 |
08/17/09, 11:08 PM
|
#4711
|
|
Von Kaiser
Tauren Druid
Lightning's Blade
|
Maybe Blizz could solve the phasing problem by making the group leader's phase be the dominant one. So, simply stated, a higher level character could go back to the old style phased zones as long as the lower level character was the group leader.
|
|
|
|
|
08/17/09, 11:27 PM
|
#4712
|
|
Von Kaiser
|
The problem I see with phasing is the way it's implemented at the moment, it never changes the actual terrain of an area - just the npcs and objects scattered about (note that buildings, fences, etc are all objects). In order for this idea to have any success at all, their phasing would have to allow for terrain changes - hills to rise where there were none, and obviously rivers / oceans / etc to form new dips and gorges. While it's certainly possible that they've included changing terrain into the phasing engine, it seems like it would create a ton of coding problems for them.
Seems much more likely to me that if the world does suffer some massive devastation, that it'd be as completely new zones. The problem with this theory is size, I don't see them being able to fit both continents (and a few new islands/areas such as Gilneas) into the ~10 or so zones an expansion gets. This also solves the "I want to help my level 3 friend in a zone that's totally changed for me" problem, there could be portals in Stormwind or CoT or wherever to the world "before" the cataclysm, and then portals back to the destroyed world.
|
Eek, Shaman
|
|
|
08/17/09, 11:28 PM
|
#4713
|
|
Von Kaiser
Night Elf Hunter
Runetotem
|
I doubt we're going to see Wrynn develop any more. All his development is in the comic, he pretty much is who he is, though I wouldn't put him doing something awesome to make the Alliance players like him more out of the question.
As far as Garrosh, I think you people are too short-sighted. It is unlikely that he is as developed as he is going to be. Blizzard has specifically been working towards making you disagree with Garrosh and hate him. Why else would they take such incredibly popular characters as Saurfang and Thrall and put them at odds with him? Why would they make all of his judgments be so obviously flawed in reasoning? You're not supposed to like him...yet.
Unless Blizzard are complete idiots at writing a story, I'm almost positive that in Icecrown Garrosh will get some redemption. He is going to do something totally awesome that will make the player-base think that he rocks. He is going to, in some way, prove that he is a strong-enough leader to bring the horde to victory. At the same time, however, what he does will not in any way change his opinion of the Alliance. Perhaps his further development will make him hate the Alliance even worse, even if he grows to become less brash and stronger and wiser as a result.
No matter what happens, you guys need to look at the long run. I think Blizzard has every intention of developing these characters further, even if they're going to be dicks that you hate in the short term.
|
|
|
|
|
08/17/09, 11:32 PM
|
#4714
|
|
Don Flamenco
|
What phasing problem?
The constant discussion on the limitations of a phased old/new Azeroth is kinda redundant. The leak explicitly stated that the entire world would be transformed for all players, low levels included. Do not expect lower levels to be separated by phasing.
|
Half the point of Cataclysm is to remake the old quest lines, eliminate redundancy and give an overall narrative to all players, whether level 1 or 80.
|
|
|
|
|
|
08/17/09, 11:42 PM
|
#4715
|
|
Piston Honda
|
Dollars to pesos that if the leak is true, then Thrall/Jaina/Malfurion will become a neutral faction in the vein of the Argent Dawn.
One of the complaints many people always had was "It's world of WARcraft!!! lololol111!!!111". Obviously if you pay an iota of attention to the game, then it's quite clear that Thrall is rather level headed and wise. All out war wouldn't happen because Thrall -knows- all out war is self-defeating. He's a good leader, whereas Varion is a hothead who would end up destroying his kingdom rather then join with horde to combat a shared threat.
By removing Thrall from the leadership position and putting him in a place of power that has greater meaning (ie, keep the great buried evil in check), it makes it easier for Blizzard to explain why Horde vs. Alliance fighting keeps happening. Also bear in mind that the will of the people != the vision of the leader always. There could be alot of resentment. Look at the Theramore quests where you deal with the guys trying to stir the pot of racial hatred. I'm sure the same happens in the Horde.
|
|
|
|
|
08/18/09, 12:26 AM
|
#4716
|
|
Piston Honda
|
Originally Posted by Cybsled
One of the complaints many people always had was "It's world of WARcraft!!! lololol111!!!111". Obviously if you pay an iota of attention to the game, then it's quite clear that Thrall is rather level headed and wise. All out war wouldn't happen because Thrall -knows- all out war is self-defeating. He's a good leader, whereas Varion is a hothead who would end up destroying his kingdom rather then join with horde to combat a shared threat.
By removing Thrall from the leadership position and putting him in a place of power that has greater meaning (ie, keep the great buried evil in check), it makes it easier for Blizzard to explain why Horde vs. Alliance fighting keeps happening.
|
That's the problem though, without the background / explanation, there's an apparent contradiction (and there might still be one after we've heard why). "Thrall is wise and wants peace" does not work well with "Thrall appoints a warmonger to replace him". The (out-of-game) justification that there needs to be friction and conflict between the Horde and Alliance is a good one, but the leaked lore is weak. Again, it might all change once we know more.
|
|
|
|
|
08/18/09, 12:38 AM
|
#4717
|
|
Von Kaiser
Tauren Druid
Lightning's Blade
|
Originally Posted by Tyrian
An overlayed image of what the speculated post-cataclysm Kalimdor continents shape is.

|
Wow, thanks for the overlay! Looks like Silithus, Desolace, the Barrens, Mulgore, Dustwallow, Westfall, and Durotar get it the worst. There even seems like there's a bit of Icecrown taken off if the map is correct. Of particular note is how there's a tiny island at the southern point of Kalimdor right where AQ would be. Also, it would appear that the island in the middle of the Barrens would be pretty much exactly where Wailing Caverns is, which gives a little credit to some of the "leaked" info about the area. I'm getting excited to hear about Blizzcon.
|
|
|
|
|
08/18/09, 12:46 AM
|
#4718
|
|
Von Kaiser
Tauren Druid
Lightning's Blade
|
Originally Posted by Kemortia
The problem I see with phasing is the way it's implemented at the moment, it never changes the actual terrain of an area - just the npcs and objects scattered about (note that buildings, fences, etc are all objects).
|
This isn't entirely true. If you do the Horde Wrathgate quest, you'll see that one of the tunnels leading to the other elevator is blocked by rubble and the elevator itself is missing. Both are terrain changes.
Although the portal idea is certainly interesting, too. Since Blizzard would have to more or less redo all of Azeroth for flying, they could leave the old version for the lowbies and only create the new version "post-Catacylsm". It would probably be less technologically demanding as well.
|
|
|
|
|
08/18/09, 1:08 AM
|
#4719
|
|
Great Tiger
Worgen Druid
Blade's Edge
|
Originally Posted by Wyldthang
Wow, thanks for the overlay! Looks like Silithus, Desolace, the Barrens, Mulgore, Dustwallow, Westfall, and Durotar get it the worst. There even seems like there's a bit of Icecrown taken off if the map is correct. Of particular note is how there's a tiny island at the southern point of Kalimdor right where AQ would be. Also, it would appear that the island in the middle of the Barrens would be pretty much exactly where Wailing Caverns is, which gives a little credit to some of the "leaked" info about the area. I'm getting excited to hear about Blizzcon.
|
If that map is a hint to whats to come then I don't think you should take the boundaries so literal (such as the Icecrown part you mentioned) since it is pretty clear it is done in a constellation type way and not how the coast would actually be. If the map isn't a hint then it probably was just done based on the original rough sketch map of Azeroth and other early Warcraft Azeroth maps that didn't include Silithus since I know a lot of early Kalimdor maps showed it similar to that.
Last edited by Leviathon : 08/18/09 at 1:18 AM.
|
|
|
|
|
08/18/09, 1:11 AM
|
#4720
|
|
Don Flamenco
Tauren Druid
Steamwheedle Cartel
|
Originally Posted by Wyldthang
This isn't entirely true. If you do the Horde Wrathgate quest, you'll see that one of the tunnels leading to the other elevator is blocked by rubble and the elevator itself is missing. Both are terrain changes
|
No, those are objects. The rubble is a unit (granted, not a targetable one) that's in that phase, and the elevator is one that is not. Kemortia's statement regarding the nature of phased areas is wholly accurate.
|
|
|
|
|
08/18/09, 1:16 AM
|
#4721
|
|
Von Kaiser
nil
Orc Paladin
No WoW Account
|

Originally Posted by Tyrian
A few more things we can connect based on recent speculation. Showing two of the relevant images from the BB (Thanks missiletoad and Viator). Some of this has been glossed over before, but here we go. One of Lokens engage quotes is
Loken: "My master has shown me the future, and you have no place in it. Azeroth will be reborn in darkness. Yogg-Saron shall be released! The Pantheon shall fall!"
The globe directly in front of Loken, in Halls of Lightning:
An overlayed image of what the speculated post-cataclysm Kalimdor continents shape is.
We've all seen the Globe in front of Loken before. Some astute players will have noticed that Kalimdor is drawn oddly. It's easy to assume that the artist who made the Globe didn't know what Kalimdor looked like, or was just enjoying some artistic freedom.
However, given that Loken says he has been shown the future, you can now speculate he means it literally. The future of post-cataclysmic Azeroth is right in front of him, and us! It might not really be an easter-egg that was dropped into Ulduar unrelated, it could indeed be Yogg-Saron showing Loken the future of Azeroth via that globe. We'll obviously find out more answers in a few days. But perhaps the Cataclysm indeed refers to the result of attempts to summon an old-god in the Maelstrom by Azshara/Deathwing, and Yogg-Saron was showing Loken the effect this will have on the world. (Would be ironic that Yogg-Saron had since been killed off by us though, before these events could transpire!)
|
I posted these maps I pulled from the data files on another forum. Guess they can be of use here.
..\Data\Lichking.MPQ - ..\World\Expansion02\Doodads\Ulduar\UL_Azeroth_Map.blp
..\Data\Lichking.MPQ - ..\World\Expansion02\Doodads\Ulduar\UL_Planet05.blp [90degree angle]
..\Data\Patch.MPQ - ..\World\Expansion02\Doodads\Ulduar\UL_WorldMap_01.blp
..\Data\Lichking.MPQ - ..\World\Expansion02\Doodads\Ulduar\UL_WorldMap_01.jpg
Side Notes: Lichking.MPQ has not been modified since the release of WoTLK.
Patch.MPQ is modified all the time with new patches.
50% Cross-Over Map

|
|
|
|
|
08/18/09, 2:27 AM
|
#4722
|
|
Chief Passenger
Gnome Rogue
Earthen Ring (EU)
|
Originally Posted by Cybsled
Dollars to pesos that if the leak is true, then Thrall/Jaina/Malfurion will become a neutral faction in the vein of the Argent Dawn.
|
Thought: if they were considering adding a third playable faction, then you'd have two necessary preconditions. Allowing faction transfer, and rearranging the old world quests to make stuff make sense again.
|
|
|
|
|
08/18/09, 2:43 AM
|
#4723
|
|
Von Kaiser
Tauren Warrior
Xavius (EU)
|
There will not be any phasing in Azeroth. Just remember while TBC was on, so many players were suggesting, asking for flying in Azeroth, and developers stated many, many times that it's impossible due technical limitations of old continents. If they are about to implement flying in old world - they will make completely new (old looking) landmass, but from scratch. And what's better chance to do that then Cataclysm.
Old maps and textures are really old and need "tuning and polishing", Blizzard is not going to invest time in all those maps all together in order to just refresh them. They will do it and we get new content!
|
|
|
|
|
08/18/09, 2:49 AM
|
#4724
|
|
Don Flamenco
|
Originally Posted by songster
Thought: if they were considering adding a third playable faction, then you'd have two necessary preconditions. Allowing faction transfer, and rearranging the old world quests to make stuff make sense again.
|
I don't think anyone's considering a third playable faction, at least not until WoW2 comes out and everyone starts again from scratch. For one, you have to make the factions equally desirable - in the current case, it's "equally lame" if the whole "Garrosh leads the Horde" thing pans out. For another, you have to balance the number of races in each faction, preferably without shattering existing organizations (that is guilds).
I suspect that in order to have three balanced playable factions in Warcraft, you will have to decouple the races from the factions. In WoW, however, the factions and races are very tightly intertwined... with the introduction of races like Space Goats, Blood/High Elves, Gobbos and Worgen, the bonds tying races to factions are weaker, but you're still left with the original eight races which are (mostly) tightly bound to their faction.
|
|
|
|
|
08/18/09, 2:51 AM
|
#4725
|
|
Mr. Sandman
Night Elf Druid
Argent Dawn (EU)
|
Originally Posted by Talanik
I can think of a logical explanation for all the new classes in the lore that fits, and I'm sure if I can do it, Blizzard has something even better planned out. I'm sure it will all be in time.
The only thing I can't comprehend is
A. Why Malfurion has the power to appoint a guardian of Tirisfal
B. Why Thrall would even consider leaving the Horde
C. Why he would leave it in the hands of Garrosh instead of anyone more able like Saurfang, Nazgrel, Drek'thar, Vol'jin, Rexxar, or Cairne.
|
Remember Nazgrel is a member of the Garosh school of (non) thought. Vol'jin wouldn't be a likely candidate as I think Trolls are too weak a part of the Horde to have that big a voice. Drek'thar and Saurfang would be good, Cairne would be good, Rexxar is probably too much of a loner to accept responsibility, if he'd be followed at all, I think the Mok'nathal are a bit of a taboo in amongst the Orcs.
Sylvannas would be a better candidate for a war hungry anti human leader. She has the brains that Garosh lacks, the restraint to not cause diplomatic outbursts, and the cunning and startegy to hurt the Alliance whilst appearing to be on speaking terms. Also the Forsaken have a much better infrastructure than the Trolls and a capital of their own, which is fairly easy to defend and likely away from flood risks.
Another candidate not discussed much because hes been mute in WoW is the Blood Elf leader, Lor'themar Theron. The Blood Elves have a great infrastructure and government compared to the other Horde factions. They are one of if not the most powerful faction due to having the only access to Paladins (so far) as well as being the most powerful magic users in general of the Horde races lore wise. He is trusted by Sylvannas, or at least used to be, has vast experience fighting the Scourge and Arthas. Being second in command to the Ranger General (Sylvannas) during the third war would have given him vast tactical expertise. If not Saurfang or Cairne, he is probably the best choice in my opinion.
As for Tauren philosophy, I don't think it has changed, if anything it is getting more peace loving. For example they successfully negotiated with Brann Bronzebeard that the Dwarven digging sites in Mulgore would be allowed to continue with the constant supervision of Tauren Shaman to see that the land was repaired afterwards. In exchange the Dwarves helped attack the Venture Co sites and remove them all from Mulgore.
Also as has been said before, their primary affiliation is to Thrall, not the Horde. If he goes playing Superman and leaves Garrosh in his stead, Cairne would not follow him. I suspect that is why he is being killed off, but indications short of a complete character rewrite show Baine the same as his father in that respect. The Tauren civilisation is still on the edge of extinction, they aren't going to throw themselves into a war for no reason. I suspect if it does go ahead, Cairne will be assassinated by the Grim Totem's to keep it in house (at the request of Garosh) but Baine doesn't make much sense, he clearly isn't a puppet to the Grim Totem.
I've been thinking about ways that they could make this right if it did go ahead. One would be a Garosh repents story line. Maybe he gets a visit from Ghost of Grom, or maybe he sees Saurfang die to save him in Icecrown. He could realise what a massive dick he was being in neglecting the finer sides of leadership whilst still maintaining his hate for the Alliance, especially if they are responsible for Saurfang's death.
Another one could be he continues his dickory and a story arc of some sort of resistance stemming in Thunder Bluff starts when it is discovered Cairne was assassinated. It is assumed that Baine takes over due to him being missing from the PTR, but what if he had gone into hiding? We already know that Magatha has ambitions for the leadership of the Tauren, perhaps she conspires with Garosh to kill Cairne and takes over the leadership, and Baine is misplaced with the Bloodhoof loyalists and the story arc is him and others attempting to remove Magatha from power, and eventually Garrosh. Magatha already has strong ties with the Forsaken herself, so they would not move to intervene, and the trolls are too powerless as a faction to do anything. The Blood Elves likely don't care considering their general attachment, and would likely back the Forsaken in this anyway. She has much the same goals as Garrosh and Sylvannas in that she wants the humans and alliance races (and eventually the other Horde races) wiped off the earth as "lesser" species. In the Horde players guide there is even a line of text "it is rumoured she is trying to kill Bloodhoof but currently she is not powerful enough". More I think about it the more I think this seems a possible route they are going to take.
|
|
|
|
|
|