We can't decide for you either. Actually, we can but we won't. This isn't what we do here. There are a variety of free sim tools at your disposal to figure it out.
I just recently got my druid to 80 and started gearing him up. But i cant decide which cloak i should take from EoF vendor.
I have 2 choises. Either [Sentinel's Winter Cloak] or [Recovered Scarlet Onslaught Cape]
Too me the dps one looks better. I gain more dodge from the agi, which also stacks with Kings so that cant be bad.
Also more offensive stats which will help with threat.
Sure you gain abit more armor and slightly more hp, but is it really worth it?