Originally Posted by sno

This should have been posted in Paladin: Simple Questions/Simple Answers
As a retri paladin you usually have the talent Judgement of the Wise witch will instantly grant you 25% of your base mana when you judge something.
As a holy paladin, however, you usually don't have that talent witch means that to get mana back you actually have to go up and hit the mob so that either Seal of Wisdom or Judgement of Wisdom can procc and for best result you should have both and then go hit the mob for a while with your weapon and hope you get lots of proccs.

I didn't get the last part of your post though, if she judge a mob and go up ahd hit it, won't JoW ever procc? Or do you mean that the judement it self doesn't return any mana? And did you say that she played on your character with a holy specc and still got mana from Judgement of the Wise?