Warning for Killars: Grammar

Kaubel · 11/05/07, 11:09 PM

Post: Ahh, the warglaives. Why rogues though?
User: Killars
Infraction: Grammar
Points: 0

Administrative Note:

Message to User:

"b4" is not a word.

Original Post:

Originally Posted by Mearis

Award it on the basis of individual player merit not classes. Any argument that is based on 'my class' instead of 'me' is bound to be stupid, because individual contributions are a lot more important than someone feeling entitled because of the class he chose to make.

Your perspective on rogues versus caster balance are completely the opposite of mine so I will leave it at that, but if you think that the nerfs were due to emotional arguments instead of looking at the numbers and drawing conclusions we probably disagree fundamentally on what makes a class balanced.

Edit:
Hemo is normalized. You cannot argue that you should get the weapons because of combat potency and in the same breath argue about how it would be a great weapon for hemo.

I don't get your contridictions. I never said it would be based purely on class, the senario in my guild that I gave were that 2 equally deserving people are up for the weapons and we choose the rogue over the warrior in the long run after reviewing class analysis. The guild raids to raid and defeat content, if your guild wants to give archimonde bows to melee b4 hunters thats fine, but its not in the best interest for you guild. True that exaple is a bit harsh, but Illidan legendaries are better for rogues flat out, understand that. If its between two equal deserving people and one is a warrior the other is a rogue, the rogue should get it, at least thats the way we see it (we = the majority).

As for the Hemo being normalized, I said that may be true. Regardless do warrior PvP as fury? I also didn't mention this in "the same breath" it was a secondary reason and not a major one at that.

Most people are trying to be a bit open minded here, as well as myself. Im open to suggestive critisim, but id be cool if it was a bit more of a general perspective.

edit: Id add Teron Gorefiend to the list of threat cap encounters, assuming you don't get ghosted of course. Notice all these fights are straight up all out DPS fights, other fights have gimics that make you either stop dps for a period of time, switch to another gimic of the encounter, or an aggro dump. So basically any fight that allows you to make full all out use of your gear/consumables you'd be threat capped as a warrior.