Infraction for harmisajedi: Grammar

• Greybone · 12/18/07, 6:18 AM

Post: [Rogue]The Combat vs Hemo Point of Inflection
User: harmisajedi
Infraction: Grammar
Points: 1

Administrative Note:

Message to User:

Please utilize your shift key to make your posts more readable for everyone. Thanks in advance!

Original Post:

Originally Posted by songster

The loss of DPS due to magic spells eating Hemo charges was never included in the spreadsheet.

my original post did not rely on any spreadsheet but rather hard math using broad assumptions & observed averages as points of departure. you can challenge the assumptions & averages, but please address the merits of the argument i've presented rather than pointing to other methodologies which may or may not pertain.

please not that i'm disparaging the usefulness of spreadsheets here, but rather am asking for direct feedback to a very precise argument. answers to the tune of "plug your stats into the damn spreadsheet, nub" aren't terribly relevant.

Originally Posted by songster

1) Going from 125% to 110%. This is a loss of 12% of your current direct Hemo DPS. If Hemo is 25% of your total, this comes out to 12% * 25% = 3% of total DPS. A 45 DPS nerf if we assume baseline DPS of 1500. 30 DPS nerf if your baseline DPS is 1000.

this is erroneous. please consult my previous post for correct math on the extent of hemo debuff, or else explain to me exactly what equation you're using to calculate the change.

i apologize for mistakenly referring to the 2.3 hemo debuff as +39--it's actually +36. i've edited the original post to correct the mistake.

i note that the substance of my original post, which was that in terms of raid-wide dps, 2.32 will be a net increase for trispec relative to 2.3, was not addressed.

thoughts, anybody else?