Okay, you get your wish! Let's start with your back-seat moderating and go from there.
I really hope some mod cleans the group of balance threads up.
By making one post with each rotation clearly laid out for newer druids and the spec/gear stat weights that favors that rotation. And maybe show some WWS' that accompany that spec/gear stat weights.
So say someone that thinks the starfire eclipse rotation is the best and has some wws' to go with it, and says hey we should stack haste then shows the stat weights so people can plug it in loot rank and start planning their BiS (best in slot) gear. (just an example)
This should cut all the different opinions down quite a bit and clean up all the threads. (always good to have people question the cookie cutter specs/rotations but we need to clean this up a bit)
Right now I'm seeing a trend of "you should be using a starfire eclipse rotation, or a wraith eclipse rotation" with a mix of dot uptime/priority without any actual numbers or wws' to back it up.
Lets see some real numbers and results rawr/calculators are great in a perfect world but lets be honest eclipse is so random it's hard to live in said world.