We don't do personalized gear recommendations on these forums. Sorry.
Finally getting back to EJ posting again. FYI, I love the info you guys have on here, debates and all. Thank you for keeping those of us who want to push our A-game to the next level armed with the knowledge we need.
As usual, First time in VoA on the new boss (this time 10 man) and the Valorous Aegis Legplates dropped. I have the following already:
Pre 3.1, I had used Redemption on trash, and Double Strikes on bosses. Now that 3.1 is here, I was running WWS to see which one would give me more bang for my buck. Using both the spreadsheet and Rawr (as of 04-15-2009) Redemption has an edge to some degree. I was shocked to see how low Aegis was on the rankings. Yet, on my WWS reports for 10-mans (and since my guild is 1/2 filled with "carry-me" chickenheads, we've barely crept into Ulduar after doing 3D Sarth25), I show Double Strikes doing a bit more.
Basically, the $20 question is, "Which one should I use?"