I did everything that was posted above except for the Gemming. I gemmed for Exp and Hit cap and reforge all of my gear for the highest possible Mastery. Got to a rating of 21.05 (599). Ran EnhSim Alpha, see the first set of results below.
I then regemmed everything for AGI. Reforged for EXP/Hit Cap first then reforge for Mastery. Got to a rating of 16.09(409). Ran EnhSim Alpha, see the second set of results below.
Note** I am having trouble exporting my character with ShockandAwe to be imported into EnhSim Alpha, so I had to do it manually. Not sure if I imported the information correctly (I think I did). I only reforge Crit and Haste. Which ever stat had the highest rating was the stat that I reforge. I ran the sim with out any trinkets, special weapons, weapon enchants or tier pieces.
Not sure if this testing means anything, but here you go regardless.
Summary -
Full AGI Gemming: 11415.78 DPS
Gem EXP/HIT: 11070.23 DPS
AGI Gemming simmed out to be ~455 DPS Higher.
-Arrakus
EXP/HIT Gemmed, All gear reforge for Mastery

### Saved by v2.0.9 of EnhSimGUI
config_version 2.0.9
simulation_time 5000
simulation_time_combatlog 300
combat_length 7
report_count 80
threads 1
combat_length_rng_factor 0.35
min_lag 250
max_lag 350
simulate_mana 1
cast_sr_on_cooldown 1
ep_precision 2
ep_base_stat ap
ep_ap 200
ep_crit_rating 100
ep_hit_rating 100
ep_expertise_rating 100
ep_haste_rating 100
ep_mastery_rating 100
ep_spellpower 115
ep_dps 15
ep_mana 600
ep_spirit 100
ep_mp5 100
ep_intellect 100
mh_auto_attack 1
oh_auto_attack 1
use_bloodlust 1
always_bloodlust_wolves 0
cast_lvb_only_if_fs_active 1
cast_fs_only_if_dots_left 0
cast_magma_only_if_ticks_left 2
cast_sr_only_if_mana_left 0
use_mana_potion_if_mana_left 1000
necrotic_touch 0
necrotic_touch_heroic 1
rotation_priority_count 10
rotation_priority1 SW
rotation_priority2 SS
rotation_priority3 LL
rotation_priority4 FS_UEF
rotation_priority5 UE
rotation_priority6 MW5_LB
rotation_priority7 ES
rotation_priority8 FE
rotation_priority9 ST
rotation_priority10 SR
aoe_rotation_priority_count 0
fight_name standard_single_target
miss 8.00
dodge 6.50
glancing 24.00
armor 8098
spell_miss 17.00
nature_resistance 0
fire_resistance 0
frost_resistance 0
arcane_resistance 0
shadow_resistance 0
additional_targets 0
additional_target_percent 0.00
additional_target_level 85
armor_debuff 12.0/12.0
physical_vulnerability_debuff 4.0/4.0
melee_haste_buff 10.0/10.0
crit_chance_buff 5.0/5.0
attack_power_buff_multiplier 10.0/10.0
spell_haste_buff 5.0/5.0
spell_crit_chance_debuff 5.0/5.0
spell_damage_debuff 8.0/8.0
spellpower_buff 10.0/10.0
percentage_damage_increase 3.0/3.0
stat_multiplier 5.0/5.0
agi_and_strength_buff 549/549
mana_buff 5401/5401
mana_regen_buff 326/326
replenishment 1
water_shield 0
mixology 0
flask_elixir -
guardian_elixir -
potion -
food -
###############################################################################
### Everything in the section below can be replaced by information obtained ###
### from your paper doll stats or exported by the ShockAndAwe addon ###
###############################################################################
race orc
mh_speed 2.6
oh_speed 2.6
mh_dps 226.7
oh_dps 226.7
mh_crit 48.54
oh_crit 48.54
mh_hit 20.53
oh_hit 20.53
mh_expertise_rating 114
oh_expertise_rating 114
ap 4916
melee_haste 17.26
str 133
agi 1931
int 135
spi 155
mastery_rating 599
spellpower 2583
spell_crit 25.42
spell_hit 17.04
spell_haste 17.26
max_mana 6141
mp5 249
mh_imbue windfury
oh_imbue flametongue
mh_enchant -
oh_enchant -
mh_weapon mace
oh_weapon mace
trinket1 -
trinket2 -
set_bonus1 -
set_bonus2 -
set_bonus3 -
metagem -
gloves_enchant -
cloak_enchant -
ring_proc -
glyph_prime1 stormstrike
glyph_prime2 feral_spirit
glyph_prime3 lava_lash
glyph_major1 -
glyph_major2 -
glyph_major3 -
armor_type_bonus 0
primary_talent enhancement
elemental_weapons 2/2
focused_strikes 3/3
improved_shields 0/3
elemental_devastation 3/3
flurry 3/3
static_shock 3/3
improved_fire_nova 2/2
searing_flames 3/3
frozen_power 0/2
shamanistic_rage 1/1
unleashed_rage 2/2
improved_lava_lash 2/2
maelstrom_weapon 3/3
convection 0/2
concussion 3/3
call_of_flame 2/2
reverberation 0/2
elemental_precision 0/3
elemental_focus 0/1
elemental_oath 0/2
lava_flows 0/3
storm_earth_and_fire 0/3
elemental_mastery 0/1
feedback 0/3
lava_surge 0/2 /

EnhSim version 2.0.9
................................................................................
MH:
miss 58021 0.47%
dodge 441827 3.55%
glancing 2983428 24.00%
hit 1562452 12.57%
crit 7384684 59.41%
average ap 7582.14
clip 0 0.00%
MH Windfury:
procs/hits 14.76%
procs/swings 14.17%
miss 0 0.00%
dodge 145470 3.54%
hit 1488450 36.25%
crit 2471646 60.20%
average ap 7581.38
MH Storsmtrike:
miss 0 0.00%
dodge 72844 3.55%
hit 746435 36.36%
crit 1233879 60.10%
average ap 7580.32
MH Unleashed Weapon Windfury:
miss 0 0.00%
dodge 38600 3.57%
hit 391806 36.19%
crit 652313 60.25%
average ap 7578.68
OH:
miss 58255 0.47%
dodge 441288 3.55%
glancing 2980900 23.98%
hit 1561897 12.57%
crit 7388072 59.44%
average ap 7582.15
clip 0 0.00%
OH Flametongue:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 9530041 64.58%
crit 5227394 35.42%
average sp 5492.44
OH Stormstrike:
miss 0 0.00%
dodge 70518 3.56%
hit 717190 36.22%
crit 1192606 60.22%
average ap 7580.32
OH Unleashed Weapon Flametongue:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 698722 64.53%
crit 383997 35.47%
average sp 5489.57
Earth Shock:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 378042 31.55%
crit 820192 68.45%
average sp 5485.32
Flame Shock:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 625715 64.55%
crit 343574 35.45%
average sp 5490.13
dots hit 3680941 64.57%
dots crit 2019718 35.43%
average dot sp 5490.47
Lava Lash:
miss 0 0.00%
dodge 56925 3.57%
hit 579383 36.30%
crit 960004 60.14%
average ap 7578.46
Lightning Bolt:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 674381 31.56%
crit 1462177 68.44%
average sp 5491.99
Lightning Shield:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 771850 31.61%
crit 1670107 68.39%
average sp 5490.66
Spirit Wolves:
miss 0 0.00%
dodge 0 0.00%
glancing 1748308 24.01%
hit 4592320 63.06%
crit 942102 12.94%
average ap 7677.74
Searing Totem:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 4588288 64.59%
crit 2515675 35.41%
average sp 5480.77
Searing Flames:
hit 2000435 64.57%
crit 1097521 35.43%
average sp 5479.16
Fire Elemental Melee:
miss 138996 8.01%
dodge 77839 4.49%
glancing 416979 24.04%
hit 1100785 63.46%
crit 0 0.00%
Fire Elemental Fire Shield:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 1621540 95.03%
crit 84825 4.97%
Fire Elemental Fire Nova:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 468115 95.00%
crit 24654 5.00%
Fire Elemental Fire Blast:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 406907 95.00%
crit 21433 5.00%
Fire Elemental stats:
average ap 7902.13
average sp 5831.08
MPS 42.84
MPCooldown 5141.36
Out of mana time 35.00%
MRPCooldown 647.69
MRPS 5.51
Fire Elemental MRPS without overregen
mana regen 5.40 100.00%
Maelstrom Weapon:
PPM 48.03
efficiency 74.14%
flurry uptime 95.67%
elemental devastation uptime 95.74%
UW Windfury uptime 17.24%
UW Flametongue uptime 20.20%
stormstrike debuff uptime 99.60%
flame shock uptime 75.62%
lightning shield uptime 100.00%
searing totem uptime 65.28%
searing flame uptime 63.74%
fire elemental uptime 28.56%
racial uptime 14.10%
necrotic touch uptime 45.99%
MRPS without overregen
mana regen 24.04 2.55%
mp5 85.09 9.01%
replenishment 21.20 2.24%
unrelenting storm 0.00 0.00%
primal wisdom 619.29 65.59%
shamanistic rage 194.56 20.61%
mana potion 0.00 0.00%
misc 0.00 0.00%
DPS PPM MPS
white 2336.97 21.11% 82.87
windfury 1075.13 9.71% 6.84
flametongue 968.95 8.75% 49.19
searing flames 247.04 2.23% 10.33
stormstrike 525.26 4.74% 6.84 155.69 23.68%
lava lash 1155.15 10.43% 5.32 62.71 9.54%
searing totem 781.56 7.06% 0.75 20.18 3.07%
earth shock 401.17 3.62% 3.99 213.09 32.41%
flame shock 425.77 3.85% 3.23 168.83 25.68%
lightning bolt 1101.59 9.95% 7.12 0.00 0.00%
lightning shield 469.93 4.25% 0.14 0.00 0.00%
necrotic touch 203.89 1.84% 52.33
spirit wolves 364.99 3.3% 0.57 26.45 4.02%
fire elemental 574.75 5.19% 0.14 10.58 1.61%
melee 391.08 68.04% 5.78
fire shield 18.74 3.26% 5.69
fire nova 115.14 20.03% 1.64
fire blast 49.78 8.66% 1.43
unleashed elements 438.09 3.96% 3.61 98.65 15.00%
MH Windfury 100.40 22.92% 3.61
OH Flametongue 337.69 77.08% 3.61
DPS 11070.23
MPS 657.54
MP2min 78904.99
MRPS 1390.65
Out of mana time 1.65%
elapsed simulation time: 5000.00h
elapsed real time: 15.14s
simulation speed: 1188668x
____________________________________________________________________________
All AGI Gemming, Gear reforged first for EXP/Hit and then reforge for Mastery

### Saved by v2.0.9 of EnhSimGUI
config_version 2.0.9
simulation_time 5000
simulation_time_combatlog 300
combat_length 7
report_count 80
threads 1
combat_length_rng_factor 0.35
min_lag 250
max_lag 350
simulate_mana 1
cast_sr_on_cooldown 1
ep_precision 2
ep_base_stat ap
ep_ap 200
ep_crit_rating 100
ep_hit_rating 100
ep_expertise_rating 100
ep_haste_rating 100
ep_mastery_rating 100
ep_spellpower 115
ep_dps 15
ep_mana 600
ep_spirit 100
ep_mp5 100
ep_intellect 100
mh_auto_attack 1
oh_auto_attack 1
use_bloodlust 1
always_bloodlust_wolves 0
cast_lvb_only_if_fs_active 1
cast_fs_only_if_dots_left 0
cast_magma_only_if_ticks_left 2
cast_sr_only_if_mana_left 0
use_mana_potion_if_mana_left 1000
necrotic_touch 0
necrotic_touch_heroic 1
rotation_priority_count 10
rotation_priority1 SW
rotation_priority2 SS
rotation_priority3 LL
rotation_priority4 FS_UEF
rotation_priority5 UE
rotation_priority6 MW5_LB
rotation_priority7 ES
rotation_priority8 FE
rotation_priority9 ST
rotation_priority10 SR
aoe_rotation_priority_count 0
fight_name standard_single_target
miss 8.00
dodge 6.50
glancing 24.00
armor 8098
spell_miss 17.00
nature_resistance 0
fire_resistance 0
frost_resistance 0
arcane_resistance 0
shadow_resistance 0
additional_targets 0
additional_target_percent 0.00
additional_target_level 85
armor_debuff 12.0/12.0
physical_vulnerability_debuff 4.0/4.0
melee_haste_buff 10.0/10.0
crit_chance_buff 5.0/5.0
attack_power_buff_multiplier 10.0/10.0
spell_haste_buff 5.0/5.0
spell_crit_chance_debuff 5.0/5.0
spell_damage_debuff 8.0/8.0
spellpower_buff 10.0/10.0
percentage_damage_increase 3.0/3.0
stat_multiplier 5.0/5.0
agi_and_strength_buff 549/549
mana_buff 5401/5401
mana_regen_buff 326/326
replenishment 1
water_shield 0
mixology 0
flask_elixir -
guardian_elixir -
potion -
food -
###############################################################################
### Everything in the section below can be replaced by information obtained ###
### from your paper doll stats or exported by the ShockAndAwe addon ###
###############################################################################
race orc
mh_speed 2.6
oh_speed 2.6
mh_dps 226.7
oh_dps 226.7
mh_crit 50.64
oh_crit 50.64
mh_hit 20.53
oh_hit 20.53
mh_expertise_rating 116
oh_expertise_rating 116
ap 5276
melee_haste 17.26
str 133
agi 2105
int 135
spi 155
mastery_rating 409
spellpower 2763
spell_crit 25.42
spell_hit 17.04
spell_haste 17.26
max_mana 6141
mp5 249
mh_imbue windfury
oh_imbue flametongue
mh_enchant -
oh_enchant -
mh_weapon mace
oh_weapon mace
trinket1 -
trinket2 -
set_bonus1 -
set_bonus2 -
set_bonus3 -
metagem -
gloves_enchant -
cloak_enchant -
ring_proc -
glyph_prime1 stormstrike
glyph_prime2 feral_spirit
glyph_prime3 lava_lash
glyph_major1 -
glyph_major2 -
glyph_major3 -
armor_type_bonus 0
primary_talent enhancement
elemental_weapons 2/2
focused_strikes 3/3
improved_shields 0/3
elemental_devastation 3/3
flurry 3/3
static_shock 3/3
improved_fire_nova 2/2
searing_flames 3/3
frozen_power 0/2
shamanistic_rage 1/1
unleashed_rage 2/2
improved_lava_lash 2/2
maelstrom_weapon 3/3
convection 0/2
concussion 3/3
call_of_flame 2/2
reverberation 0/2
elemental_precision 0/3
elemental_focus 0/1
elemental_oath 0/2
lava_flows 0/3
storm_earth_and_fire 0/3
elemental_mastery 0/1
feedback 0/3
lava_surge 0/2

EnhSim version 2.0.9
................................................................................
MH:
miss 58497 0.47%
dodge 440606 3.54%
glancing 2985513 23.98%
hit 1302016 10.46%
crit 7663731 61.55%
average ap 7998.19
clip 0 0.00%
MH Windfury:
procs/hits 14.74%
procs/swings 14.16%
miss 0 0.00%
dodge 145829 3.55%
hit 1404518 34.19%
crit 2558029 62.26%
average ap 7997.60
MH Storsmtrike:
miss 0 0.00%
dodge 73071 3.56%
hit 703679 34.27%
crit 1276568 62.17%
average ap 7996.35
MH Unleashed Weapon Windfury:
miss 0 0.00%
dodge 38214 3.53%
hit 370159 34.19%
crit 674418 62.29%
average ap 7994.79
OH:
miss 58851 0.47%
dodge 441119 3.54%
glancing 2985685 23.98%
hit 1300943 10.45%
crit 7663765 61.55%
average ap 7998.20
clip 0 0.00%
OH Flametongue:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 9541353 64.55%
crit 5239097 35.45%
average sp 5721.46
OH Stormstrike:
miss 0 0.00%
dodge 70171 3.54%
hit 676009 34.14%
crit 1234067 62.32%
average ap 7996.33
OH Unleashed Weapon Flametongue:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 699420 64.59%
crit 383371 35.41%
average sp 5718.70
Earth Shock:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 378474 31.60%
crit 819154 68.40%
average sp 5714.41
Flame Shock:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 625788 64.54%
crit 343750 35.46%
average sp 5719.10
dots hit 3682016 64.58%
dots crit 2019140 35.42%
average dot sp 5719.44
Lava Lash:
miss 0 0.00%
dodge 56412 3.53%
hit 547904 34.32%
crit 992259 62.15%
average ap 7994.40
Lightning Bolt:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 675446 31.58%
crit 1463651 68.42%
average sp 5721.03
Lightning Shield:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 772432 31.61%
crit 1671235 68.39%
average sp 5719.81
Spirit Wolves:
miss 0 0.00%
dodge 0 0.00%
glancing 1747332 23.98%
hit 4595700 63.08%
crit 942902 12.94%
average ap 8093.85
Searing Totem:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 4587746 64.59%
crit 2514653 35.41%
average sp 5709.74
Searing Flames:
hit 2005019 64.60%
crit 1098790 35.40%
average sp 5708.19
Fire Elemental Melee:
miss 139153 8.01%
dodge 77878 4.49%
glancing 415466 23.93%
hit 1103793 63.57%
crit 0 0.00%
Fire Elemental Fire Shield:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 1622717 95.01%
crit 85256 4.99%
Fire Elemental Fire Nova:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 468631 95.02%
crit 24543 4.98%
Fire Elemental Fire Blast:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 407350 95.01%
crit 21396 4.99%
Fire Elemental stats:
average ap 8318.33
average sp 6060.30
MPS 42.84
MPCooldown 5141.01
Out of mana time 35.00%
MRPCooldown 647.67
MRPS 5.51
Fire Elemental MRPS without overregen
mana regen 5.40 100.00%
Maelstrom Weapon:
PPM 48.10
efficiency 74.12%
flurry uptime 96.37%
elemental devastation uptime 95.75%
UW Windfury uptime 17.20%
UW Flametongue uptime 20.18%
stormstrike debuff uptime 99.60%
flame shock uptime 75.63%
lightning shield uptime 100.00%
searing totem uptime 65.27%
searing flame uptime 63.64%
fire elemental uptime 28.58%
racial uptime 14.10%
necrotic touch uptime 46.08%
MRPS without overregen
mana regen 23.96 2.54%
mp5 85.00 9.00%
replenishment 21.17 2.24%
unrelenting storm 0.00 0.00%
primal wisdom 619.44 65.60%
shamanistic rage 194.63 20.61%
mana potion 0.00 0.00%
misc 0.00 0.00%
DPS PPM MPS
white 2466.54 21.61% 83.00
windfury 1119.85 9.81% 6.85
flametongue 980.39 8.59% 49.27
searing flames 251.46 2.2% 10.35
stormstrike 552.84 4.84% 6.84 155.66 23.68%
lava lash 1190.27 10.43% 5.32 62.73 9.54%
searing totem 794.19 6.96% 0.75 20.18 3.07%
earth shock 404.00 3.54% 3.99 212.89 32.38%
flame shock 430.67 3.77% 3.23 168.84 25.68%
lightning bolt 1117.73 9.79% 7.13 0.00 0.00%
lightning shield 475.72 4.17% 0.14 0.00 0.00%
necrotic touch 214.42 1.88% 52.50
spirit wolves 375.45 3.29% 0.57 26.47 4.03%
fire elemental 596.40 5.22% 0.14 10.67 1.62%
melee 407.68 68.36% 5.79
fire shield 19.11 3.2% 5.69
fire nova 118.60 19.89% 1.64
fire blast 51.01 8.55% 1.43
unleashed elements 445.82 3.91% 3.61 98.66 15.01%
MH Windfury 105.67 23.7% 3.61
OH Flametongue 340.15 76.3% 3.61
DPS 11415.78
MPS 657.43
MP2min 78891.69
MRPS 1391.94
Out of mana time 1.61%
elapsed simulation time: 5000.00h
elapsed real time: 15.11s
simulation speed: 1191500x