Originally Posted by saedo

Buffs to Combat made them pretty much on par.

Also, your mutilate spec is just wrong. Combat I'd pick up Killing Spree too.

Here's a mutilate spec. Talent Calculator - World of Warcraft

Should prob still expect it behind combat on target dummies still cause you need Murderable mobs for Mutilate to pull ahead if you're geared to maximize the current mutilate (it is kinda different from pre-3.0 mutilate).