Well im in a guild that runs BWL/AQ40 up to emps (havent downed them yet) And Raz and anub. Tonight we did BWL and killed nef yada yada long story short. Prestors drops and a warrior wins. Needless to say the hunters and rogues are all rediculously pissed off. Truthful fact that guy is a moron and doesnt understand game mechanics to begin with. Considering he was arguing the fact that
Edgemasters did indeed increase his DPS with his Asscandy. Why you ask would he take that necklace? First he is a moron. Second he took the Ony trinket. Third he dps's in wrath pieces at least 3-5 of them. All in all i know im making people read useless in information but i wanted to see who was the bigger idiot me or him. What type of a DPS increase is it for him? I can list his gear and enchants. I memorized most of it so im sure im very close to it.

Helm of endless rage
Conivery talisman
Conqueors
ZG chest
Legplates of wrath
Boots of wrath
Bracers of wrath
Onslaught girdle
Rune of the guard captain
Blackhands breath
Gaunts of steadfast might *He was using edgemasters with asscandy*
Dragonic might cloak *16str 16agi one*
Asscandy
Strikers mark.

Long story short again i dont have excel so i cant plug in any of this into the DPS war spread sheet if sumone could help me out would greatly appreciate the information.

anyone? =(

Well first of all I dont think a post like this belongs here, you could just ask anyone in any good guild ingame and they would tell you the warrior is an idiot. And its not good manners to bump your own topic every five minutes. But to really answer your question if it was a dps increase for him or not we would have to know what necklace he was wearing before.

My apologies he was wearing Eskhanders Collar. Sorry im not very attent its 6 am i should really sleep and didnt notice what time it was i posted it must have fallen asleep and woken up or something again sorry.

Id go with him since he didnt post this here since you ask.

And to answer your question on DPS upgrade it is:

1% crit vs 1.5% crit + 1% hit

Is it the best item item in the world for a warrior? I doubt it but it was a DPS upgrade.

Eskhandars is pretty worthless so I would safely assume he does more damage with prestors.

The good side about a free bidding system is that everyone can get what he wants as long as he wants to spend the points, the bad side is the exact same.

You sure it's not just someone suffering from purple-itis? It's surprising how many people start using downgrades just because it's an epic. ;)

Its a good possibility. Like i said before chicken the guy thinks DPSing in wrath is the shit. Ive tried to help him but his ignorance truly shined last night. A hunter would have gotten alot with that. Where as he got like .5 dps upgrade if that.

Hes gaining 0.5% crit and +1% hit, so yes its a DPS increase. Hes clearly clueless if he thinks Edgemasters increases 2H damage - not much else I can say really.

Input appreciated thank u kinds sirs. =)

Also, please stop referring to Ashkandi as Asscandy. Its really not that funny anymore, and it has become a personal crusade of mine to convince people to stop calling it that.

Don't do this.

Also don't post here with stupid "my guild did X with Y piece of loot, help me prove that they're dumb" threads.