 |
01/17/10, 11:26 AM
|
#301
|
|
Witch doctors park in gear
Cadfael
Worgen Priest
No WoW Account (EU)
|
Yes you can do this.
Not killing Putricide only prevents you to go to Arthas. Nothing else.
|
"Take the universe and grind it down to the finest powder and sieve it through with the finest sieve and then show me one atom of justice, one molecule of mercy. And yet you act as if there were some sort of rightness in the universe by which it may be judged."
- Discworld: Hogfather
|
|
|
01/17/10, 11:57 PM
|
#302
|
|
Glass Joe
|
Server culture seems to play heavily into it. Prices in Ner'zhul US have traditionally been fairly low compared to other high-pop servers. We had our first GDKP run on Sunday, and by every comparison here, the pot ended up small. Between Solace for 2.5k, the BOE Str ring for 3k, Dual-blade butcher for 4.2k, Reign of the Dead for 2k and all trophies for 600g each, the final pot ended up at exactly 22k. At such a number, I question its long-term viability here. It's possible there were too many raiders and not enough buyers though.
|
|
|
|
|
01/18/10, 10:40 AM
|
#303
|
|
Great Tiger
Worgen Priest
Ravencrest (EU)
|
Originally Posted by crimsona
Server culture seems to play heavily into it. Prices in Ner'zhul US have traditionally been fairly low compared to other high-pop servers. We had our first GDKP run on Sunday, and by every comparison here, the pot ended up small. Between Solace for 2.5k, the BOE Str ring for 3k, Dual-blade butcher for 4.2k, Reign of the Dead for 2k and all trophies for 600g each, the final pot ended up at exactly 22k. At such a number, I question its long-term viability here. It's possible there were too many raiders and not enough buyers though.
|
If all your prices are that low, a pot of almost 1k each will have a much larger relative value than a similar pot elsewhere.
It basically just means there's less gold in circulation on the server, which has caused less inflation. I wouldn't discount the potential of GDKP just because there are fewer zeroes in your figures.
|
|
|
|
|
01/18/10, 3:58 PM
|
#304
|
|
Bald Bull
|
I just noticed this site, which could be an interesting development for GDKP. Does anyone have any more information to shed?
GDKP RUN, Gold Run, Gold Pot, Cash Run:
It appears to be run with suspicious (possibly nefarious) motives. Despite taking most of the text straight from my OP to preface the website, it also has several points worthy of note:
- It mentions every server (from all realms) of both WoW and Aion
- It has a button for 'Live help'
- The text not directly copied from the OP uses somewhat broken English. (Eg: "As a buyer,you can inform us your need")
- It uses the words 'our business'
Basically it looks like a Gold Selling website, except setup for running GDKP raids. Buying gold itself is not mentioned at all. Everything might appear legitimate for now, but it could turn out quite sinister. Interesting text is:
GDKPRUNS has a team dedicated to offer professional service for game players around the world. In meeting the demand of game players to buy, sell and trade in-game items in raid, we are dedicated to improving gamer services and fostering a more enjoyable raiding experience.
We care about what you need and what you want. After registering on our site, we will help you schedule or join in a raid.All Our agents are all well trained and have good knowledge with game. They can also work as consultant when you have any problem in game. So don't hesitate to try our service and you will find out it is much more fun to shop at our site.
|
- Submit reports about the the GDKP raid including things like Drops and their transaction prices; Total revenue; How much gold split to every worker; who was absent
- You can ask some of your friends to go or recruit mercenaries from our platform.
Rewards:
- Raid leaders will get a credit after every successful raid
|
This is quite an interesting/disturbing development. It appears that a model is being set up which will 'run gdkp raids' like a cross realm/game business. Does anyone have more information on this website? Who it's registered to (and in what country). Obviously it's not a charity going by the business text, so people will naturally begin to wonder why exactly they are doing this - and how they would profit from it.
It would be a very unusual situation if Gold Selling type business attempted to organise and run (successfull) GDKP raids for WoW players. The next questions would be: "Why would they do this?" and "How will they profit by doing this?". GDKP raid leaders are often:
- Geared max level characters
- Players fluent in communicating over vent/ingame
- Familiar with class/instance/game mechanics
Therefore, it's natural to assume that any sort of business set up will require some sort of scheme to recruit raid leaders, because they are what make GDKP runs a success. You can't set up a business to run hundreds of GDKP raids over all the Warcraft realms via using your own employees.
But why would you as a raid leader want to get involved? The only scenario I could see is if these raids did something like take 10% of the pot. That 3-5k is sold for real money, and the raid leader receives a split of the money (paid to his credit card). Basically it would turn the recruited Raid Leader into the indirect Gold Seller. If a business like this ran 100 GDKP raids, each with a pot of 30 000 (10% tax taken), they would have 300 000 gold available to sell for real money, and that's their profit, split with the raid leaders. You can see how the model could work.
Or perhaps everyone is charged an 'entry fee'. The money is collected by the raid leader (then onsold for real money), and the rest of the raid is run like any other normal run.
The easiest way to stomp this out, would simply to be to go only on GDKP runs that have no entry fee and take no tax out of the pot. I don't see how else they could make this kind of business model profitable: It needs to suck extra money out of players/pot somehow, and there's only a limited number of ways to do that and not turn them off wanting to go to your run.
Last edited by Tyrian : 01/18/10 at 4:41 PM.
|
|
|
|
|
01/18/10, 4:22 PM
|
#305
|
|
Piston Honda
|
Tyrian,
That's not exactly a new thing. Gold sellers are eager to find ways to launder money/gold. For instance, there have been cross-server BG pug groups that will have Ventrilo used to coordinate hosted by a goldseller (name is advertised in vent, etc), with "premium" access if you give then $x or y gold. It was only a matter of time until similar arrangements came around for gdkp.
|
Therefore, it's natural to assume that any sort of business set up will require some sort of scheme to recruit raid leaders, because they are what make GDKP runs a success. You can't set up a business to run hundreds of GDKP raids over all the Warcraft realms via using your own employees.
|
The idea, based on the portions you quoted, seems to be that they want to groom GDKP leaders to put together runs. They help the leader solve some of the arrangements for the group, then have their "mercenaries" get in the groups to absorb a good portion of the end pot. I don't think it's a particularly great model, as the larger the proportion of mercenaries is the smaller the pot size will be. Perhaps what the site is really trying to do is simply set themselves up as a hub for this sort of activity and make their money mostly off ad revenue and pushing gold from the landing page of the site. That would leave a lucrative opening for raid leaders, as they would basically be getting free help with organizing without having to give a cut of their gold to the site itself (similar to the afforementioned vent hosting for BG pugs). This is just theorizing, of course, but it sounds plausible enough to be worth the 40-60 bucks a year the domain registration+hosting costs.
As for the registrar, they are Domains by Proxy, Inc. registered through GoDaddy. So the registrar values their privacy. Though in all fairness, I use a proxy when registering my domains as well. Less spam to deal with.
Someone could do more digging, but it would go into a gray area rather quickly.
Last edited by Grigorim : 01/18/10 at 4:30 PM.
|
|
|
|
|
01/18/10, 7:04 PM
|
#306
|
|
Piston Honda
Tauren Paladin
Lightbringer
|
We've all heard the argument against GDKP saying "You're just promoting/encouraging people who buy gold." I think that site is as simple as that. "You want your uber trinket? They usually go for xxxxx gold. You can buy that gold from us and we will link you to a GDKP run on your server who kills the boss who drops it."
It could very well be just trying to leverage the surge in interest in GDKP runs into more customers for gold/cash swaps. They can basically say "Pick any gear you want, we'll help you get it." I wouldn't be surprised if farmers tried to leach gold from the runs as well or use phishing built into the site to steal account info to add to the company coffers. Regardless of how it develops, I'd advise nothing but the highest level of caution in dealing with a site like this. I agree with Tyrian in that it must have a potentially profitable business hook somewhere that will be detrimental to the player base at large.
|
|
|
|
|
01/19/10, 8:24 AM
|
#307
|
|
Great Tiger
Worgen Priest
Ravencrest (EU)
|
The most obvious revenue model would be to implement a tie-in to gold selling sites, either initially or later on as the site builds volume.
The line of thought isn't hard to follow:
- Prevalence of GDKP runs gives people incentive to buy gold
- If you manage to create a popular GDKP portal, you've gathered a lot of high potential gold buyers in one place
- Featured gold ads on this portal will be highly effective, thus very valuable to gold sellers
It might be started by a gold seller, or it could just be someone looking to sell ad space/the site later.
|
|
|
|
|
01/19/10, 3:57 PM
|
#308
|
|
Piston Honda
Human Warlock
Emerald Dream
|
I can't picture any scenario really where as a raid leader I'd want to get involved with these guys. They offer "Raid leaders will get a credit after every successful raid" but it doesn't say what you use those "credits" for.
Since it clearly seems to be setup to run as a business I agree that it seems they're in it to make money. I'm all for capitalism and making money for your efforts, but the only way (I know of) for someone not employed by Blizzard to make real money based on actions in game is against the Terms of Service. So why would I want to get involved with someone that may be breaking the Terms of Service?
Even if the way they *ARE* making money is by hosting ads not breaking the Terms of Service and not selling gold themselves, I don't see ANY benefit they can provide to a raid leader that I can't do on my own via the realm forum posts and the mmo-champion raid comp tool.
I would be more concerned that this is another way for gold sellers or scammers to find people in game who have lots of gold. Since they have raid leaders submit a report "Submit reports about the the GDKP raid including things like Drops and their transaction prices; Total revenue; How much gold split to every worker; who was absent". Although I usually post a summary of prices on the realm forums, I always remove the names of who bought what.
|
|
|
|
|
01/27/10, 8:41 AM
|
#309
|
|
Glass Joe
Troll Death Knight
Dentarg (EU)
|
Hey you, successful GDKP runners.
I got a question, I've been running GDKP raids for quite a while on Dentarg EU - both ToC25 and ICC25.
While ToC25 doesnt seem to impose any trouble, especially when it was with guild "boosters", Festergut and Rotface seem to be way too hard for your average joe and cant be possibly beaten by my GDKP raids for 3 weeks already. Closest i've come on Festergut is around 10-11% and then wipe on enrage, and that is with babystitting, explaining tactics, calling out for possible blinds/cooldowns usage on vent. Now even thinking about attempting Rotface makes me cringe. is this the same for you, on average size realms? Or is it Dentarg being obnoxiously bad?
|
|
|
|
|
01/27/10, 8:54 AM
|
#310
|
|
Von Kaiser
Human Priest
Tarren Mill (EU)
|
Originally Posted by Torgrimm
Hey you, successful GDKP runners.
I got a question, I've been running GDKP raids for quite a while on Dentarg EU - both ToC25 and ICC25.
While ToC25 doesnt seem to impose any trouble, especially when it was with guild "boosters", Festergut and Rotface seem to be way too hard for your average joe and cant be possibly beaten by my GDKP raids for 3 weeks already. Closest i've come on Festergut is around 10-11% and then wipe on enrage, and that is with babystitting, explaining tactics, calling out for possible blinds/cooldowns usage on vent. Now even thinking about attempting Rotface makes me cringe. is this the same for you, on average size realms? Or is it Dentarg being obnoxiously bad?
|
While not technicaly a GDKP run, it is a pug with both regulars, alts and more or less random people from various guilds, we do get Rotface down. We haven't tried Festergut yet but that is because we don't have the necessary dps to beat the enrage. With Rotface, it's the situational awareness that is required and not what kind of dps output you can perform.
So it's not impossible but can take a lot of wipes before getting it right.
|
|
|
|
|
01/27/10, 3:56 PM
|
#311
|
|
Glass Joe
|
I do a run on Spinebreaker that is in a similar situation. To date, everyone has been very understanding, and after three weeks of runs, I am turning away more and more people. Honestly, when the "Songs of battle" buffs are put through, I feel that the GDKP runs will start to balloon in success and gold pot.
|
|
|
|
|
01/27/10, 7:12 PM
|
#312
|
|
Von Kaiser
|
Originally Posted by Torgrimm
Hey you, successful GDKP runners.
I got a question, I've been running GDKP raids for quite a while on Dentarg EU - both ToC25 and ICC25.
While ToC25 doesnt seem to impose any trouble, especially when it was with guild "boosters", Festergut and Rotface seem to be way too hard for your average joe and cant be possibly beaten by my GDKP raids for 3 weeks already. Closest i've come on Festergut is around 10-11% and then wipe on enrage, and that is with babystitting, explaining tactics, calling out for possible blinds/cooldowns usage on vent. Now even thinking about attempting Rotface makes me cringe. is this the same for you, on average size realms? Or is it Dentarg being obnoxiously bad?
|
Hi, I run a gold pug on Dunemaul US that this past week got Rotface and for the past three weeks got Festergut. My story quickly: I ran a successful random-converted-to-gdkp TOC25 through most of 3.2 (ended up as 2 toc25, 2 ony25 runs over 4.5 hours one night a week), and now in 3.3 I moved the pug to IC25. My guild is ten man focused so we bring 7-10 of our raiders who are intimately familiar with the mechanics on 10 man (this includes 2 skilled tanks but usually only 1-2 healers), and then I have a rolling calendar invite that includes the most skilled puggers I met throughout TOC25. There's a churn of maybe 8 or so spots each week with the remiander being regulars.
Basically what I told my puggers was that I wouldn't be bringing any poorly geared alts (or poorly geared mains, for that matter), and while a willingness to bid on items is still necessary, geared/skilled/knowledgeable players are what I am looking for first and foremost. What I've found is that apart from the regular crew that likes having a decent 25 man to run (but only wants to devote one afternoon a week to it), I can also grab two or three main raiders from other guilds that were asked to sit out that week who are interested in badges, a chance at loot, and a couple thousand gold. With the possibility of hard modes starting next week, I expect several guilds that are currently running 2 IC25 raids (half alts/half mains x 2) will switch to one main raid. If this is a common occurrence, hopefully successful GDKP runners can pick up a few of the geared/skilled alts so that their pugs have more success.
tldr: bring the player, not the bankroll and IC25 non-attempt-limited bosses are very possible.
|
|
|
|
|
01/29/10, 2:00 AM
|
#313
|
|
Glass Joe
Troll Death Knight
Dentarg (EU)
|
Thanks for the advice, last night managed to get down Rotface quite easily. In fact, almost killed Festergut right after, 5-6% wipe. Filtering people for 3 weeks seem to give results, and bankroll increases every time.
|
|
|
|
|
01/29/10, 2:45 PM
|
#314
|
|
Piston Honda
Human Warlock
Emerald Dream
|
I've had a similar problem, Torgrimm. My ICC GDKP runs have been moderately successful downing first four bosses consistently and downing Blood Princes last week, but not enough 7.5k folks to down Festergut.
One of the changes I've made is I'm allowing people to reserve a spot in advance by sending me a link to a parse of them doing 7.5k dps on a single target fight (or pointing it out to me on recount if they're in raid with me). This has meant that I'm slowly building a core group that's evolving into a 25 man raid capable of downing Festergut regularly.
I'll also note that as I get higher and higher dps players attending I'm going to start running a ToGC run because many of the heroic trinkets are still Best or 2nd Best in slot. Plus I want the achievement. One thing I can't recommend strongly enough is REQUIRE A DEPOSIT at the start of the raid. If you have people in the raid capable of actually doing ToGC there's often a couple of personality issues in these raids. Many of the people tend to get impatient with failure, blame others and feel like they're too busy and elite to hang around wiping so they leave and then you have to search around to bring in a replacement. You basically lose one of the biggest benefits of GDKP which is good people stay and people you have to boot are easy to replace.
|
|
|
|
|
01/29/10, 5:27 PM
|
#315
|
|
Don Flamenco
Draenei Shaman
Kazzak (EU)
|
Alternatively you could make it known that if that if people act like children and quit when it's not going perfectly you just won't bring them next week. I don't know if its just me, but my runs get 100ish signups (about 60 on forums, then 30or so via in game mail and pm's) for 25 spots. So the threat of just never getting another invite is very real, especially when people have generally waited a fair few weeks just to get a spot in the actual group.
We do however kill Festergut and Rotface, and were getting sub 5% wipes on Putri last week, and have a very VERY good core of people.
Thats an interesting point actually.... How are other GDKP run leaders balancing the need to take 'the best' players to kill the new bosses, with the desire to get the best bang for your buck (biggest pots)?
Last edited by Tel : 01/29/10 at 5:32 PM.
|
|
|
|
|
|