Has anyone done the math on how this set along with the bonus stacks up to other Hunter weapon combos? We have a couple Hunter's wielding these on our raids, I'm assuming mostly for style. I'd like to see the math to back this set up.
I really don't mind them for average trash, but if it's really gimping DPS I'd much rather see them equipping different weapons in most cases.
Can't really back it up with math unless someone runs tests on how often it procs
However, I do know a rogue with this set, he says it procs pretty rarely, once every 4+ minutes, and if that's the case they won't be better than a MH Hakkari/Silithid Claw/FoF combo. It would need to proc at least once a minute to match the attack power off a SC/FoF combo, let alone the extra crit % (300*(12/60)= 60, the AP off SC/FoF is 58).
Yeah, pretty sure it's a flat 1% then you have +300 ATP for 12 seconds. The only other damage modifier for ranged is the 1% crit on Thekal's. So I suppose it'd vary for Huhuran's Stinger and the Xbow from BWL, but still it's probably no more than a toy.