Elitist Jerks
Register
Blogs
Forums


Go Back   Elitist Jerks » Player vs. Player

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
Old 11/07/07, 1:33 PM   #26
Tiiki
Rogue About Town
 
Troll Rogue
 
<Moo>
The Venture Co (EU)
2.
That they reverted silence diminish returns is also generally seen a paladin nerf. Yes it was a buff for healers in general, but it affects pallys by far the most in arena.

3.
+Dmg on healing is nice, but it won't have such an impact for arena, i think. It's already a mana war most of the time, where you surely don't want to waste it on manainefficient spells as a healer.
Sure, this will be some more interessting for priests/shamans and maybe even druids, but far less for paladins.
2. Because Shaman have so many instant heals they can use. Oh and they can bubble out of silence and you can't? Oh no... wait...

3. Another very Paladin centric viewpoint. In 2s and 3s especially, the dmg/heal change is MASSIVE, especially for resto shaman and priests who can provide a lot of extra burst at the start on top of their offensive dispelling. The lowering of the Chain Lightning cast time only adds to this. I think 2 healer warrior teams will benefit greatly from the ability of their healers to DPS in clutch situations.

You're right about heroics though. I hate them, and now I have to run about 20 of them.

I must say also, as a Rogue, I don't see what the big deal about the Hemo change is. Sure, it's decent whilst your 2 x ARs is up, and the new Dirty Deeds is nice. But really it's not a huge change. We still get owned by hamstring and warriors, we're still soft targets, and Mutilate hasn't been buffed enough to remain viable (my personal bugbear).

[I recently switched back to mutilate and the biggest and most unexpected problem, after being maces for a long time, is positioning. Having to be behind someone is a HUGE disadvantage against decent players...]

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 11/07/07, 1:37 PM   #27
Nurru
The beatings will stop once morale improves
 
Nurru's Avatar
 
Nurru
Undead Priest
 
No WoW Account
Originally Posted by Tiiki View Post
2. Because Shaman have so many instant heals they can use. Oh and they can bubble out of silence and you can't
This is a weak troll considering a Paladin cannot DS out of a holy lock, which is most of what a Paladin has to deal with in the arena.

United States Online
Reply With Quote
Old 11/07/07, 1:42 PM   #28
Tiiki
Rogue About Town
 
Troll Rogue
 
<Moo>
The Venture Co (EU)
Originally Posted by Nurru View Post
This is a weak troll considering a Paladin cannot DS out of a holy lock, which is most of what a Paladin has to deal with in the arena.
Genuinely not trolling. He mentioned silence and they can bubble out of that. My point still stands - only Druids / Priests suffer 'less' from either interrupts or silences. Paladins aren't out there on their own. Not to mention that Shaman suffer far more from CC in general (e.g. sheep).

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 11/07/07, 1:45 PM   #29
Antoine
Piston Honda
 
Night Elf Druid
 
Black Dragonflight
Double Healer+Warrior will be a lot stronger in general in 3s, I believe. 2s is nearly impossible to predict, and 5s will stay roughly the same (with possibly more hunters, but they still have some issues).

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 11/07/07, 1:45 PM   #30
mikebro
Piston Honda
 
Night Elf Warrior
 
Bleeding Hollow
What happened to that sticky in the PVP forums about not making retarded posts like list wars?

As for 2.3/Season 3, all I'm really looking forward to is playing with a new 2's partner if things come through. I don't see how a new season makes arenas and battlegrounds new and fresh again or why people want it to end so bad unless they don't have their drake yet and they are going to get Gladiator this season. A new season means I need to go and farm another 75k honor again, which sucks. But on the bright side, I have 60 badges for the PVP cloak, 75k honor, 100 of each BG token, and 5k arena points and a whole bunch of enchanting materials, so I'm pretty set for season 3.

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 11/07/07, 2:02 PM   #31
Elendril
KIND OF A BIG DEAL
 
Elendril's Avatar
 
Night Elf Hunter
 
Ner'zhul
I'm pretty excited to see what kind of push we can make in the 2.3 mechanics week with my tri-healer drain team. The spell damage for healing change significantly increases our ability to finish people off, and I'm looking forward to all of the delicious hunter changes. I sort of just want to arena all of that week and screw anything else.

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 11/07/07, 2:50 PM   #32
Ralask
On WOW's Worst Server
 
Human Warlock
 
Ner'zhul
Originally Posted by mikebro View Post
What happened to that sticky in the PVP forums about not making retarded posts like list wars?

As for 2.3/Season 3, all I'm really looking forward to is playing with a new 2's partner if things come through. I don't see how a new season makes arenas and battlegrounds new and fresh again or why people want it to end so bad unless they don't have their drake yet and they are going to get Gladiator this season. A new season means I need to go and farm another 75k honor again, which sucks. But on the bright side, I have 60 badges for the PVP cloak, 75k honor, 100 of each BG token, and 5k arena points and a whole bunch of enchanting materials, so I'm pretty set for season 3.
I cant pull your armory from here so I have no idea what ratings or battlegroup you play in however reseting of the ratings for this season is pretty big. In bloodlust their are a lot of inactive teams in the top 20 and a lot of teams were able to power up their ratings with SR gear which was changed deep in the season. There isnt going to be a lot of changes to what combos are dominate though.

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 11/07/07, 3:05 PM   #33
Encross
Von Kaiser
 
Encross's Avatar
 
Blood Elf Mage
 
Mal'Ganis
Originally Posted by mikebro View Post
What happened to that sticky in the PVP forums about not making retarded posts like list wars?

As for 2.3/Season 3, all I'm really looking forward to is playing with a new 2's partner if things come through. I don't see how a new season makes arenas and battlegrounds new and fresh again or why people want it to end so bad unless they don't have their drake yet and they are going to get Gladiator this season. A new season means I need to go and farm another 75k honor again, which sucks. But on the bright side, I have 60 badges for the PVP cloak, 75k honor, 100 of each BG token, and 5k arena points and a whole bunch of enchanting materials, so I'm pretty set for season 3.
It's a matter of competition. The first few weeks of a season are really interesting to play in due to the rating resets and balance changes that are typically implemented. It's really for the people like me who get psyched over facing new blood.

But, I can see why you're negative about it. Most of the players who take in new patches as a farming spree are just negative in general.

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 11/07/07, 3:06 PM   #34
Ralask
On WOW's Worst Server
 
Human Warlock
 
Ner'zhul
Originally Posted by Elendril View Post
I'm pretty excited to see what kind of push we can make in the 2.3 mechanics week with my tri-healer drain team. The spell damage for healing change significantly increases our ability to finish people off, and I'm looking forward to all of the delicious hunter changes. I sort of just want to arena all of that week and screw anything else.
Just curious what hunter changes are going to give you such a huge edge than before? I know the dead zone is going to help but other than that it seems kind of lackluster. I have never played a hunter in arena before but to me it seems that hunters didnt get anything that will make them a force in arena.

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 11/07/07, 3:25 PM   #35
Elendril
KIND OF A BIG DEAL
 
Elendril's Avatar
 
Night Elf Hunter
 
Ner'zhul
Originally Posted by Ralask View Post
Just curious what hunter changes are going to give you such a huge edge than before? I know the dead zone is going to help but other than that it seems kind of lackluster. I have never played a hunter in arena before but to me it seems that hunters didnt get anything that will make them a force in arena.
The dead zone change is huge, and the arcane shot change is pretty significant as well. Being able to strip HoTs off people, break through BoP without another dispeller, pop PW:S, etc - are all potentially game winning uses of the arcane shot dispel effect. The MS addition to Aimed Shot isn't a big deal, but with my setup (warlock/hunter/holy priest/holy paladin/resto druid) it's a reasonable way to finish someone off if you can get them snared - I can easily wind up an Aimed Shot while a target is Cycloned, for instance.

It's nothing individually groundbreaking, but it's a bunch of small changes that I can see having a huge impact when added up.

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 11/07/07, 4:57 PM   #36
mikebro
Piston Honda
 
Night Elf Warrior
 
Bleeding Hollow
Originally Posted by Encross View Post
It's a matter of competition. The first few weeks of a season are really interesting to play in due to the rating resets and balance changes that are typically implemented. It's really for the people like me who get psyched over facing new blood.

But, I can see why you're negative about it. Most of the players who take in new patches as a farming spree are just negative in general.
I don't think it's bad that there's a new season starting up, I just don't get the big excitement that comes around whenever theres a new season starting. Class changes have nothing to do with new seasons, classes have been getting changes all throughout season 2 and there has even been a major arena change in the middle of a season, gear swapping once the gates have opened.

All a new season accomplishes is a) Purging of dead teams and b) New gear. I'm pretty sure majority of people get excited about a new season because of the latter.

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 11/07/07, 5:15 PM   #37
Encross
Von Kaiser
 
Encross's Avatar
 
Blood Elf Mage
 
Mal'Ganis
Originally Posted by mikebro View Post
I don't think it's bad that there's a new season starting up, I just don't get the big excitement that comes around whenever theres a new season starting. Class changes have nothing to do with new seasons, classes have been getting changes all throughout season 2 and there has even been a major arena change in the middle of a season, gear swapping once the gates have opened.

All a new season accomplishes is a) Purging of dead teams and b) New gear. I'm pretty sure majority of people get excited about a new season because of the latter.
Every class is going to be affected by this upcoming patch/season. I'm very interested in seeing subtlety rogues, hunters, possible enhancement shaman, and even how the +damage from healing change affects a team's playstyle when the oppurtunity for burst is put into play. Sure, classes have been getting changed around for the length of the season, but the affects of -this- upcoming patch will be a fresh of breath air for anyone who climbed for Merciless Gladiator and has seen the same re-hashed teams/playstyles a thousand times over.

I'm not saying that the actual season is going to totally revolutionize the game; the patch that is coming out one week before a fresh season, though, will be quite enjoyable to start off with on top of already recieving new gear and reset ladders.

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 11/07/07, 5:44 PM   #38
Optimized
Von Kaiser
 
Gnome Warlock
 
Blackhand
I'm pretty excited as our resto shaman has been collecting points and with the new gear is going to go elemental, changing our team from 3 dps/2healer to 4 dps. In addition a lot of players got more into arena in 2.2 and they have been building up points for season 3. When season 3 comes along they'll go from a low gear level to an acceptable one for high level play as they spend their stockpile of points. In addition a lot of people rolled alts that were more desirable that are leveled up now and collecting arena/honor points.

New season bringing new gear bringing new players/specs is what I'm excited about.

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 11/07/07, 6:21 PM   #39
Rej
Piston Honda
 
Undead Priest
 
Doomhammer
Originally Posted by Psykal View Post
It's just a cloak, they still have to PVP for the weapons, gladiator set and honour items. I can understand your frustrations not wanting to do heroics but it's not like people who don't PVP much can avoid the honour/arena grind.
I'm not really sure what to feel about this either. On one hand, doing a greater variety of activities to accrue PvP gear is nice for a change of pace. On the other hand, getting together a team skilled enough to handle ZA or Heroics is a challenge in and of itself.

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 11/07/07, 7:04 PM   #40
Juli
Don Flamenco
 
Juli's Avatar
 
Undead Priest
 
Executus
Originally Posted by Rej View Post
I'm not really sure what to feel about this either. On one hand, doing a greater variety of activities to accrue PvP gear is nice for a change of pace. On the other hand, getting together a team skilled enough to handle ZA or Heroics is a challenge in and of itself.
I believe the argument made by devs was that 'you can certainly do heroics in season 2 arena gear' (the actual comment was regarding tanking iirc), and actually arena items are a pretty good amount of ilvls above what heroics mandate. With that level of gear, heroics are really really just not hard at all.

Being forced to PvE for just 1 slot of gear isn't that bad even if you hate it, and you have multiple avenues to accomplish this (heroics, kara, ZA). It's way less painful to get 60 badges if you hate running heroics than it is to get 80k+ honor when you hate doing 2 year old battlegrounds, and just skipping it and not getting the item would affect you a lot less than skipping the honor grind.

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 11/07/07, 7:34 PM   #41
Zraknul
P is for Park
 
Zraknul's Avatar
 
No active account.
Orc Death Knight
 
No WoW Account
I'm just curious what the logic behind ending the season a week after the patch?

That doesn't seem like a ton of time for the people who benefit from the changes to grid up their ranking. You also might see people passing on that week if they are either negatively impacted or unsure on the impact for fear of losing too much standing.

Canada Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 11/07/07, 7:42 PM   #42
Humbaba
John Galt
 
Humbaba's Avatar
 
Humbalo
Tauren Druid
 
No WoW Account
They want a week to make pve fixes from the patch before they have to start fixing pvp stuff, too.

United States Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 11/07/07, 7:45 PM   #43
Yes
progamer
 
Yes's Avatar
 
Tauren Druid
 
Dragonmaw
Originally Posted by Juli View Post
It's way less painful to get 60 badges if you hate running heroics than it is to get 80k+ honor when you hate doing 2 year old battlegrounds, and just skipping it and not getting the item would affect you a lot less than skipping the honor grind.
No it isn't! Grinding 80k honor requires you to press a button every 5 minutes while reading a book, watching a movie, talking with friends on the phone, playing Guitar Hero III, studying for class etc. Also, 80k honor is not one item, one item is 18~k honor. At a lazy pace of afking AVs at 1000 honor per hour that's 18 hours of playing for one item. The cloak, clearing mechanar in one hour of semi focused button mashing adds up to twelve runs. At one hour per run and 30 minutes to get people online, there, etc we are at 18 hours of playtime. The differance is that while in AV you are free to do other things and are simply stuck to the computer while in a heroic you need to pay enough attention to the heroic that you can't do the things I mentioned above.


Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 11/07/07, 7:53 PM   #44
Aphyrax
Great Tiger
 
Tauren Druid
 
Tichondrius
Originally Posted by Yes View Post
No it isn't! Grinding 80k honor requires you to press a button every 5 minutes while reading a book, watching a movie, talking with friends on the phone, playing Guitar Hero III, studying for class etc. Also, 80k honor is not one item, one item is 18~k honor. At a lazy pace of afking AVs at 1000 honor per hour that's 18 hours of playing for one item. The cloak, clearing mechanar in one hour of semi focused button mashing adds up to twelve runs. At one hour per run and 30 minutes to get people online, there, etc we are at 18 hours of playtime. The differance is that while in AV you are free to do other things and are simply stuck to the computer while in a heroic you need to pay enough attention to the heroic that you can't do the things I mentioned above.

The man speaks the truth. Also, easier or not, lets not forget the design-philosophical issue of forcing PvPers to do a substantial amount of PvE to be competitive. Hey, Blizzard. If I wanted to PvE I would still be raiding. If doing BT with my guild isn't appealing to me, what makes you think pugging heroics is?

They should really have made that cloak available from both PvE and PvP. That way, nobody would have been forced to do anything.

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 11/07/07, 8:20 PM   #45
Osse
King Hippo
 
Osse's Avatar
 
Orc Hunter
 
Stormscale (EU)
You have to get 50 EotS, 40 or 80 WSG and 40 (I think) AB badges too though.

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 11/07/07, 8:46 PM   #46
 Mex
Sour Bear Mojo
 
Mex's Avatar
 
Mex
Tauren Shaman
 
No WoW Account
Originally Posted by Caal View Post
The +damage on healers is a very big deal for Paladins, actually. Look forward to destroying felhunters in a jiffy come next patch.
Aye, combined with lower mana costs for exorcism this really gives paladins a nice edge against those damn dogs.

The bonus spell damage from +healing isn't something that's designed to turn healers into nukers though, but it definitely gives a few advantages for certain spells with high coefficients and low mana costs (judgement of righteousness and insect swarm spring to my mind). With JoR and holy shock a pally can potentially do 2k burst in a single global cooldown, assuming 500-600 spell damage. If you take the time to pre-emptively judge crusader, or run with a ret pally, that figure becomes even more dangerous. It's not something you want to spam every cooldown, but it will change the dynamics of play as healers suddenly become able to finish off low health targets in a pinch.

Insect swarm, for many resto druids, is something that they use against melee classes anyway for the miss %. Having it do an extra 300-400 damage every 12 seconds is nothing to sneeze at.

I'm not sure if there are shaman / priest equivalents, since I haven't played these classes in like two years, but I'm not looking forward to trying to burst down resto shamans while they slam me with 1k frost shocks.

Australia Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 11/07/07, 8:50 PM   #47
Ngita
Don Flamenco
 
Human Paladin
 
<Aus>
Proudmoore
Originally Posted by Yes View Post
No it isn't! Grinding 80k honor requires you to press a button every 5 minutes while reading a book, watching a movie, talking with friends on the phone, playing Guitar Hero III, studying for class etc. Also, 80k honor is not one item, one item is 18~k honor. At a lazy pace of afking AVs at 1000 honor per hour that's 18 hours of playing for one item.
Getting off topic but I dont feel this should be advocated and unreplied to, if their are 40 people afk in the cave how much honor do they get? 0. Unrealistic? Ok their are 20 people afk, a new game starts every 3 mins so each game tends to have the same people. Horde or alliance only need to look at the scoreboard and see that going for total domination of the map and spending 2-3 mins longer to get the win for 60 more honor is feasible.

Each player afk lowers the potential for their side to get honor. Pre afk patch Horde often had few enough actually playing that their honor would not have passed 200 honor per hour let alone 1k.

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 11/07/07, 10:22 PM   #48
Yes
progamer
 
Yes's Avatar
 
Tauren Druid
 
Dragonmaw
Originally Posted by Ngita View Post
Getting off topic but I dont feel this should be advocated and unreplied to, if their are 40 people afk in the cave how much honor do they get? 0. Unrealistic? Ok their are 20 people afk, a new game starts every 3 mins so each game tends to have the same people. Horde or alliance only need to look at the scoreboard and see that going for total domination of the map and spending 2-3 mins longer to get the win for 60 more honor is feasible.

Each player afk lowers the potential for their side to get honor. Pre afk patch Horde often had few enough actually playing that their honor would not have passed 200 honor per hour let alone 1k.
If 'their' are 40 people AFK in the cave the first side to get an active tank and a healer will quickly kill the npcs and get a ton of honor. I see that you have 6585 lifetime honorable kills. I really do not think you understand what kind of an annoyance it has been to grind honor again and again and again and again. The novelty of playing PUG PvP via the solo queueing has worn of years ago.


Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 11/07/07, 10:56 PM   #49
Elendril
KIND OF A BIG DEAL
 
Elendril's Avatar
 
Night Elf Hunter
 
Ner'zhul
I am typing this as I just noticed I got AFK'd out of AV 5 minutes ago - I have 107K lifetime honorable kills on my hunter, and my alt druid was rank 13 pre-BC. I have absolutely no desire to ever do pug BGs again, except perhaps on a lark to play with a new weapon. The BG honor grind is pretty much the worst element left in WoW, and I have absolutely no qualms about shadowmelding in Icewing Bunker throughout AV weekend to get my points and get out.

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 11/07/07, 11:47 PM   #50
Calantus
Custom User Title
 
Calantus's Avatar
 
Dwarf Paladin
 
Frostmourne
Originally Posted by Ngita View Post
Getting off topic but I dont feel this should be advocated and unreplied to, if their are 40 people afk in the cave how much honor do they get? 0. Unrealistic? Ok their are 20 people afk, a new game starts every 3 mins so each game tends to have the same people. Horde or alliance only need to look at the scoreboard and see that going for total domination of the map and spending 2-3 mins longer to get the win for 60 more honor is feasible.

Each player afk lowers the potential for their side to get honor. Pre afk patch Horde often had few enough actually playing that their honor would not have passed 200 honor per hour let alone 1k.
The content is beyond stale already and they require you to play the damn things way more than you would normally just want to play the same thing. AFK is the only thing that keeps me sane for more than 1 game at a time. Less honor is a fine price to pay for not playing the BG.

Originally Posted by Elendril View Post
BG honor grind is pretty much the worst element left in WoW, and I have absolutely no qualms about shadowmelding in Icewing Bunker throughout AV weekend to get my points and get out.
I'm quite partial to Snowfall Graveyard myself. Or another thing I like to do is AFK just south of the Dun'Modor (sp?) South Tower and ninja it back right near the end for kicks and giggles.

Offline
Reply With Quote
Reply

Go Back   Elitist Jerks » Player vs. Player

Thread Tools

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
TBC Release date Pedesvir Public Discussion 70 11/10/06 3:07 PM
TBC Release date Awaa Public Discussion 162 10/25/06 7:47 PM
TBC Launch date? james The Dung Heap 3 10/17/06 4:14 PM