Elitist Jerks
Register
Blogs
Forums


Go Back   Elitist Jerks » Death Knights

Closed Thread
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
Old 10/27/08, 4:18 PM   #3301
Moratia
Von Kaiser
 
Moratia's Avatar
 
Troll Priest
 
Dalaran (EU)
I am really not sur UB is boost by crypt fever, it make no sense since UB isn't a disease.
I think more the 30% increase damage come from the increase of AP scale made the confusion.

Someone can test on a puppet ?

Store 100 RP, change puppet and just let UB make damage without hitting the puppet (leaving it without crypt fever).
Then, do it again with crypt fever on the puppet and compare both dps.

At the same time, check combat log (not addon or else which can have mistake) to see if it can critic or not.

I think it won't be increase by crypt fever and won't critic but like that we'll be sur of it.

Offline
Old 10/27/08, 4:28 PM   #3302
Flamingcloud
Great Tiger
 
Goblin Warlock
 
Cho'gall
Originally Posted by Moratia View Post
I am really not sur UB is boost by crypt fever, it make no sense since UB isn't a disease.
I think more the 30% increase damage come from the increase of AP scale made the confusion.

Someone can test on a puppet ?

Store 100 RP, change puppet and just let UB make damage without hitting the puppet (leaving it without crypt fever).
Then, do it again with crypt fever on the puppet and compare both dps.

At the same time, check combat log (not addon or else which can have mistake) to see if it can critic or not.

I think it won't be increase by crypt fever and won't critic but like that we'll be sur of it.
Just tested this again to make sure it is still the case. Both death & decay and unholy blight are affected by crypt fever.

86dmg with nothing, 139 with fever, ebon. 86*1.3*1.1*1.13 = 138.96

Offline
Old 10/27/08, 4:28 PM   #3303
methods
Piston Honda
 
methods's Avatar
 
Human Death Knight
 
Frostmane
Originally Posted by Flamingcloud View Post
A fight would have to be pretty short to not want to apply diseases and do 0 disease SS or Obliterates instead, like maybe 4-5 second fights, anything longer and you are better just doing something else. In pvp there is many reasons to disease, attack speed reduction, dot cleansing, death strike healing, dps that ignores armor, etc. I would think ideally you would want to get in a situation where your diseases are up and you have near 100 runic power and then just unload as much as you can for the maximum burst.
Did some quick combos and found that the highest damage output in a 4.5 second window (3 GcD's) is most likely PS->IT->SS and if you have one more cooldown DC. This is obviously for an Unholy spec and not so obviously includes desecration.

Offline
Old 10/27/08, 4:31 PM   #3304
 Embar
Bugsby's Expressive Single Digit!
 
Embar's Avatar
 
Issar
Orc Hunter
 
No WoW Account
Originally Posted by Zurm View Post
Yea, I believe the issue is not the hitbox, per say, but rather the circle. Just something to watch out for, I doubt it's the only boss with that situation.
It's either the circle, or the center of the hitbox. I've noticed this previously as well on several other bosses including Thaddius and Malygos. When UB was still a disease affecting SS, this was quite a noticeable issue.

On occasion, English has pursued other languages down alleyways to beat them unconscious and rifle their pockets for new vocabulary. -- James Nicoll

Canada Offline
Old 10/27/08, 4:34 PM   #3305
Flamingcloud
Great Tiger
 
Goblin Warlock
 
Cho'gall
Originally Posted by methods View Post
Did some quick combos and found that the highest damage output in a 4.5 second window (3 GcD's) is most likely PS->IT->SS and if you have one more cooldown DC. This is obviously for an Unholy spec and not so obviously includes desecration.
Right but going onto a mob and going oblit oblit (or ss) only works if you are going to be having travel time to the next mob to get those runes back, it may be better to be doing less to the first target if it means that all your runes aren't all on CD for target two. Still a situation like this is so rare that it may not even be worth discussing. Only real place where this could come up is in 5s when you deathgrip someone to your team and want to have the absolute most burst before their healer gets his heal off. Any kind of outlast pvp you will be putting your diseases up unless you are having issues with them getting dispelled.

Originally Posted by Embar View Post
It's either the circle, or the center of the hitbox. I've noticed this previously as well on several other bosses including Thaddius and Malygos. When UB was still a disease affecting SS, this was quite a noticeable issue.
Not sure how this is an issue on thaddius, you do not need to dps from max range to not zap the other group, infact ideally you will be the closest you can to the other group without zapping them. That distance is definitely within 10 yards of the center of his hitbox let alone the outside of the circle. The radius of the zap is only 10 yards so you have an extra 10 yard worth of playing room.

Offline
Old 10/27/08, 6:12 PM   #3306
Moratia
Von Kaiser
 
Moratia's Avatar
 
Troll Priest
 
Dalaran (EU)
Originally Posted by Flamingcloud View Post
Just tested this again to make sure it is still the case. Both death & decay and unholy blight are affected by crypt fever.

86dmg with nothing, 139 with fever, ebon. 86*1.3*1.1*1.13 = 138.96
You made this test with how many AP ?

Does it get critical hit ?

Offline
Old 10/27/08, 6:15 PM   #3307
 Zurm
The Ultimate in /facepalm Technology
 
Zurm's Avatar
 
Worgen Rogue
 
Bonechewer
Originally Posted by Moratia View Post
I am really not sur UB is boost by crypt fever, it make no sense since UB isn't a disease.
It is, I've verified this multiple times since the nerf. That being said, it doesn't APPLY crypt fever/ebon plague... only an applicate of FF or BP would do that.

Edit: And yes, individual hits of UB can crit from my experience.

Formally Xyrm/Zurm, the Ret Pally. Now playing my rogue, Zyrm, more casually with RL friends.

Offline
Old 10/27/08, 6:22 PM   #3308
Flamingcloud
Great Tiger
 
Goblin Warlock
 
Cho'gall
Originally Posted by Moratia View Post
You made this test with how many AP ?

Does it get critical hit ?
No it doesn't critical. How much ap I had is irrelevant, I was only testing that it was affected by crypt fever. It definitely 100% cannot crit. If you see something on sct that sort of looks like a UB crit it was probably a BCB proc.

Offline
Old 10/27/08, 6:45 PM   #3309
 Embar
Bugsby's Expressive Single Digit!
 
Embar's Avatar
 
Issar
Orc Hunter
 
No WoW Account
Originally Posted by Flamingcloud View Post
Not sure how this is an issue on thaddius, you do not need to dps from max range to not zap the other group, infact ideally you will be the closest you can to the other group without zapping them. That distance is definitely within 10 yards of the center of his hitbox let alone the outside of the circle. The radius of the zap is only 10 yards so you have an extra 10 yard worth of playing room.
The group I used to pug with insisted on melee DPSing from max range while stacking with the ranged for maximum buffs, so I found out that way. *shrug* Nevertheless, the point does stand that on any fight where you may have to DPS from max melee range, you might lose the effect of Unholy Blight.

On occasion, English has pursued other languages down alleyways to beat them unconscious and rifle their pockets for new vocabulary. -- James Nicoll

Canada Offline
Old 10/27/08, 6:48 PM   #3310
Moratia
Von Kaiser
 
Moratia's Avatar
 
Troll Priest
 
Dalaran (EU)
Originally Posted by Flamingcloud View Post
No it doesn't critical. How much ap I had is irrelevant, I was only testing that it was affected by crypt fever. It definitely 100% cannot crit. If you see something on sct that sort of looks like a UB crit it was probably a BCB proc.
it is really relevant, we think Ap coeff base is 1.3, but it could still be 1 and the +0.3 went from crypt fever.
Only one site said the coefficient was bump to 1.3, it worth to make a verification.

Offline
Old 10/27/08, 6:52 PM   #3311
Flamingcloud
Great Tiger
 
Goblin Warlock
 
Cho'gall
Originally Posted by Moratia View Post
it is really relevant, we think Ap coeff base is 1.3, but it could still be 1 and the +0.3 went from crypt fever.
Only one site said the coefficient was bump to 1.3, it worth to make a verification.
If someone else wants to test the AP coefficient again they can go ahead I am not going to, and it had nothing to do with the tests I ran. I agree that it is possible it is still 1.0 and some one just though crypt fever didn't affect it.

Offline
Old 10/27/08, 7:30 PM   #3312
Moratia
Von Kaiser
 
Moratia's Avatar
 
Troll Priest
 
Dalaran (EU)
Originally Posted by Flamingcloud View Post
If someone else wants to test the AP coefficient again they can go ahead I am not going to, and it had nothing to do with the tests I ran. I agree that it is possible it is still 1.0 and some one just though crypt fever didn't affect it.
it's senseless testing if crypt fever increase UB damage if you aren't even sur which is the base coefficient take by UB.
Even more with the "supposed" up of AP coefficient is exactly the same as crypt fever.

If i hade a beta key i could make the test myself but that is not the case, someone can run the test ?

Offline
Old 10/27/08, 9:38 PM   #3313
methods
Piston Honda
 
methods's Avatar
 
Human Death Knight
 
Frostmane
Originally Posted by Moratia View Post
it's senseless testing if crypt fever increase UB damage if you aren't even sur which is the base coefficient take by UB.
Even more with the "supposed" up of AP coefficient is exactly the same as crypt fever.

If i hade a beta key i could make the test myself but that is not the case, someone can run the test ?
What he is saying is that Ap had nothing to do with the increase from crypt fever, rage of rivendare and ebonplague which is pretty damn close to what he tested to be true.

Offline
Old 10/28/08, 12:01 AM   #3314
Kaejin
Great Tiger
 
Kaejin's Avatar
 
Troll Death Knight
 
Mal'Ganis
Does parry haste count as a "Haste Effect" as far as Heart Strike is concerned? I've lurked in this thread for a while and don't remember any mention of this before.

It seems to me that as long as at least one Blood DK was in the raid, whatever DK is tanking (be it the Blood DK himself or some other DK) would be free to DW tank and reap the benefits of two tanking one-handers.

Offline
Old 10/28/08, 12:31 AM   #3315
Clandestine
Don Flamenco
 
Clandestine's Avatar
 
Human Rogue
 
Laughing Skull
Stroke doesn't really work as advertised, not really sure how it's working right now. It feels like it doesn't do anything at all in PvE, and in PvP it feels like it's applying a Tongues and super Thunderclap. I haven't done any extensive testing on it.

Offline
Old 10/28/08, 12:53 AM   #3316
Caggy
Von Kaiser
 
Tauren Hunter
 
Azjol-Nerub
Shouldn't affect casting unless except for bloodlust. Probalby IV too. Parry haste isn't normal haste. It resets the swing timer, it doesn't speed it up.

Offline
Old 10/28/08, 1:32 AM   #3317
Zurai
Bald Bull
 
Orc Death Knight
 
Whisperwind
Originally Posted by Moratia View Post
it's senseless testing if crypt fever increase UB damage if you aren't even sur which is the base coefficient take by UB.
Even more with the "supposed" up of AP coefficient is exactly the same as crypt fever.

If i hade a beta key i could make the test myself but that is not the case, someone can run the test ?
How much AP he had and the magnitude of the coefficient are completely irrelevant to his test. He tested how much damage it did with no relevant talents (86), then how much it did with crypt fever, ebon plague, and rage of rivendare talented (139). The two results matched perfectly with crypt fever being applied to UB's damage, and the testing was performed in a manner that made attack power utterly irrelevant, as it was the same at all points of the test and none of the mentioned talents changed the coefficient.

Unholy Blight cannot crit, and hasn't been able to for several patches now, so the only possible conclusion we can draw is that CF affects UB.

Offline
Old 10/28/08, 1:33 AM   #3318
Amare
Glass Joe
 
Orc Death Knight
 
Khaz'goroth (EU)
After a parry the next autoattack is being done immediately, so basically yes it does speed up the swing timer and it also resets it since 1 attack is done immediately.
That's from what I understand at least.

Offline
Old 10/28/08, 1:58 AM   #3319
Aezoc
Piston Honda
 
Orc Death Knight
 
Scilla
Originally Posted by Amare View Post
After a parry the next autoattack is being done immediately, so basically yes it does speed up the swing timer and it also resets it since 1 attack is done immediately.
That's from what I understand at least.
It's not a true haste effect and therefore not affected by heart strike is the point. Nobody's debating the existence of parry haste.

Offline
Old 10/28/08, 2:58 AM   #3320
Moratia
Von Kaiser
 
Moratia's Avatar
 
Troll Priest
 
Dalaran (EU)
Originally Posted by Zurai View Post
How much AP he had and the magnitude of the coefficient are completely irrelevant to his test. He tested how much damage it did with no relevant talents (86), then how much it did with crypt fever, ebon plague, and rage of rivendare talented (139). The two results matched perfectly with crypt fever being applied to UB's damage, and the testing was performed in a manner that made attack power utterly irrelevant, as it was the same at all points of the test and none of the mentioned talents changed the coefficient.

Unholy Blight cannot crit, and hasn't been able to for several patches now, so the only possible conclusion we can draw is that CF affects UB.
He ran it without crypt/ebon/rage and it get 86 dmg per tick, it mean AP contribution would be 86-48=38

AP's Coefficient = 38*100/AP

If he had 3800 AP, coefficient is 1 and if he hade 2923 AP the coefficient is 1.3.

Offline
Old 10/28/08, 4:22 AM   #3321
Nethris
Piston Honda
 
Night Elf Druid
 
Scilla
Originally Posted by Kaejin View Post
Does parry haste count as a "Haste Effect" as far as Heart Strike is concerned? I've lurked in this thread for a while and don't remember any mention of this before.

It seems to me that as long as at least one Blood DK was in the raid, whatever DK is tanking (be it the Blood DK himself or some other DK) would be free to DW tank and reap the benefits of two tanking one-handers.
As has been mentioned, parry "haste" is such a drastically different mechanic that heart strike is rather unlikely to affect it, as Blizzard would have had to specifically go change the parry mechanic code, and it would be odd if they hadn't mentioned that large of an advantage to tanking by now. Now, with expertise gems available in WotLK, at some point it may be a tanking stat gain to replace other gems with expertise and switch to double tanking one-handers, and at the very least it will be viable at some point to hit the expertise cap - the main barrier is keeping uncrittable status, which requires a major focus on defense in gear and gems until gear upgrades can be obtained.

Of course, with the removal of crushing blows in raid tanking, there is the question of whether an avoidance tank like DKs are looking to end up being would take less average damage not bothering with reaching the expertise cap even when dual wielding and focusing on more avoidance, as parry haste will only be painful and not a potential to not only take extra damage, but to have back to back crushing blows suddenly... and if a single extra hit can kill the tank, the possibility will exist with a two-hander as well, and for every other tank. Just don't tell your healers/raid leaders that you're ignoring parry haste, even if you end up deciding that's the best path to take

Edit: it did just occur to me that modeling how much benefit we get from parrying a boss's attacks might influence the 2h/DW numbers for tanking as well, as getting parry haste favors slower, harder hitting attacks... not that the efforts to try to theory craft DKs need more complications added :P

Last edited by Nethris : 10/28/08 at 4:29 AM. Reason: typo

Offline
Old 10/28/08, 9:13 AM   #3322
CumpsD
Glass Joe
 
Blood Elf Rogue
 
Sporeggar (EU)
After having read through all 132 pages (so much great info, and nice to see the evolution) I'm in the progress of making up my mind for an end-game and leveling build.

After some searching I'm confused about the 2 speed increase talents in Unholy. I was wondering if anyone on beta could tell me if Unholy Aura also increases mount speed, or if I really need On A Pale Horse for it?

Google searches give conflicting answers, and I'm having problems with the search on this forum, too many results with the world "unholy" in it I think.

Offline
Old 10/28/08, 9:21 AM   #3323
pldcanfly
Glass Joe
 
pldcanfly's Avatar
 
Night Elf Warrior
 
Baelgun (EU)
Originally Posted by CumpsD View Post
After having read through all 132 pages (so much great info, and nice to see the evolution) I'm in the progress of making up my mind for an end-game and leveling build.

After some searching I'm confused about the 2 speed increase talents in Unholy. I was wondering if anyone on beta could tell me if Unholy Aura also increases mount speed, or if I really need On A Pale Horse for it?

Google searches give conflicting answers, and I'm having problems with the search on this forum, too many results with the world "unholy" in it I think.
i havent noticed any speed increase while mounted. Maybe it's just my own subjective opinion.
I can verfiy it @home in 2-3 hours.

Offline
Old 10/28/08, 9:40 AM   #3324
Flamingcloud
Great Tiger
 
Goblin Warlock
 
Cho'gall
Originally Posted by Moratia View Post
He ran it without crypt/ebon/rage and it get 86 dmg per tick, it mean AP contribution would be 86-48=38

AP's Coefficient = 38*100/AP

If he had 3800 AP, coefficient is 1 and if he hade 2923 AP the coefficient is 1.3.
Actually I had much less than 2923, but I had impurity. When I logged on today with horn up I have 2445 and UB is still hitting for 86 a tick.


99% sure unholy aura doesn't affect mount speed. The two school of thought with regards to leveling are go blood for max surviability/lowest downtime or go unholy for aoe and increased movement speed. Couldn't say which way is better.

Offline
Old 10/28/08, 9:50 AM   #3325
 Zurm
The Ultimate in /facepalm Technology
 
Zurm's Avatar
 
Worgen Rogue
 
Bonechewer
I tried unholy and blood for leveling... and I found I had no downtime with unholy either. Plus, that was back when DK coefficients were all messed up, and the ghoul was almost half my damage. I've slowly been starting one a second time through and I still prefer unholy.

Formally Xyrm/Zurm, the Ret Pally. Now playing my rogue, Zyrm, more casually with RL friends.

Offline
Closed Thread

Go Back   Elitist Jerks » Death Knights

Thread Tools

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
WotLK Talents & Abilities Discussion Neruse Hunters 5086 11/14/08 9:39 PM
Feral talents/abilities - WotLK discussion Rannasha Druids 3759 11/14/08 10:56 AM

« - | DPS Compendium »