I'm seeing some strangeness in the sim. All simulations were done with the following gear set:
Kayfas @ Lothar - Game - World of Warcraft
First Sim, 2H unholy:
DPS 18500(+/- 2022)
Total Damage 6660.09m
EP values for said sim:
EP AttackPower 0.65 DPS
EP Strength 2.56
EP Agility 1
EP CritRating 0.6
EP MasteryRating 0.68
EP HasteRating 1.06
EP ExpertiseRating 0.92
Before Melee Hit Cap 0.94
EP SpellHitRating 0
EP WeaponDPS 3.8
EP WeaponSpeed 380
EP 2T10 295
EP 4T10 312
EP 2T11 132
EP 4T11 245
You will of course note the sky high value of expertise relative to crit and mastery.
So I think "well, golly I should reforge some excess crit and mastery to expertise", so I look and pretty quickly discover I only have I can only reforge about 100 mastery into expertise without sacrificing either haste or hit rating. This effectively bumps me from 4 to 8 expertise.
So I run the sim on this new set of stats:
DPS 18183(+/- 1846)
Total Damage 6546m
Well, that's strange. Even though expertise is rated roughly 50% higher than mastery and I'm no where near the expertise cap reforging expertise yields a fairly significant DPS loss. So I think to myself, "maybe it's a middle ground effect, where just a bit of expertise is enough to counteract the GCD capping of having high haste and a haste trinket. So of the two items available for reforging I reforge one to mastery and one to haste, giving about a 50/50 split, here are the results:
DPS 18485(+/- 1680)
Total Damage 6654.73m
Still lower, but better than when I simply reforged to expertise, potentially you could chock it up to RNG and say they're even given the variance, however given that expertise was weighted more heavily than mastery by 50% and a swing as small as ~50 expertise rating yields such strange results seems fishy to me.
I chock it up to the sim being a bit funny lately and go about simming other things, this time, 2H frost because my guild has asked me to spec chillblains while we work on Cho'gal for the blood of the old god adds, without reforging from my main spec (2H unholy) I get the following results:
DPS 18718(+/- 1629)
Total Damage 6738.6m
218 DPS switching to a spec that is supposedly the worst DPS spec available to DKs from what is supposedly the best dps spec, sets off a few alarms for one - especially given that I left reforging as it would be for unholy. Admittedly, the difference in gear is minimal - I'd simply prioritize hit > Exp > Haste > Mastery > Crit instead of hit/haste > Mastery > Expertise > Crit,
I haven't made any modifications to the sim, and the sim has produced the same results on multiple sims for me. Anyone know anything? It seems to me that the sim has been acting very strangely lately, this is the first documentation I am capable of providing, although certainly not the first I've experienced.