Just picked up Shadows Edge today and have been spending the last our trying to figure out which ones to use?
The three weapons i have; Shadows Edge, Bryntroll and Justicebringer (not the heroic one >_<)

Which one should i put where? MH/OH? Going mental soon, really have no idea.

My armory; The World of Warcraft Armory - Mortejn @ Turalyon - Profile

Thanks,
Mort

Hmm, I switched a bit of gear around and now all of a sudden Spirit outweighs Crit just, when Crit used to just outweigh Spirit.

I'm running 56/0/15. I'm about ~400 sprit unbuffed. COULD this be due to LIFETAP GLYPH not being as effective? I go from 3058sp to 3141sp, so it now only offers ~83 sp.

I would've thought replacing most of my spirit with crit would've been better, but sim says otherwise.

You shouldn't swap to a weapon without hit rating, which would cause you to be under the hit cap for almost the entire boss fight. (Assuming you aren't over the hit cap by far)

Point to point str wins, but agi items are often better itemized due to the 4 rows vs 5 rows policy. Practicly that means 4 rows of better stats gives you lower dps output then 5 rows of worse stats. The actual benefit of agi vs str item depends greatly on your current gear and you should use spreadsheet/rawr/head to determine which one works better for you. But keep in mind you'll have to run with full str gear once 4.0 hits live (several months ahead, but still)

This question is actually interesting. You shouldn't be under hit cap, but this could make lost hit even more of a loss if the refresh part of Everlasting Affliction requires hit rating. Given that it triggered Nibelung, it might. On the other hand, Improved Shadow Bolt also triggered Nibelung.

Either way, being under hit cap is bad.

Really, I didn't scan the posts, but for a Mut/prep spec (41/5/25) should I gem according to color? Currently I use AP gems for red, AP/Hit for yellow, and AP/Stam for blue. Am i screwing up?

Oh ya, and i use the +42 AP and +run speed meta.
Talent Calculator - World of Warcraft Talent Spec
Major Glyphs:
Mutilate
Vigor
Ambush

HI guys can you advise me what weapons to use i have shadows edge, bryntroll, and ramaldinis blade of culling im fury spec soft capped for arp with mjr and wfs just dont know if its worth using bryn mh and shadow oh as it goes against everything i know about equipping weapons lol any advice would be great thx

well, i was sure they were a really good upgrade, until i read the compendium :-s
Because there are perople some pronouncing so hard that haste/mp5 is optimal and crit is a almost meaningless (pure) luck stat which tends to fail if you really need it (heh, Murphys Law even rules in WoW almost like taking crit makes you a lowbob.
Thanks for your answer, I am going to gear, as I first off planned.
But it'd still like to here what you think about the belt, because there the crit/haste tradeoff is quite big.

And not that it really matters... but i bought the recipe for distilled wisdom in Zangarmarsh, so I believe its from BC.

HI guys can you advise me what weapons to use i have shadows edge, bryntroll, and ramaldinis blade of culling im fury spec soft capped for arp with mjr and wfs just dont know if its worth using bryn mh and shadow oh as it goes against everything i know about equipping weapons lol any advice would be great thx

Uhh, good idea, I'll try that now.

HMMM, interesting, its back to CRIT being over SPIRIT, it makes sense now, it might be a transition (~400spirit unbufffed) that the glyph is useful. I might do a few tests with other glyphs etc, and will keep you guys posted.

I have a question about the use of geming ArP as a MM hunter. I have read that ArP was nerfed and I am not sure what is the correct thing to do with geming or not geming ArP. I read this post on Outdps.com and I was wondering if you all agree with this suggestions.

"# If your gear has less than about 350 ArP from gear (not including gems or a trinket proc), then you should use arcane shot taking improved arcane shot talent, as well as gem agility.
# If your gear has more than 350ish ArP (this amount changes based on how much crit and AP you have), but less than 850 (again, not including gems or a trinket proc), then you should continue to gem agility, but drop arcane shot from your rotation, and use the improved arcane shot points somewhere else. To see whether this is a DPS increase, you need to use a DPS calculator for your spec and gear.
# If your gear has over 850 ArP (again, not including gems or a trinket proc) and you don’t mind being a bit of a “one trick pony” (a term Tobin at EJ coined to mean that you don’t AOE or DPS while moving well), then you can gem ArP and will get a DPS increase."

I was sitting at 567 ArP on my gear and I was told I need to gem total ArP so I did. I have now 879 ArP plus the proc from Needle scorpion trink and I have noticed a large dps drop in 5, 10, and 25 man groups. Thank you for any help
Mize