Originally Posted by Angelic

Is anyone capable to answer me why Simulation Craft is giving Subtlety rogues a Spell Hit value almost equal to Crit Rating value? While Shadowcraft suggests Spell Hit has noticeably lower value compared to Crit Rating.

I respect and follow both projects, but in this case it's confusing me.

Edit: Additionally, Shadowcraft seems to be giving weird weight values sometimes for Subtetly. I could click Reforge several times and every time the values would change and jump around and gain or lose a lot. For example, just seen Mastery at 1.35 and then at 0.35 respectively. It seems to happen after a few Optimize Gems and Auto Reforge clicks.

Originally Posted by Aldriana

I ran across the same issues with sub BIS gearing, but for me its spiking haste as well as hit/expertise which implies its not a hit cap problem - at least not directly. It seems like its vastly overestimating the value of autoattack damage somehow, but as I haven't touched the sub model in almost a year I don't have any immediate ideas as to why.

I'll work on the problem as I have time, but I don't consider it to be the most pressing issue to resolve, as we're still a month or two out from people getting close to BIS gear levels.

Edit: And now I got it to spike mastery but not haste, which implies that something is going pretty deeply wrong at a fundamental level here.