Originally Posted by Cathela

Yeah, that's what I noticed too, which is why I was considering dropping Commendation for the Artifact (actually I'd have to farm up the Artifact first).

I ended up doing what you did (switching Commedation -> Shadowmoon Insignia) and we got our first kill last night. I got gibbed at 50 seconds to Enrage when I took 25k damage in 1.5 seconds during a stomp. Looking at the WWS I didn't have any survival clickies up at that time; I'm not sure if they were all on cooldown or if I just screwed up. Anyway, it's that kind of massive burst gib that makes me think a 2.5k armor buff that doesn't suffer the stomp penalty would be a nice thing to have. (Our prot warrior smartly pivoted Brut away from his soak group to face mine and tanked him to the kill. Exciting stuff!)

Regardless of which trinkets are exactly best, it's clear that tank gearing on Brutallus is all about surviving stomps, so I'm definitely a believer in two clicky trinkets for this fight.