Ring enchants-Self only?

Kinv · 10/04/06, 11:54 PM

http://wowexposed.de/?p=10 Was looking @ Wowexposed (hunter talents) and stumbled across the ring enchants.. which say they're self only now. I wonder if any other professions are getting stuff like self only crafted items (Like the 3 epic robe patterns) and as time goes on how those 2 extra enchants will end up adding. Right now it's only +8 to all stats, +4 weapon dmg, +24 Spelldmg, or +40 Healing power if you double up on the same enchant.

psychaotic · 10/05/06, 1:10 AM

I really hope it's a mistake - the odd BoP item that you can make from a trade? Slightly annoying, but ok, i can buy having an extra perk to actually having the trade, and there's probably another (probably more difficult to aquire) option for that slot that's just as good or better, or it's very, very gimicky (the smithing fear-breaker), or it's the entire point of the tradeskill (see: engineering, parts of jewelcrafting) but an entire class of item that you can only enhance if you have enchanting? That's.... kinda jacked.

The other option I suppose is the ring enchants are some sort of lvl 70 libram-esque thing, which I'd be ok with, but making it so the only way to enchant rings is being an enchanter is just going to make everyone become an enchanter, which is bad design, and very annoying for those of us with two non-enchanting production skills and rare forms for both.

Kinv · 10/05/06, 1:17 AM

Originally Posted by psychaotic

I really hope it's a mistake - the odd BoP item that you can make from a trade? Slightly annoying, but ok, i can buy having an extra perk to actually having the trade, and there's probably another (probably more difficult to aquire) option for that slot that's just as good or better, or it's very, very gimicky (the smithing fear-breaker), or it's the entire point of the tradeskill (see: engineering, parts of jewelcrafting) but an entire class of item that you can only enhance if you have enchanting? That's.... kinda jacked.

The other option I suppose is the ring enchants are some sort of lvl 70 libram-esque thing, which I'd be ok with, but making it so the only way to enchant rings is being an enchanter is just going to make everyone become an enchanter, which is bad design, and very annoying for those of us with two non-enchanting production skills and rare forms for both.

The enchants are nice... but hardly enough to force every1 to be an enchanter... are you gonna lvl enchanting to 375 and find those enchants for a mere 8 stats?

krucifix85 · 10/05/06, 1:21 AM

You're talking on a forum board full of min-maxer's?

psychaotic · 10/05/06, 1:21 AM

If that's the only way to get an enchant for that item slot? Yea, probably, and I don't think I'm the only one that obsessive-compulsive about min/maxing, especially on these boards.

Enchanting is also pretty easy to level up at max lvl (solo low lvl instance, burn everything, repeat until you run out of stuff you can solo) compared to say smithing or engy that requires an acompanying gathering skill, more time, and you have to compete for the resources.

Groglox · 10/05/06, 1:42 AM

I say its enough of a benifit to get enchanting on your main.

You can always use an alt for the other junk.

Lord BEEF · 10/05/06, 1:53 AM

The general idea is to have all professions with a self only booster. They haven't accomplished that but it's the idea.

Also UGH at the "arcane dust" being made from arcane crystals. I am very tired of arcane crystals.

GIJebus · 10/05/06, 1:56 AM

The only thing Alchemy buffs is my wallet, maybe :(

Kody · 10/05/06, 1:56 AM

Originally Posted by Lord BEEF

The general idea is to have all professions with a self only booster. They haven't accomplished that but it's the idea.

Also UGH at the "arcane dust" being made from arcane crystals. I am very tired of arcane crystals.

No kidding. :( Guess it's to be expected though with the name. But... wasn't that suggested as an alternative to having to compete with farmers a while back for raiders? :P

Edit: And yes, if these turn out to be self-only(it's very possible since enchanters already have the resist trinket) then I'll skill up enchanting for it once I'm 70 and have rings worth putting the enchants on at that level. I won't do it to enchant Naxx or Pre-Naxx rings though.

Darkchani · 10/05/06, 2:19 AM

If its the only way, then yeah I'll probably drop herbalism and get enchanting along with my alchemy, and pick up herbs on my alt... If they give something special to alchemy ? great then ill be getting both...

VIB · 10/05/06, 2:24 AM

Looks like to me that they want to give actual gameplay PvE/PvP advantages to all professions, not only engineers. If they never did this all hardcore arena teams would be engineers.

Apparently blacksmiths also have a damage shield only they can use. I really hope that's their intention.

Kinv · 10/05/06, 2:29 AM

Originally Posted by VIB

Looks like to me that they want to give actual gameplay PvE/PvP advantages to all professions, not only engineers. If they never did this all hardcore arena teams would be engineers.

Apparently blacksmiths also have a damage shield only they can use. I really hope that's their intention.

Except that enginers lose alot of their advantages in the arena...

• Fogbug · 10/05/06, 2:33 AM

Originally Posted by Kinv

Originally Posted by VIB

Looks like to me that they want to give actual gameplay PvE/PvP advantages to all professions, not only engineers. If they never did this all hardcore arena teams would be engineers.

Apparently blacksmiths also have a damage shield only they can use. I really hope that's their intention.

Except that enginers lose alot of their advantages in the arena...

actually yeah, if they're going to be adding worthwhile self-only profession buffs like this I'm not sure why they wouldn't let explosives work in the arenas

Grayson Carlyle · 10/05/06, 2:34 AM

Can we OCD miners get something to self-buff ourselves? I can't possibly think of what that would be... maybe something to do with smelting? :(

psychaotic · 10/05/06, 2:43 AM

Is it confirmed that the smithing shield buff was self only? I had assumed it was like sharpening stones.

Regardless, there's a big difference between a self-use reagent (shield buff, engy bombs), short-term gimick items (engy trinkets), BoP items (3 cloth robes, corruption), and permanent buffs that you can apply to ANY item - the first two have a cost/use attatched as well as cooldowns, the 3rd is nice, but will be replaced eventually through some other source (however long that takes, the priest tailored robe has one helluva long lifespawn), while the final one has no downside and no replacement, suddenly adding that level of power to tradeskills is a very large departure from how trades have worked in the past, and seems like it would be almost impossible to ballance between trades (skinning is silly-easy to level up, should it's trade-special thing suck then?, seems a bit unfair either way), as well as leading to massive forum whining ala the old "i took alchemy and my leveling buddy took herbalism, and as a result I can't EVER make a flask?" (back when black lotus was BoP), it just generally seems a step backward, unless they're lifting the 2-trade limit, which while I'd be happy with (yay, more things to master!), I don't see as likely.

I'm hoping it's either a bug, or they're some sort of libram-type thing that anyone can get.