So, Just did a Major Upgrade, I added proper links and correct the drop info on all known items (Mainly the Set pieces). There are very few items left with unkown drop locations.

Also note that I excluded the SBV/SBR items and everything with Ilvl<219 I also didn't add the Set drops from Emalon.

Hope you appreciate the list.

Also: Suno is trying to make a BiS list for tanks in his post. But I'd suggest keeping discussions about items in this post as much as possible and leave Suno's post for theorycrafting around tanking itself.

8.5: Updated (thanks to Cloudgatherer and Vynn)

9.5: Yet another Update (Thanks to filed magrat and Crona)

13.5 Update: thanks to Giske and Cloudgatherer

Head:
Ilvl: 226 [Conqueror's Darkruned Faceguard] Thorim 25 Man / 58 Emblembs of Conquest
Ilvl: 226 [Helm of the Faceless] General Vezax 25 Man
Ilvl: 219 [Ironbark Faceguard] Freya 10 Man
Ilv:l 219 [Valorous Darkruned Faceguard] Mimiron 10 Man

Neck:

239 [Bronze Pendant of the Vanir] Freya 25 Man Hard Mode
226 [Titanstone Pendant] Trash Mobs 25 Man
226 [Shard of the Crystal Forest] 19 Emblems of Conquest
219 [Mark of the Unyielding] Kologarn 10 Man
219 [Fervor of the Protectorate] Trash Mobs 10 Man

Shoulders:

226 [Conqueror's Darkruned Pauldrons] Yogg Saron 25 Man
226 [Shoulderplates of the Deconstructor] XT-002 Deconstructor 25 Man
219 [Valorous Darkruned Pauldrons] Thorim 10 Man

Cloak:

239 [Titanskin Cloak] Mimiron 25 Man HardMode
226 [Cloak of the Makers] Auriaya 25 Man
219 [Saronite Animus Cloak] General Vezax 10 Man

Chest:

226 [Conqueror's Darkruned Chestguard] Hodir 25 Man / 58 Emblems of Conquest
226 Breastplate of the Timeless Algalon 10 Man
219 [Valorous Darkruned Chestguard] Yogg-Saron 10 Man

Wrists:

226 [Mimiron's Inferno Couplings] Flame Leviathan 25 Man
219 [Flamewatch Armguards] Flame Leviathan 10 Man

Hands:

239 [Handguards of Revitalization] Freya 25 Man HardMode
226 [Conqueror's Darkruned Handguards] Mimiron 25 Man
226 [Gauntlets of the Royal Watch] 28 Emblems of Conquest
219 [Valorous Darkruned Handguards] Freya 10 Man
219 [Gauntlets of the Iron Furnace] Ignis the Furnace Master 10 Man

Belt:

226 [Indestructible Plate Girdle] Blacksmithing Recipe
226 [Shieldwarder Girdle] 28 Emblems of Conquest
219 [Stormtempered Girdle] Razorscale 10 Man

Legs:

239 [Legplates of the Endless Void] Algalon 25 Man
226 [Conqueror's Darkruned Legguards] Freya 25 Man
226 [Gilded Steel Legplates] Flame Leviathan 10 Man HardMode
226 [Saronite Plated Legguards] Kologarn 25 Man
219 [Archaedas' Lost Legplates] Auriaya 10 Man
219 [Valorous Darkruned Legguards] Hodir 10 Man

Feet:

226 [Charred Saronite Greaves] Razorscale 25 Man
226 [Spiked Deathdealers] Blacksmithing Recipe

Fingers:
239 [Fate's Clutch] Thorim 25 Man Hard Mode
226 [Seal of Ulduar] XT-002 25 Man
226 [The Leviathan's Coil] Flame Leviathan 25 Man
226 [Platinum Band of the Aesir] Auriaya 25 Man
219 [Signet of Winter] Hodir 10 Man

Trinkets:

226 [Heart of Iron] Ignis the Furnace Master 25 Man
226 [The General's Heart] General Vezax 25 Man
219 [Royal Seal of King Llane] Yogg-Saron 10 Man
219 [Furnace Stone] Ignis the Furnace Master 10 Man

Two-Handed Weapon:

239 [Dark Edge of Depravity] Yogg-Saron 25 Man HardMode
239 [Voldrethar, Dark Blade of Oblivion] General Vezax 25 Man HardMode
232 [Aesir's Edge] Xt-002 10 Man HardMode
232 [Earthshaper] Yogg-Saron 25 Man
232 [Worldcarver] Ignis the Furnace Master 25 Man
232 [Stormrune Edge] Iron Council 25 Man
226 [Hammer of Crushing Whispers] Yogg Saron 10 Man HardMode
219 [Abaddon] Yogg-Saron 10 Man
219 [Ironsoul] Flame Leviathan 10 Man
219 [Stormedge] Hodir 10 Man
219 [Hoperender] Thorim 10 Man

One-Handed Weapons:

239 [Sorthalis, Hammer of the Watchers] XT-002 Deconstructor 25 Man Hard Mode
226 [Shiver] Hodir 10 Man
232 [Titanguard] Flame Leviathan 25 Man
219 [Legacy of Thunder] Thorim 10 Man
219 [Stoneguard] Kologarn 10 Man

Sigil

226 [Sigil of Deflection] Razorscale 25 Man
226 [Sigil of the Vengeful Heart] XT-002 25 Man

I think you really need to denote which of those are the iLvl 239 items. Sure, I'd take a Bronze Pendant of the Vanir any day, but so would everyone else and that's either a hard mode item or a YS item. In the interim, Shard of the Crystal Forest is likely to be the most common 226 tanking item. I'd also add the set pieces we know about, but frankly I'm pretty disappointed they are all "parry" based items, and will likely not be picked up by DKs. Here's a couple items to consider:

Shard of the Crystal Forest - neck
Cloak of the Makers - back
Shieldwarders Girdle - is a waist item not a wrist item
Wyrmguard Legplates - looks like they changed them to have shield values

As far as weapons go, it's looking like Voldrethar will be highly sought after with Worldcarver the likely 2nd and most common choice.

I'd add the Setpieces, but the only thing I could find were the Screenshots from MMO-Champion, so I posted those above.

Concerning the Emblems items: I'm unsure about them, because the MMO-Champ screenshots list some of them without SV/SBR...but I'll trust WoWHead on this one.

Thanks for the tipps, I'll make some Itemlevelranking throughout the week (or if I get benched in today's raid)

Bronze Pendant of the Vanir is from Freya on hard-mode.

I too agree that iLevels should be listed either right before or right after the item link, it makes it easier to differentiate at a glance without having to read the description.

The link to the Valorous Darkruned Faceguard is faulty.

What do you mean by faulty? It is working just fine for me.

Updated, thanks for the help and suggestions till now!

All defensive 1H weapons are fast and therefore favor parry-gibbing. Also, weapon based strikes suck even more with fast 1H weapons. I wonder if Blizzard is trying to tell DW DK tanks that they should not be dual-wielding.

I posted it because it might be an upgrade for some people.

I don know some tanks who still wear one or another ilvl 200 Chest/should, whatever simply because they had no luck with drops or did not have enough DKP.

Even though I agree with you, most people who raid 25 man Ulduar will have (or at least will be close to) BiS it still might help one or two people.

And for the confusion: I think most people on these forum are clever enough to recognize what item suits them, and what does not.

I doubt it would be an upgrade beyond Strength, Stamina, and Defense. I would imagine it to be more of a downgrade since you would lose dodge, parry, expertise, or hit rating.

The Worldcarver should be the first weapon for dk 2H tanking : it has the highest stamina + a huge bunch of expertise and for an orc dk like me even more.

The dark blade of oblivion is much more a dps weapon and i won't roll on it , plus it dropped in hard mode so i highly doubt we'll see plenty of them.