Elitist Jerks
Register
Blogs
Forums


Go Back   Elitist Jerks » Class Mechanics

 
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
Old 11/16/07, 10:02 PM   #1426
smatrixt
Glass Joe
 
Night Elf Rogue
 
Blackhand
Does vanish reset the mob's PP loot table?

If not, if you notice a lockbox show, but you dont loot it, you could try vanishing and PP again.

Probably not worth it to blow the cooldown, but ya never know, that could have been the lockbox with it in there.

Offline
Old 11/17/07, 12:38 AM   #1427
Dontmindme
King Hippo
 
Dwarf Rogue
 
Icecrown
No, Vanish does not reset the loot table. I've Vanished before when interrupted looting in order to acquire the pick pocketed item I've missed.

Offline
Old 11/17/07, 4:59 AM   #1428
Towbar
Glass Joe
 
Night Elf Rogue
 
Azjol-Nerub (EU)
Long time reader, recently registered

I use this macro when farming:

#Showtooltip Sap
/cast Sap
/stopcasting
/script SetAutoLootDefault(1)
/cast Pick Pocket
/script SetAutoLootDefault(0)
/stopcasting

The sap is nice as it lets you get all the loot while your energy regens.

Would love one of these thrown weapons as I have had no luck so far regarding an Arcanite Steam Pistol.

Offline
Old 11/17/07, 5:08 PM   #1429
Tosa
Von Kaiser
 
Tosa's Avatar
 
Troll Rogue
 
Bonechewer
I just got a Spinesever. I can confirm that is from a pickpocketed lockbox, and its is ilvl100.

Offline
Old 11/17/07, 5:14 PM   #1430
aegris
Glass Joe
 
Troll Rogue
 
Bloodscalp
And where did you farm this wonderful weapon?

I put in about an hour at the Legon hold in SMV last night, and no luck.

Offline
Old 11/17/07, 6:15 PM   #1431
Tosa
Von Kaiser
 
Tosa's Avatar
 
Troll Rogue
 
Bonechewer
Originally Posted by aegris View Post
And where did you farm this wonderful weapon?

I put in about an hour at the Legon hold in SMV last night, and no luck.
Heroic Blood Furnace. I suspect it can be from any mob that can be pickpocketted.

Offline
Old 11/17/07, 6:37 PM   #1432
Dizglan
Glass Joe
 
Dwarf Rogue
 
Balnazzar (EU)
Hmm yeah, a rogue on my realm got it too. I spent about 6 hours farming on Friday and another 6 hours today and haven't even seen a single green yet from the boxes. Oh well, that's just my luck, I'll get it sooner or later. :p

Offline
Old 11/17/07, 10:22 PM   #1433
Macblade
Piston Honda
 
Draenei Shaman
 
Windrunner
Another PP/CS option if you aren't getting everything with auto loot, might be to use the /castsequence command e.g.
I don't know that I've ever had a problem with it though.

/castsequence reset=0 Pick Pocket, Cheap Shot

hit it once to pick pocket and a second time to Cheap Shot.

A question about 5s/5r cycles. I'm a sword rogue and I've always heard of using 1s/5r or 2s/5r if you don't have 2/T4. Is 5s/5r for sword rogue? If so, can someone explain why you would want to wait and use 3 more CPs for a SnD?

Offline
Old 11/17/07, 10:54 PM   #1434
Arindelest
Piston Honda
 
Night Elf Rogue
 
Garona
Originally Posted by Macblade View Post

A question about 5s/5r cycles. I'm a sword rogue and I've always heard of using 1s/5r or 2s/5r if you don't have 2/T4. Is 5s/5r for sword rogue? If so, can someone explain why you would want to wait and use 3 more CPs for a SnD?
The basic idea behind any rotation is to keep Slice and Dice up 100% of the time while doing the maximum possible Rupture damage. The reason why you'd use any Xs/Yr rotation is that for your spec and gear, it optimally accomplishes both these goals.

That said, it depends what type of build exactly you're talking about.

As Combat Swords, 1s/5r is usually the norm with 2-piece Tier 4 (although it varies based on how much hit/haste you have for Combat Potency procs). Once you lose 2-piece Tier 4 the sheet will usually recommend 3.Xs/5r. As Aldriana put it so well in the first post of the thread, this means you can either "weave" 3 and 4 point Slice and Dices, or you can just do the next highest SnD, which will usually be 4. Of course you'd have to check the sheet with your specific gear and build put in.

As Hemo, combo point generation is a bit slower due to the lack of Combat Potency (even though Hemo only costs 35 energy). Therefore you'd want to a 5s/5r; however, you'd have to do one 4-point Rupture every so often because 5s/5r with this build is not hypothetically sustainable, and you also need to have the energy to use Blade Flurry.

Last edited by Arindelest : 11/17/07 at 11:01 PM.

Offline
Old 11/18/07, 6:05 AM   #1435
• Aldriana
Mike Tyson
 
Night Elf Rogue
 
Doomhammer
Originally Posted by Macblade View Post
A question about 5s/5r cycles. I'm a sword rogue and I've always heard of using 1s/5r or 2s/5r if you don't have 2/T4. Is 5s/5r for sword rogue? If so, can someone explain why you would want to wait and use 3 more CPs for a SnD?
So, the reason one specifically doesn't use 1s5r or 2s5r as a sword rogue without 2/5 T4 is because you won't be able to keep up 100% SnD uptime, and that is, shall we say, very very bad, on the whole. Hence, you need to use a cycle long enough to keep SnD up; for most of us, that's either 3s5r or 4s5r.

Now, the next question is, why would one use 5s5r over one of those? Well, there's a couple answers to that question, all of which can reasonably be argued to be valid:

1) You shouldn't, 4s5r (or 3s5r, or whatever) is better.
2) Because 5s5r only deals trivially less damage (like, .2% or something), and some people find it easier to maintain, it's potentially worth using if you have responsibilities in a raid beyond optimizing your DPS.
3) 5s5r has more slack in it; if your cycle gets disrupted for any reason (Kaz'rogal War Stops you, Naj'entus throws up a shield causing you to pause DPS for a few seconds, Kael starts casting something that you need to kick, Magtheridon bounces you around, or even just simple bad luck on procs) 5s5r is less likely to drop SnD uptime due to the disruption than 4s5r or 3s5r.
4) What 5s5r fundamentally does relative to more compressed cycles is sacrifice some finisher damage for extra SS damage. 5s5r spends 0 net energy on finishers; a cycle like 3s5r on average spends 10 energy on finishers, which is 10 energy not being spend on Sinister Strikes. For most rogues, this tradeoff is worth it; however, at very high itemization levels, it's possible to get enough AP/Crit/Armor Penetration that the Sinister Strikes actually do more damage, such that 5s5r will actually do more damage.

And lastly, something I've been playing around with lately:
5) If you have Ashtongue Talisman of Lethality, the slack energy of 5s5r allows you to manipulate your cycles a little more than you can with a tighter cycle; you can, for instance, wait a few seconds after building up 5 combo points to let your energy tick up to ~60 before launching the next finisher; this allows more Sinister Strikes to be launched while the Ashtongue buff is up. Such manipulations are somewhat harder (though, admittedly, not totally impossible) with a tighter cycle.

Offline
Old 11/18/07, 6:23 AM   #1436
 Andeh
The Titleless
 
Andeh
Goblin Rogue
 
No WoW Account
Originally Posted by Aldriana View Post
And lastly, something I've been playing around with lately:
5) If you have Ashtongue Talisman of Lethality, the slack energy of 5s5r allows you to manipulate your cycles a little more than you can with a tighter cycle; you can, for instance, wait a few seconds after building up 5 combo points to let your energy tick up to ~60 before launching the next finisher; this allows more Sinister Strikes to be launched while the Ashtongue buff is up. Such manipulations are somewhat harder (though, admittedly, not totally impossible) with a tighter cycle.
I've actually been playing around with this myself as well, albeit going from a tight 3s/5r to 4s/5r. I haven't recorded any hard numbers, but my gut is that it is a significant increase. Not only from it being able to stack up a pool of energy to be burst out after finisher, but also due to getting an extra 20% for the buff. I'm considering moving up to a 5s/5r cycle for that reason, since it would give me a 100% chance for the buff, and I could get more SS's off while covered by it. Its like what you have to do as raid Mutilate with Find Weakness.

United States Offline
Old 11/18/07, 2:19 PM   #1437
nelalas
negentropy
 
Human Rogue
 
Lightbringer
Originally Posted by Aldriana View Post
Such manipulations are somewhat harder (though, admittedly, not totally impossible) with a tighter cycle.
I can confirm that this is possible with a 1s/5r rotation though certainly not on every cycle. The cases where I have mostly been able to pull this "energy burst" off is typically when I cannot overwrite a rupture but still have some SnD time to spare. Since I have the Ashtongue trinket, I thought it better to save some energy while the last seconds of rupture tick off, refresh it (getting the trinket buff), renew my SnD, and launch some nasty sinister strike crits. Sadly, I finally broke my 2 piece-T4 bonus this week for T6 and will have to experiment with a longer cycle.

One question, though: is it also worth switching to 5s/5r, if you have the Ashtongue trinket, as to guarantee the buff after each SnD? Will the dps gained by increased trinket uptime outweigh the dps lost by less rupture uptime?

Offline
Old 11/18/07, 5:25 PM   #1438
• Aldriana
Mike Tyson
 
Night Elf Rogue
 
Doomhammer
Going from, say, 3s5r to 5s5r doesn't actually increase your Ashtongue uptime significantly; yes, you will get an Ashtongue proc on every SnD instead of only 60% of them; but your cycle is somewhat longer as well. Hence, neglecting any energy-queuing effects like the one discussed, the uptime works out to be very very close to the same. Hence, the only advantage of going to 5s5r is the greater ability to manipulate the cycle, which isn't modeled in the sheet (and probably never will be).

Offline
Old 11/19/07, 10:27 AM   #1439
Squirl
Glass Joe
 
Gnome Rogue
 
Vek'nilash
Question: have ZA drops been added or am I going to have to calculate AEP by hand :P

Offline
Old 11/19/07, 10:48 AM   #1440
koaschten
In the rear with the gear!
 
koaschten's Avatar
 
Worgen Rogue
 
Auchindoun (EU)
Originally Posted by Squirl View Post
Question: have ZA drops been added or am I going to have to calculate AEP by hand :P
Look back a few pages, Katherine linked a spreadsheet with Zul Aman loot and updated formulas for Expertise and new hit cap. No changes to Hemo and Aggression though

Originally Posted by Katherine View Post
Free file hosting by Savefile.com
Don't ask questions, its no official version, not supported by Ald and not proof read on the changes, take with major grain of salt.

How to get an Android Authenticator on your PC. (updated feb'11)

Germany Offline
Old 11/19/07, 1:11 PM   #1441
mih
Von Kaiser
 
Orc Rogue
 
Mannoroth (EU)
no Berserker's Call :/

Bloodlust Brooch has 115ap, i think it should be 118 ^^ (115 is pre 2.1 itemchange)

Offline
Old 11/19/07, 1:12 PM   #1442
mih
Von Kaiser
 
Orc Rogue
 
Mannoroth (EU)
doublepost :o

Offline
Old 11/19/07, 1:32 PM   #1443
royaljester
Piston Honda
 
Orc Death Knight
 
Destromath
Speaking of cycles, I'm currently ~t5 level with 1pc t6 and 1pc t4 still :\. I lost my 2pc t4 to get the t6 gloves, even the spreadsheet says it's a huge upgrade with the cycle difference, but it recommends a 3.4s5r. I was using that but noticing a lof of SnD overlap and usually having trouble keeping Rupture up all the time. I switched to a 1.2s5r (switching between 1 and 2 SnD's as needed) and see about 99% SnD uptime (less than a second of downtime, if at all) and 0 rupture overlap.

Is there a reason that I'm able to see somewhat tighter cycles in practice, but the sheet doesnt' offer it? Am I just that lucky that for the past week I've had amazing energy procs and thus able to run a tighter cycle?

United States Offline
Old 11/19/07, 3:51 PM   #1444
• Aldriana
Mike Tyson
 
Night Elf Rogue
 
Doomhammer
Originally Posted by mih View Post
Bloodlust Brooch has 115ap, i think it should be 118 ^^ (115 is pre 2.1 itemchange)
Yeah, I noticed that while working on the sheet a week or two back; it'll be corrected in 0.9.

Originally Posted by royaljester View Post
Speaking of cycles, I'm currently ~t5 level with 1pc t6 and 1pc t4 still :\. I lost my 2pc t4 to get the t6 gloves, even the spreadsheet says it's a huge upgrade with the cycle difference, but it recommends a 3.4s5r. I was using that but noticing a lof of SnD overlap and usually having trouble keeping Rupture up all the time. I switched to a 1.2s5r (switching between 1 and 2 SnD's as needed) and see about 99% SnD uptime (less than a second of downtime, if at all) and 0 rupture overlap.

Is there a reason that I'm able to see somewhat tighter cycles in practice, but the sheet doesnt' offer it? Am I just that lucky that for the past week I've had amazing energy procs and thus able to run a tighter cycle?
From a theoretical perspective, I don't see how 2s5r would be sustainable without 2/5 T4; consider:

A 2-point SnD with 3/3 Imp SnD lasts 17.4 seconds.

2s5r with 3/3 Ruthlessness requires, on average, 5.8 (7-2*.6) Sinister strikes to maintain; Assuming SS is never dodged, this requires, on average, 40*5.8 = 232 energy. Additionally, it requires an average of 15 energy to perform a 2-pt SnD. Hence, 247 energy is required per cycle.

Hence, to be sustainable, this requires that your energy regent exceed 247 per 17.4 seconds, or roughly 14.2 energy per second.

Natural regen is 10 energy per second; hence you need to generate 4.2 energy per second from other sources; ignoring Rod of the Sun King for the moment, the only real source for this is Combat Potency.

Combat Potency generates an average of 3 energy per hit; hence you need to average 1.4 OH hits per second. Even assuming that you are both hit and expertise capped, this still requires 1.4 attacks per second, or an average weapon speed of .71.

With the fastest possible OH (1.3) and 2/5 T6 on the SnD, even assuming 100% uptime on both mongoose enchants (unlikely), this still requires that one drop one's attack speed from .93 to .71 with haste effects; this requires an average of 467 haste rating - which I'm reasonably certain isn't possible.

Now, in short term situations - like, if you're getting chain-heroismed - this is possible. But in terms of a steady cycle that you can sustain without such internal factors? I'm not seeing it.

Offline
Old 11/19/07, 5:12 PM   #1445
royaljester
Piston Honda
 
Orc Death Knight
 
Destromath
Originally Posted by Aldriana View Post
Yeah, I noticed that while working on the sheet a week or two back; it'll be corrected in 0.9.



From a theoretical perspective, I don't see how 2s5r would be sustainable without 2/5 T4; consider:

A 2-point SnD with 3/3 Imp SnD lasts 17.4 seconds.

2s5r with 3/3 Ruthlessness requires, on average, 5.8 (7-2*.6) Sinister strikes to maintain; Assuming SS is never dodged, this requires, on average, 40*5.8 = 232 energy. Additionally, it requires an average of 15 energy to perform a 2-pt SnD. Hence, 247 energy is required per cycle.

Hence, to be sustainable, this requires that your energy regent exceed 247 per 17.4 seconds, or roughly 14.2 energy per second.

Natural regen is 10 energy per second; hence you need to generate 4.2 energy per second from other sources; ignoring Rod of the Sun King for the moment, the only real source for this is Combat Potency.

Combat Potency generates an average of 3 energy per hit; hence you need to average 1.4 OH hits per second. Even assuming that you are both hit and expertise capped, this still requires 1.4 attacks per second, or an average weapon speed of .71.

With the fastest possible OH (1.3) and 2/5 T6 on the SnD, even assuming 100% uptime on both mongoose enchants (unlikely), this still requires that one drop one's attack speed from .93 to .71 with haste effects; this requires an average of 467 haste rating - which I'm reasonably certain isn't possible.

Now, in short term situations - like, if you're getting chain-heroismed - this is possible. But in terms of a steady cycle that you can sustain without such internal factors? I'm not seeing it.

As I said, it seemed odd to myself as well, losing an extra 3 secs on my SnD and I'm still able to maintain roughly the same cycle. I'll monitor it better this next hyjal/bt clear, but I'm fairly certain I saw little to no SnD/Rupture downtime.

United States Offline
Old 11/19/07, 5:19 PM   #1446
Koosai
Von Kaiser
 
Troll Rogue
 
Smolderthorn
Since you have a DST I suspect that when it procs you get an excess of energy that allows you to keep the cycles going when you normally would not, also, BL or drums of battle would help out with the speed increase. If you are going to watch your uptimes, try and keep track of when your DST procs to see if that is where you are getting your extra energy.

Offline
Old 11/19/07, 5:30 PM   #1447
royaljester
Piston Honda
 
Orc Death Knight
 
Destromath
Originally Posted by Koosai View Post
Since you have a DST I suspect that when it procs you get an excess of energy that allows you to keep the cycles going when you normally would not, also, BL or drums of battle would help out with the speed increase. If you are going to watch your uptimes, try and keep track of when your DST procs to see if that is where you are getting your extra energy.
Good point, I'll try and notice that. And, its' entirely possible that I'm not noticing drop offs in SnD/Rupture when they actually ARE happening, but I'll se tuesday, we do a full hyjal and 3/9 BT clear, so that should give me plenty of fights to notice and keep track on.

I wasn't pointing this out to find flaw the the sheets, btw. Rather, I was worried that I am either a)Screwing myself over without even knowing it, since this is 100% impossible, or the other option of b) I found some odd set of circumstances where I am able to do what I'm doing and it's possible for others to do it as well. We'll see after tuesday..


Also, wondering if anyone has heard of a spinesever coming from lockboxes from other places than heroics/SMV. I know that reasonably, the boxes from any 61+ mob would work, but with so few spinesevers out, hard to really put a nail on any definite answers. I was working the ogre's at Burning Blade just because I can two shot them, little reistance from opposing faction and seem to have a little better lockbox rate than anything I've found in SMV, but I don't want to waste my time if no one has gotten one from anything lower than 67+ mobs... :\

United States Offline
Old 11/19/07, 5:33 PM   #1448
Vesper
Glass Joe
 
Human Rogue
 
Darksorrow (EU)
I don't see the Relentless strikes energy in the calculation (could be me though, already falling half asleep).

From personal experience 2s/5r is doable if you have 2 T6, before I got my 2nd piece it was almost impossible to keep up a 2 point SnD rotation.
It's by no means a perfect rotation, meaning that without "lucky" procs from DST, Mongoose and my other friendly fellow rogues are slacking on Drums rupture will run out, but then I have some extra combo's for SnD meaning I have more slack in the next rotations.

Then I again there's hardly any fight left where I can stand on the boss for more than 3 min without having to run out or something else happening so I can't keep up any cycle.

Offline
Old 11/19/07, 5:42 PM   #1449
• Aldriana
Mike Tyson
 
Night Elf Rogue
 
Doomhammer
Relentless Strikes is implicitly included by the fact that only 15 energy is counted for finishers instead of 50.

Offline
Old 11/19/07, 6:51 PM   #1450
songster
Chief Passenger
 
Gnome Rogue
 
Earthen Ring (EU)
Ignore, being an idiot

Great Britain Offline
 

Go Back   Elitist Jerks » Class Mechanics

Thread Tools

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Rogue DPS Spreadsheet pf Class Mechanics 2735 07/20/07 6:42 PM
Newbie qestion reg. rogue dps spreadsheet thesmellyone The Dung Heap 2 06/21/07 9:18 AM
[Rogue] Haste rating and the spreadsheet Cloak-SH Class Mechanics 11 05/30/07 4:37 PM
Spreadsheet that can optimize Gear and Spec? Bury Public Discussion 7 01/07/07 1:36 PM
Rogue Spreadsheet tynan Public Discussion 2 12/06/06 6:30 AM