Oh, here's the actual follow-up on this guy. During his second raid with the guild, he started making comments about members of the raid: for example, suggesting that the tank learn to pull or else that we have a hunter pull, when we accidentally had a double-pull of the dragonhawks in Al'ar's room. Needless to say, he was out of the guild in short order, thus making him, for real, one of our shortest-lived recruits.