This is exactly what and how not to post on our forums. Take a day to familiarize yourself with the rules before you even think of posting again.
When I first glanced over this write up, I thought OMG you had to break it into several pages? And all these formulas, WTF? Just tell me what is good and bad and get on with it!
Well I started reading despite my first emotion and I am really enjoying it.
I have found it incredible that after several hundred dungeon visits, maybe a thousand, I have only ever had one good Pally Tank.
So I'm rolling one to find out why!
I suspect that it is the use of talents and talent builds. It seems like the Paladin is the choice of all the kiddies who really don't understand team functions and want to show off their damage skills. They NEVER hold aggro! Except the one. She was awesome at it too!
In that one good Pally Tank experience, we were in Black Rock Depths and NOBODY died! NOBODY! And what was funny was that she said from the start that she was worried because she was at the bottom end of the level range. LOL she rocked it!!! I wish I could remember her name!
Any how, this guide seem very helpful and I look forward to using it as a reference as I grow my new tank.