Originally Posted by Aldriana

Well, it depends somewhat on gear level and what you're getting instead, but, for reference: my guild usually runs three rogues on Brutallus, two of which are in the melee group (with enhancement shaman, fury warrior, and ret pally) and the third gets thrown in with the hunters (with GoA and a couple righteous furies). Those in the melee group are usually in the top 3 damage dealers; the one in the hunter group tends to be only barely in the top 10. So, like, if you're still getting battle shout and leader of the pack or some such, I can still see performing pretty well; but if you're running in, like, a hunter group and still beating casters and hunters, this is a sign that the rest of your DPSers are doing something very very wrong.