Rules 4 and 6: No one cares about your guild loot drama.
Rule 7: The purpose of this thread is to teach people how to use the sim to make their own gear decisions, not to make those decisions for them.
I was wondering if anyone has run the numbers on trinkets at different levels. (i.e. using 397 starcatcher over 384 vial) this is mostly because loot council is not taking into account that the proc for starcatcher is very weak and gave the vial to a rogue who also had wraith and starcatcher