hardest grind. In no way does it compare to grinding in EQ circa planes of power, but more on topic it also doesn't even compare to the badge of justice/heroic/kara grind with a guild that is actually working progression in kara. On my mage I was grinding rep for scryer, rep for shat'ar, rep for thrallmar, grinding cloth, cash and primals for tailored gear, grinding badges in heroics, hoping for random drops in kara and heroics. It took me much more than 3 days played to get to my current standard of gear which still has room for improvement in PvE as a casual (kara/ZA geared).
My Rogue alt as he levels will have a much easier time of it as when he runs kara he will be grabbing upgrades after upgrade to prevent sharding of loot. But that is not how most people see Kara, they see it during progression with their guild of choice.
I look at the Honor grind and it doesn't seem so horrible, especially with the new changes coming to HK DR. I get 1 or 2 honor pieces a week via honor on my collection of toons, and I don't grind every day. Every single piece has made a difference in my pvp experience. It just doesn't feel horrible to me. Also the HWL gear will make a difference in the quality of the PvP experience prior to picking up of S1 gear. That is a real difference, it is the difference between getting steamrolled and fighting a good fight before dying.
|
|
|
|
|
02/05/08, 8:16 PM
|
#498
|
|
Bald Bull
|
Originally Posted by Nisu
My 30 resil, 9k hp hunter alt is sitting at 1564 rating in 2's, on a relatively large battlegroup, with a fire mage for a partner, on her first week of arena. Five of our losses were to outgearing by SL/SL warlocks. I am by no means an amazing PvPer, but those of you whining that you're completely nonviable in arenas without 150+ resil really need to consider what else you're doing wrong.
That said, the current PvP grind is stupendous - I can't take grinding over 1k honor a day, so being able to sub in the blue PvP pieces until I slowly gear up via a mix of arenas and casual BGing is a great design decision, and it'll certainly help with being stunlocked 100-0 by rogues with s1 maces.
On another note, has it been specified which pieces are available for purchase? If I'm not crazy, there was a blue neck and ring in s1 as well, so if those are buyable, that'd bump up available PvP gear still further.
|
People need to stop bringing up andedoctal evidence about their experience at low resilence levels. Even the slowest player in the world can work out that some classes have escapes/immunities from damage while others have to tank it.
|
|
|
|
02/05/08, 8:48 PM
|
#499
|
|
Bald Bull
Undead Death Knight
Twisting Nether (EU)
|
Originally Posted by panny
People need to stop bringing up andedoctal evidence about their experience at low resilence levels. Even the slowest player in the world can work out that some classes have escapes/immunities from damage while others have to tank it.
|
That and battlegroup level vary a lot, and you might end up facing not so good pvpers, or people who don't care because they're in the 1400rating 10games a week thingie, and so on and on. The fact is, if you have crap for resilience, there's good chances you're going to get your ass handed to you for a decent amount of time while you get your gear.
Farming honor is rather fast, but extremly boring and annoying. You're forced to do BGs for marks even tho they're extremly inneficient in terms of honor(WSG pugs mainly, but AB or EoTS can be pretty bad too), and then you're "forced" to do the same old AV for honor, which barely involves any pvp to win anyway. Easier to get gear, or at least gear you can acquire solo, or while doing something else, is a good step in the right direction in my opinion. Sometimes, you just don't want to do AV, and playing more arenas won't get you more points once you hit your "cap" for your gear/composition.
|
|
|
|
|
02/05/08, 9:03 PM
|
#500
|
|
Soda Popinski
Tauren Druid
Twisting Nether (EU)
|
|
Originally Posted by Bornakk
While we have had a lot of exciting information to share in the last week, not everything is ready right now and we don't plan to rush into things like class changes that people keep bringing up. When we have more we'll share it.
|
That quote is *potentially* dishearteningly depressing, I'm really hating the over-large patches with so many changes that it takes forever to adapt, amend and quantify them all to allow it even on to the PTR which is likely to take atleast a month of testing to release onto live servers.
|
|
|
|
|
02/05/08, 9:45 PM
|
#501
|
|
Von Kaiser
Night Elf Warrior
Earthen Ring (EU)
|
Originally Posted by vorda
Are you seriously responding negativly to such a possible gold cow (in your case)?
edit: something like: /dnd I have the !craft addon, standing infront of org/SW mailbox. Trade me with your gem +10 gold and whisper me what cut you want.
could earn you tons of gold if you really are one of the only ones with those designs.
|
I don't play much apart from raiding and grinding for raiding. Having half the world say "Hey, I'd really need a gem cut, can I come to you?" would just eat up all my time or bloat my ignore list. I already spend upwards of 30min / day handling gems as it is. Maybe someone else would enjoy being a 24/7 JC bot earning a lot of money, but it could become quite silly with so few people / server who can cut epic gems.
Anyways, I'd be very very surprised if anything like that is what we will see. Isn't the whole idea of epic gems being widely available based mostly on the assumption Blizzard words everything they post ultra-accurately?
|
|
|
|
|
02/05/08, 9:55 PM
|
#502
|
|
Bald Bull
Blood Elf Paladin
Echo Isles
|
|
I highly question anyone's knowledge of their class and gearing choices if they wasted honor that could be put towards vindicator and/or season 1 pieces but opted for HWL out of impatience. You clearly are offended by that because you took that as my main point when it is not and I addressed that already.
|
As I understand it, this will never happen: HWL gear being put on reputation vendors will most likely mean that they will cost gold instead of honor, provided you meet the reputation levels.
Ergo, there's no honor being wasted.
Even then, you can question someone's gear choices all you want, no one is putting a gun to your head and forcing you to buy this readily available gear.
As someone who cannot be arsed to grind up some 100k honor for a Ret set that I'd just use to have some fun on off-days, I'm welcoming this with open arms. Non-zero resilience is always better than zero resilience.
|
Most will still be honor grinding for S1/S2 with the possible availabilty of HWL to fill holes as a mere perk.
|
That's exactly the point. Say they put HWL shoulders buyable for 20g from the Scryer/Aldor quartermaster at Exalted. Now, you're going to have to do the Exalted grind anyway for your shoulder enchant.
Then, say they put the HWL helm (for casters) buyable for 30g from the Sha'tar quartermaster at Revered. You're going to have to do the Revered grind anyway for your caster head enchant. The same thing would apply for the HWL Warrior helm being buyable from Cenarion Expedition Revered.
So, given that you know that you can buy a PvP helm and shoulders from reps that you cannot avoid grinding for regardless of the HWL availability, what would be the first thing you might consider spending honor on? S1 Chest, pants or gloves. Personally, I'd grab the gloves first for the glove bonus, since even the pants (and a belt) can be acquired from one night of Halaa PvP.
Depending on how Blizzard structures the availability, it will be a perk, a great perk, for something that you would have to do anyway.
|
If it really matters how accessible HWL gear is where has the outcry been for the past year? I haven't seen one thread, post, PM here, official WoW forums, or anywhere else complaining that they want HWL gear but it's too expensive. Not a single one.
|
If you check the "How to make BGs fun" thread in the PvP forums, there has been a lot of support for giving people a free set of PvP gear as soon as they hit 70. In fact, I wouldn't be surprised if Blizzard got the idea from there (not necessarily free, but much easier to acquire nonetheless).
And no, you haven't seen a massive outcry on the WoW forums about the exorbitant cost of HWL gear because HWL gear is not buyable anymore. Instead, there has been a massive outcry about the exorbitant cost of S1 gear, which is the new baseline.
I guarantee that if S3 came out without making S1 buyable through honor, that the outcry would have directed to HWL gear instead, in much larger volume and with much more vehemence;
Instead of:
"200k honor for 5/5 S1 and full Vindicator's is a soul-sucking grind that makes me want to destroy my eyes with an icepick"
We would get:
"Why is Blizzard making me do a 200k honor grind for ilevel 115 blues that will still get me instagibbed against a Vengeful Gladiator anyway?"
|
OK so 2.4 hits, everyone and his mom goes and buys HWL gear. Then what? Back to the thread mill for S1/Vindcator's gear. You are still looking at 270000+ honor to gear up two seasons below the best arena geared people. 270000+ honor from the same fucking 4 BG's over and over and over and over and over and over and over.
|
Except you won't be PvPing with the fresh 70 Mage with full (and I mean full) greens, 6k HP and literally gets cleaved in half by a single autoattack and one MS. Part of the irritation in BGs comes from having to play with people who are drastically undergeared for their role. The other part comes from finally hitting 70 and experiencing that undergearedness yourself. This change alleviates that.
On a final note, I can't believe people are railing against getting free stuff.
|
|
|
|
02/05/08, 10:26 PM
|
#503
|
|
Bald Bull
Night Elf Druid
Tichondrius
|
Originally Posted by Nuveena
Anyways, I'd be very very surprised if anything like that is what we will see. Isn't the whole idea of epic gems being widely available based mostly on the assumption Blizzard words everything they post ultra-accurately?
|
It's from http://elitistjerks.com/623372-post258.html which is a complete rumor. There are a few guilds on Tichondrius with strong Blizzard connections. I know of at least one instance of a leak coming from one of them, so there's enough credibility to take it seriously. Not enough though to be anything but idle speculation.
|
|
|
|
|
02/06/08, 12:01 AM
|
#504
|
|
Von Kaiser
|
Originally Posted by Prinsesa
On a final note, I can't believe people are railing against getting free stuff.
|
Could it be because we are intelligent people who realize that this is worthless tweak whose value will be zero exactly one second after players get their HWL gear and go "now what"? With the extent of mudflation in TBC HWL gear is a joke and a poor one at that.
Also we don't know how much rep is required for these, so stop with all "free stuff" phrases. Did you(?) or someone else say in their post something about exalted rep for these? If they put in Exalted requirement for HWL gear then I KNOW that the devs are just laughing their ass off at the playerbase.
|
|
|
|
|
02/06/08, 12:12 AM
|
#505
|
|
unique snowflake
Blood Elf Paladin
Frostmourne
|
Originally Posted by Taantric
Could it be because we are intelligent people who realize that this is worthless tweak whose value will be zero exactly one second after players get their HWL gear and go "now what"? With the extent of mudflation in TBC HWL gear is a joke and a poor one at that.
Also we don't know how much rep is required for these, so stop with all "free stuff" phrases. Did you(?) or someone else say in their post something about exalted rep for these? If they put in Exalted requirement for HWL gear then I KNOW that the devs are just laughing their ass off at the playerbase.
|
The HWL gear will have a bit of worth to a small portion of the playerbase. In particular, those who want to do casual arena, but not grind a million years of honour. It will also help those looking to grind the honour, making it somewhat more enjoyable to start with (though the fact that they will grind it anyway kinda makes this not so significant).
I hope that they itemize boots/bracers/belt/rings/etc. via this method as well. If they do this, then I personally could gain 100+ resilience. A 100 resilience increase, to me, would be the difference between 1450 and 1550. Sure, it isnt going to get me much further than that, but a potential boost is a potential boost.
If it is exalted though, that would be crazy. If I were blizz, I would be putting 5 pieces each on different vendors at honoured (boots/belt/bracers/gloves/offhands&jewlery) and 5 more at revered (weapons/head/chest/legs/shouders).
|
|
|
|
|
02/06/08, 1:56 AM
|
#506
|
|
Piston Honda
Human Priest
Lightbringer
|
It's difficult for me to see how putting blue PvP gear on rep vendors can be criticized; the worst thing I think you can legitimately say is "nice idea but it won't be effective", and we won't know THAT until we see stats, price, and rep requirements.
There has been a huge amount of complaining over the "bootstrap" needed to become competitive in arenas. Again and again we've seen people suggest that what is needed is gear that is much more obtainable than S1 (that is, without the mind numbing BG grind). Unstated - but implicit in the suggestions - is that the gear wouldn't be as good as S1. (Although once S4 starts, I could see S1 gear on rep vendors - but it'd almost have to require exalted then. That won't help rerolls looking for a "starter kit" for arenas.)
In short, the announced change is exactly what multiple threads on EJ and other forums have been asking for. And the response is... "Nobody will want this." Um, sorry, you couldn't be more wrong. (And no, arguing that you meant the current blue honor gear costs too much honor doesn't help, since nobody else is even talking about the 2.3 solution.)
|
|
|
|
|
02/06/08, 2:08 AM
|
#507
|
|
Bald Bull
Blood Elf Paladin
Echo Isles
|
|
Could it be because we are intelligent people who realize that this is worthless tweak whose value will be zero exactly one second after players get their HWL gear and go "now what"? With the extent of mudflation in TBC HWL gear is a joke and a poor one at that.
|
There are no decent non-raid/non-heroic plate healing shoulders outside of the HWL gear.
There are no non-raid/non-heroic 2.60 speed Shaman off-hands.
A 93.2 DPS HWL weapon is still better than a Crystalforged War Axe.
There are quite a few more examples out there, depending on the kind of rep needed, such as the HWL's Shiv (1.40 speed dagger offhand).
|
Did you(?) or someone else say in their post something about exalted rep for these? If they put in Exalted requirement for HWL gear then I KNOW that the devs are just laughing their ass off at the playerbase.
|
Yes, I did mention Exalted rep, although that was pure speculation on my part.
My point was that even Scryer/Aldor Exalted would be perfectly acceptable given how any serious player would still grind that out for his shoulder enchant.
Revered would probably be fine and dandy with most people: Either it's something like Cenarion Expedition/Thrallmar where you'll need a head enchant anyway or it's something like Mag'har/Consortium that can be grinded solo.
|
If I were blizz, I would be putting 5 pieces each on different vendors at honoured (boots/belt/bracers/gloves/offhands&jewlery)
|
I think it's worth noting that there are no "blue" PvP belts/boots/bracers - those are actually the Marshal/General's gear, and it's doubtful that they'd be included since they're ilevel 123 epics.
I'm with you in hoping that the blue jewelry gets included too though.
Last edited by Prinsesa : 02/06/08 at 2:09 AM.
Reason: Spelling
|
|
|
|
02/06/08, 4:57 AM
|
#508
|
|
Mr. Sandman
Night Elf Druid
Argent Dawn (EU)
|
Legendary Ranged Weapon from Sunwell confirmed by a French rep to be a drop like Warglaives as opposed to quest based like Atiesh or Thunderfury. I'm a little dissappointed at that, once more we're thrown at the mercy of the RNG.
|
A few more details on this legendary weapon : it will be a loot like the Warglaives of Azzinoth, not a reward from a quest like Thunderfury.
|
Forums de wow-europe.com -> Arme Ã* distance légendaire (in french)
Last edited by Vaccine : 02/06/08 at 5:36 AM.
|
|
|
|
|
02/06/08, 5:05 AM
|
#509
|
|
Don Flamenco
Human Hunter
The Maelstrom (EU)
|
Originally Posted by Vaccine
Legendary Bow from Sunwell confirmed by a French rep to be a drop like Warglaives as opposed to quest based like Atiesh or Thunderfury. I'm a little dissappointed at that, once more we're thrown at the mercy of the RNG.
Forums de wow-europe.com -> Arme Ã* distance légendaire (in french)
|
And here I was hoping for a Rhok'delar-esque questline. 
|
|
|
|
|
02/06/08, 5:09 AM
|
#510
|
|
Von Kaiser
|
Originally Posted by Vaccine
Legendary Bow from Sunwell confirmed by a French rep to be a drop like Warglaives as opposed to quest based like Atiesh or Thunderfury. I'm a little dissappointed at that, once more we're thrown at the mercy of the RNG.
Forums de wow-europe.com -> Arme �* distance légendaire (in french)
|
Figured blizzard would learn their lesson, its a shame when guilds such as Nihilum face the wrath of RNG when they deserve warglaives more then any guild out there. Maybe Im bitter as well because weve only seen 1 in 23 kills, however its a horrible mechanic to have items that are that powerful be on a random loot table. A pair of warglaives adds around 200 personal dps, thats a pretty decent advantage going into new content with say a couple pairs in your raid, adding to the already horrible rng of getting the 1 or 2 offsets you need out of BT... 40+ najentus kills and weve seen 1 halbred, 30 something archimonde kills and we have never gotten the healing staff.. the drop mechanics are way to random.
|
|
|
|
|
|