Originally Posted by Unaz

My guild is having a tanking issue right now, our old main tank (we have a few now, but he's still usually considered the primary one) who used to be rock solid at 60, and is a hardcore "always prot, always pve" warrior - is having serious issues keeping up with our other tanks.

We've got Karazhan and Gruul on farm, and got to about 40% on Mag, usually for lack of warlocks/class mix on the last few times to get a serious attempt past phase 1.

ANYWAY, our tank seems to be having noticable problems staying up, and we want to figure out who's fault it is and what we have to do to change it.

Here's his profile: http://armory.worldofwarcraft.com/ch...ol&n=Icesavage

And here's the profile of one of our other main tanks who for whatever reason doesn't seem to consistantly have the same issues:

http://armory.worldofwarcraft.com/ch...thol&n=Andzrel

We've all talked about it and can't find what the key difference is, and I'm about to try and find some good way to compare what's going on during the fights to objectively pin it down as well. I mainly use swstats to track myself, but haven't really looked at other mods that may be good for this, like Recap.

Any suggestions as to what Ice could be doing differently, and maybe what addons could help as well?