Elitist Jerks
Register
Blogs
Forums


Go Back   Elitist Jerks » Public Discussion » Public Discussion

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
Old 08/16/10, 11:19 AM   #9421
Bierzkrieg
King Hippo
 
Orc Warrior
 
Burning Steppes (EU)
Fact is, Exemplar, if you try to draw an orc with only the tusks showing from the lower lip, it'll look odd. Really odd. The thing is, it forces the lower lip to make a sharp turn to cover the lower teeth. Or to draw them a lip the size of a bicep.

Although, Blizzard depicting orcs as mouth-breathers isn't far-fetched at all. Even though no artist draws the orcs in a hunched position (the WoW art book as a concept drawn that way and it looks absolutely hideous), Blizzard insists on making them hunched...they don't need to pose like elves, but give their necks a break (no pun intended).

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 08/16/10, 12:05 PM   #9422
Exemplar
Bald Bull
 
Human Paladin
 
Scarlet Crusade
Originally Posted by Bierzkrieg View Post
Fact is, Exemplar, if you try to draw an orc with only the tusks showing from the lower lip, it'll look odd. Really odd.
Well, to be frank, tusks sticking out of the lower lip are odd and would look odd. If you've ever seen someone wear something like that as a Halloween costume or perhaps in a movie - it looks odd (partially because the human lip isn't designed for the extra distance - someone with natural tusks would probably genetically have a longer lower lip or have "stretched" their lower lip over time). It should look odd, so if it looked odd - good.

Or have the minimized Orc Tusks within the lips, like most Vampires somehow hide the fangs. The upper teeth could be displaced to accept the tusks, they can fit between upper jaw and upper lip (with unsightly upper lip bulges that would look really bad in life, and in game), or they stick out oddly.

Trolls have huge rooting tusks, and in-game their mouths are sealed. One design of female troll has tiny stubs of tusks, not unlike Orcs. They're all designed with closed mouths.

As was pointed out, they keep minimizing Orc tusks. Go all the way and make them only show when the mouth opens. It's not like we'll suddenly fail to recognize them as an Orc without tiny tusks. A large part of a character's personality is expressed through their visual design. Closing the mouths of the intelligent would allow for actual slack-jawed daffodi... NPCs.

Rock: "We're sub-standard DPS. Nerf Paper, Scissors are fine."
Paper: "OMG, WTF, Scissors!"
Scissors: "Rock is OP and Paper are QQers. We need PvP buffs."

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 08/16/10, 12:30 PM   #9423
Bierzkrieg
King Hippo
 
Orc Warrior
 
Burning Steppes (EU)
I guess someone pointed out how awesome this was already, but here's proof that a closed mouth does indeed make for a better orc (being serious, here, he looks much more determined):



Although I find the tusks to be a little too thick and positioned to the sides of the mouth, this picture makes all the in-game model's awkwardness worth it - also, notice...no hunching posture.

Tauren, too, suffer a little from that. While I like the lump (it makes them look more menacing), I'd rather have their heads positioned a bit higher with a smaller lump, thus making more room for a larger chest.

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 08/16/10, 1:06 PM   #9424
Molakar
Von Kaiser
 
Orc Shaman
 
Tarren Mill (EU)
Where can I find info about Garrosh being older then Thrall? I'm not saying he isn't or that I don't believe you since it all makes sense when you think about it. Grom was around when Ner'zhul was cheftain of the Horde and he participated in the Second War, ofcourse his son would be atleast the same age as Thrall. I've just always pictured Garrosh as being younger then Thrall due to him being a hothead and giving an overall immature picture of himself while Thrall always seemed more mature and wiser.


Edit: Stupid me confused Grom Hellscream with Orgrim Doomhammer...

Last edited by Molakar : 08/16/10 at 1:15 PM.

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 08/16/10, 1:44 PM   #9425
Jackaran
Glass Joe
 
Jackaran's Avatar
 
Night Elf Druid
 
Lightninghoof
Reference: Light's Hope Chapel - WoWWiki - Your guide to the World of Warcraft


This is according to WoWwiki - which compiled data from WoW lore and the Comic mini-series 'World of Warcraft: Ashbringer.'

"Lord Maxwell Tyrosus takes Darion Mograine to the catacombs beneath and tells him the story of how, during Arthas's rampage through Lordaeron, Tyrosus and a few others were chosen for the secret task of unearthing the bodies of a thousand fallen heroes of the Light and bringing them to Light's Hope Chapel."

It further explains that the souls of the dead heroes buried beneath Lights hope chapel together their reckoning is so powerful that no force on Azeroth can with-stand it.

The Lich King remarks during the Battle of Light's hope chapel, claiming that there is nothing but hallow ground beneath the chapel.

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 08/16/10, 3:10 PM   #9426
Cireena
is about to die
 
Cireena's Avatar
 
Cireenah
Orc Death Knight
 
No WoW Account
Originally Posted by Molakar View Post
Where can I find info about Garrosh being older then Thrall?
This has been asked twice in the last day so just to put it to rest here it is. Garrosh was left with the Mag'har on dreanor when the Horde departed through the Dark Portal to Azeroth. Thrall was born 2 years after the Orcs invaded. this means Garrosh is no less than 2 years older than Thrall.

Originally Posted by Zyla View Post
Plus, my anus is painfree and still virginal!
Originally Posted by madsushi View Post
Honestly, if you're any good, then you know about the changes as soon as they happen and you adjust. If you're not any good, Blacksen's already benched you by now, and so who cares.

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 08/16/10, 7:09 PM   #9427
Leviathon
Great Tiger
 
Worgen Druid
 
Blade's Edge
Originally Posted by Cireena View Post
This has been asked twice in the last day so just to put it to rest here it is. Garrosh was left with the Mag'har on dreanor when the Horde departed through the Dark Portal to Azeroth. Thrall was born 2 years after the Orcs invaded. this means Garrosh is no less than 2 years older than Thrall.
Garrosh had to be bit older than that considering he was old enough to possibly fight when Kargath came to Garadar looking for help in Beyond the Dark Portal.

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 08/16/10, 8:51 PM   #9428
Bierzkrieg
King Hippo
 
Orc Warrior
 
Burning Steppes (EU)
Originally Posted by Leviathon View Post
Garrosh had to be bit older than that considering he was old enough to possibly fight when Kargath came to Garadar looking for help in Beyond the Dark Portal.
One more thing in favor of Orcs reaching maturity before Humans. Garrosh couldn't have been more than, let's say, 10 years old, by then. And I'm exaggerating, most likely. That he was deemed ready for war - even if Kargath was desperate, I don't think he'd take infants to battle.

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 08/16/10, 8:59 PM   #9429
Krixooks
Von Kaiser
 
Krixooks's Avatar
 
Gnome Warlock
 
Barthilas
Originally Posted by Bierzkrieg View Post
Draenosh was killed and ghoul-rezzed in Northrend, I was appointing Varok as the ruler of Garadar, in Outland. I mentioned Northrend because, like Outland, it's not - that we know - due for any major changes.

It should, really...Outland's the biggest pain of all the levelling experience, in my opinion.

I still have a bad feeling about Saurfang. I don't see him getting into a fight with Deathwing - although, that'd make him on par with his brother - and he's probably been turned into a hermit until we rouse him, but I still find this silence too ominous. I fear the day MMO-Champ will post "Saurfang's no more".
Yeah we haven't heard anything about Varok since his appearance in Icecrown Citadel...
A sensible place to put him next would definitely be in Nagrand, perhaps in Garadar or at the Ancestral Burial Grounds near Oshu'gun, as that would be a good place to send off Draenosh.
But I don't think they will.
Outland is in the "past" now. Blizzard are not going to remove questlines such as the Hero of the Mag'har one with Garrosh, it is far too plot-heavy and gameplay involved with the mini-cinematic and Thrall coming to Garadar. It would be like removing the Wrathgate questline from Northrend after Cataclysm hits.
They couldn't move Varok there because Garrosh and Draenosh are still there.

Almost because of this I think they will move Varok to somewhere in Azeroth, despite everything he's been through in Northrend, we don't really know what's happening in the pre-Cataclysm world event, maybe he fights Deathwing. His death would certainly incense the Horde players to renew their subscriptions so that they can avenge him.

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 08/17/10, 3:29 AM   #9430
Fnar
Piston Honda
 
Fnar's Avatar
 
Troll Rogue
 
Moonglade (EU)
Originally Posted by Vaccine View Post
I like the Thrall model. I guess Doomhammer's gear had to go because it is a huge symbol of the Alliance, and now he is moving to a neutral faction they wanted a similar look. For the aging, I just assumed it was the forces at work through him holding the Maelstrom apart. I mean when we talk about Thrall as a Shaman, he is so far above normal shaman it's not even a joke. He's basically the Neo of Shaman.

It would be cool to see Saurfang in Doomhammer's gear, but I think it will probably just disappear. I'd like if it was displayed in the throne room in Orgrimarr, just discretely in a corner on an armour tree as a constant reminder to Garrosh that one day Thrall will be back (although I don't actually believe he will be back). Is Saurfang still MIA on Beta? What zones are unfinished at the moment? I wonder if he is in one of those.
This always strikes me as odd.

The community seemingly has no issues with Thrall being the super magnificent uberest shamanator of all time. Rhonin and Malfurion on the other hand display an ounce of ability and they are being 'mary-sued'. I mean Thrall is just one in a long line of orc shaman going back probably as long ago as when oshugun first crashed on Draenor, Malfurion is the first ever druid, Cenarius' own protoge and is over ten thousand years old yet whenever he does something powerful he is 'super malfurion jesus superstar' and the community rolls it's eyes in dismay.

As for Rhonin, I don't even think he is considered to be a particularly gifted mage and most of his feats are borne from being supercharged by the well of eternity (War of Ancients trilogy) or he has a lot of help (Night and Day of the Dragon), he has never really done anything of real note in game but you could bet if he did then there would be a mini lore revolt.

It just grates on me that the wow lore community seems to accept great power and deeds without question from one character and meets it with indignation in the case of others.

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 08/17/10, 3:50 AM   #9431
Halibell
Von Kaiser
 
Halibell's Avatar
 
Blood Elf Paladin
 
Gorefiend
I think the reason people dislike Malfurion and Rhonin is because they were poorly written by Knaak who gave them ridiculous power-ups. Where as Thrall (thank god) hasn't been touched by him and gets written by Christie Golden in The Shattering. Also did you see what he did to Tyrande and Vareesa ='(

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 08/17/10, 4:53 AM   #9432
Bierzkrieg
King Hippo
 
Orc Warrior
 
Burning Steppes (EU)
Aye, and Malfurion is actually one of the most liked characters from his role in WC3. He was genuinely ingenious, back then. But in the War of the Ancients Trilogy, for example, you see him displaying the same nervousness about his enemies - coupled with insecurity about his own powers - but relying (every single time) on his seed pouch. He literally has a seed for every occasion.

Rhonin is akin. He had Day of the Dragon, in which he evaded/got lucky, most of the time. And it worked. We believed he was a competent mage, he was simply fighting too many and too powerful enemies. In WotA, his worst enemy ended up being his physique - he got tired (though he was also spell-smothered in one occasion). In Night of the Dragon, though no longer supercharged, he ended up cleaning house as well.

On Thrall, he thunderstruck down a Necropolis, wind-blew the others away, brought down a castle by doing a rain-dance, killed Varimathras (with help)...and yet, time and again, he's been powerless to stop tragedy from knocking at his door. Taretha got headless, Orgrim sacrificed himself without Thrall having made a dent to Magtheridon, Doomhammer was impaled, his rule - based on justice and being firm while peaceful - ended up being perceived as weak by a great deal of the warriors who probably fought by him in WC3 (and in the last few years). We know Thrall, between his combat and shamanistic training, could've ripped Garrosh in half - it might've even got him some respect from his detractors.

That, despite his power, reality still manages to punch Thrall in the gut time and again, is what makes him much more acceptable.

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 08/17/10, 10:06 AM   #9433
Kirion
Don Flamenco
 
Kirion's Avatar
 
Tauren Shaman
 
Deathwing (EU)
Originally Posted by Bierzkrieg View Post
Aye, and Malfurion is actually one of the most liked characters from his role in WC3. He was genuinely ingenious, back then. But in the War of the Ancients Trilogy, for example, you see him displaying the same nervousness about his enemies - coupled with insecurity about his own powers - but relying (every single time) on his seed pouch. He literally has a seed for every occasion.

Rhonin is akin. He had Day of the Dragon, in which he evaded/got lucky, most of the time. And it worked. We believed he was a competent mage, he was simply fighting too many and too powerful enemies. In WotA, his worst enemy ended up being his physique - he got tired (though he was also spell-smothered in one occasion). In Night of the Dragon, though no longer supercharged, he ended up cleaning house as well.

On Thrall, he thunderstruck down a Necropolis, wind-blew the others away, brought down a castle by doing a rain-dance, killed Varimathras (with help)...and yet, time and again, he's been powerless to stop tragedy from knocking at his door. Taretha got headless, Orgrim sacrificed himself without Thrall having made a dent to Magtheridon, Doomhammer was impaled, his rule - based on justice and being firm while peaceful - ended up being perceived as weak by a great deal of the warriors who probably fought by him in WC3 (and in the last few years). We know Thrall, between his combat and shamanistic training, could've ripped Garrosh in half - it might've even got him some respect from his detractors.

That, despite his power, reality still manages to punch Thrall in the gut time and again, is what makes him much more acceptable.

You surely meant Grom and Mannoroth.
Still Thrall's power is not that surprising. He was destined to became greatest shaman, stronger than Ner'zul. But his powers come from spirits and elements. Question is, how is he able to communicate with spirits with world in this state?

42.

Russia Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 08/17/10, 10:46 AM   #9434
Tinwhisker
Bald Bull
 
Tinwhisker's Avatar
 
Dwarf Rogue
 
Scarlet Crusade
Isn't a state of chaos pretty normal for the elements? More chaos might cause some interference with communication but it's not like the elements were at peace before Cataclysm.


United States Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 08/17/10, 11:01 AM   #9435
Bierzkrieg
King Hippo
 
Orc Warrior
 
Burning Steppes (EU)
Man, two lorefails in one setting...I'm getting better. Yep, Grom and Mannoroth.

@Kirion: I think the answer to that last question of yours lies in the fact that Thrall doesn't communicate with some elementals. Rather, he communes with the elements' higher consciences. The spirit of fire/water/earth/air/wilderness. As in, Fire/Water/Air/Earth/Wilderness itself.

These spirits' children are in disarray, but the spirits themselves have always existed between the two planes. You don't need an elemental crossing into Azeroth and going psycho to have a giant wave. Not even Neptulon. So the water spirit might be from the Elemental Plane, but it has always manifested itself in Azeroth.

Elements coexist in some sort of "round food-chain" order: fire consumes the wilderness, water consumes fire and rock, the wilderness consumes water, rock...well, rock is pretty much everywhere, it's the basis of the world. This is simplistic, of course, but it goes to show that while elementals' idea of "food chain" is to spank each other, the elements themselves don't necessarily like chaos and disorder. They strive for balance and reasonableness.

If memory serves, one of the things Drek'thar taught Thrall was that requesting aid from the elements required a purpose. Sure, you now have shamans everywhere asking for a thunderbolt to strike a gnome, but the elements are supposed to obey to the "everything has a purpose" rule. Thrall is an agent of order and purpose. The ideal agent, in fact.

The reasons for Thrall quitting from Warchief and being capable of using dragons as kites are one and the same: his good nature.

Edit: In any way, the matter of the elemental state-of-affairs has been discussed a few pages back.

Last edited by Bierzkrieg : 08/17/10 at 11:08 AM.

Offline
Reply With Quote
Reply

Go Back   Elitist Jerks » Public Discussion » Public Discussion

Thread Tools