I just downloaded Rawr v2.1.2 again and remade my character from scratch, damn you armory for being down! And _again_ I'm seeing aged winter cloak far ahead. 219.98 dps vs 173.56 for Drape of the Deadly Foe.
I ran "Update item cache" and "Reload known wotlk items from wowhead", which took ages btw and the problem still persisted. I then tried right clicking and "Refresh item data from wowhead" and then finally, what did work, was right clicking and "refresh item data from armory" and it snapped into place where it belongs, I hope, right after Cloak of Mastery.
Now the funny thing is, if I update it from wowhead again it hops back into first place and back down when I update from armory. Nothing even changes with the tooltip. Strange and somewhat disturbing.
I just found another item that shows the same problem. Depraved Linked Belt
