Originally Posted by tufy

There is no whining, Alliada. This thread was created with the intent of finding optimal gear and a simple cold fact is that the optimal weapon for us is a mace with wasted stats (or before Lich King, dagger with wasted stats). Since Quel'Delar had the exact same mace and had to be fixed later on, it is logical to assume that the stats must be intentional - simply because doing the same mistake twice back to back is highly improbable, especially since there ARE perfectly optimized weapons in ICC that just so happen to be swords. Now the question is whether this is it or the weapon will be optimized in the future. Personally, I find the latter unlikely, as we have had a similar situation before.

In other words, at this point, BiS gear includes Royal Scepter of Terenas II (spellpower, crit, mp5). This means that our projected bis gear stays as it was, the only modification being the weapon.