@Ravhin I only had the 245 version so it wasn't too hard, looking at DEP only, to see the huge jump. I really prefer the style of trinket Reign is, but if the numbers tell me something else is better I can't see a reason not to upgrade.
@Zamir. When you choose your trinket on the main page it pulls the avr proc # to calculate your final DPS? Seeing that instead of the DEP value is what confused me the most. My mind is trained to perceive bigger numbers as better numbers and going from +dmg proc to +sp proc saw the number shrink. I don't know how to make it less confusing but maybe that helps you understand why I was confused in the first place.
I'm hesitant to start tweaking away from the pre-set rotation scheme but I also know that with all the movement I do it would benefit me to try and model realistic conditions so my trinket considerations can be more accurate. I'll have to mull this one over for awhile I guess.