This week is attunement week for us, so thankfully I have WWS parses from pre2.3 of the same bosses.
Also, before 2.3, I was a habitual totem twister with medium to low earth shock usage.
I've since honed my twisting skills and with 2.3 I use a ton of earth shock while still twisting to nearly 100% uptime of WF. I've not found an addon that counts debuffs on bosses, so I've not used flame shock all too often, fearing that I'd knock tongues off or something drastic.
2.2 _ the bladefist+merci glad axe, leatherboots from kara, no t5 4piece bonus, no band of devastation
Wow Web Stats i healed for morogrim, i interrupted priest on FL
Wow Web Stats
2.3_ syphon+syphon
Wow Web Stats
i interrupted priest on FL (so just look at my damage against Karathress himself)
On Vashj, i got the first two charges, so I did nearly zero damage in phase1.
Wow, i wish i could just delete this post. I was merely trying to put up what could be useful WWS information and it turns out that I did substantially less damage in 2.3 than in 2.2. Of course Leotheras is a terrible example to use, but Karathress and Vashj aren't shining examples of melee not influenced by randomness either. All in all, my data more or less just shows that in SSC, it doesn't matter what gear I'm wearing or what changes Blizzard does to my talents. The less than melee friendliness of the area counters any gearing decisions I could make. Hopefully keying is done and on Sunday or Monday, i can look through WWS of tier6 content and have some real results for folks, which I'll do some math on first, before wasting a post.