Your good fortune on Thaddius of all bosses is not reason enough to rehash a beaten-to-death discussion.
So, last night I did Naxx25 as Ret instead of my usual Prot role - I got good gear but it's far from being all BiS items.
Since we were doing an Immortal run (which we got, by the way, yay), I didn't wanna risk killing myself on Thaddius, so I used Seal of Command instead of Martyr. To my surprise, I came out third on dps with 9400~ dps. Since Ret is not my main spec, I forgot to re-glyph, so I didn't even have the Consecration glyph or the Seal of Command one.
Everyone says Seal of Command sucks but apparently it's not THAT bad, right? If I had both glyphs and a feral druid, I would be doing close 11k dps, which is what most pallies do with Seal of Martyr - at least according to WMO
Did I get lucky with SoC procs on that fight? Is SoC supposed to be somewhat close to SoM/SoB dps? Why does everyone say it sucks bad then?