For the record: this sort of post is discouraged on these forums. We don't really do the "personalized advice" thing. Next time please just do what you wound up doing anyway - plug it into the available tools and decide for yourself. Thanks.
On the topic of gear, for an orc rogue, which would make a better combat OH, Gara'kal or Spiritsever? My MH is Claws of Shek'zeer just fyi. The primary reason for having a fist OH is the orc racial, granting added expertise. But Spiritsever has sufficient expertise to keep my OH above cap, plus it's sha-touched so I can gem it for 10k. Ideally I would like to have a second Shek'zeer as an OH but haven't been fortunate enough to get one. So, keep Gara'kal or spend the 10k++ to gem/enchant Spiritsever and use it?
Warnings serve as a reminder to you of the forum's rules, which you are expected to understand and follow.