Elitist Jerks
Register
Blogs
Forums


Go Back   Elitist Jerks » Class Mechanics » Druids

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
Old 10/19/12, 5:10 AM   #76
Regallion
Glass Joe
 
Regallion's Avatar
 
Night Elf Druid
 
Борейская Тундра (EU)
Can i get some perspective on glyph on shred? so far i find it extremely useless(not even situational) since incarnation makes it totally obsolete, and using it without incarnation only allows you to shred during berserk(and maybe once or twice doing TF uptime) which, with bulk of our DPS being bleeds seems like a prety marginal DPS increase.

Oh and about the guide
1. It says
Tranquility You may be a kitty, but your spellpower is still boosted by your Agility. Additionally, if you have Dream of Cenarius, your Tranquility will be buffed by your prior melee abilities. This can save the raid if used correctly.
But! DoC specifically doesn't boost tranq! what kind of mind games are afoot here?
2.
Stampeding Roar This makes you and everyone else in near you run 60% faster. This can be invaluable for handling raid mechanics.
That one seems to give much more speed... at least to the druid using it. It actually makes me run faster than dash does!(at least in cat form)

3. As much as i LOVE having stat weights of 4pc high-ilvl gear can we get some weights for 489-496 ilvls with no pieces?

Last edited by Regallion : 10/19/12 at 9:34 AM.

Russia Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 10/19/12, 11:36 AM   #77
Numiro
Von Kaiser
 
Worgen Druid
 
Ravencrest (EU)
Originally Posted by Fengel View Post
I have a question I hope to get an answer too. Crystal of Insanity - Item - World of Warcraft, is an item that works like elixirs, giving a 500 all stats buff. The strangest thing about this is, when I have this on and then try to use a +1k agi flask, the system tells me I can't because there is a more powerfull buff active. Thus I have to remove the 500stats buff manually and apply the flask then. I was wondering why the system would prevent me to use my flask when I have that items buff active. After all, agi is much better for a kitty. Sure, the 500 stamina is handy to have, and 500 strenght is a nice AP buff, but still Agi is our strongest stat. Should I keep using the item's buff then? Or just do as normal and use flasks?
It says exactly the same for all flasks, atleast that's what I've noticed the couple of times I've switched specc mid raid and tried to pop an agility flask over my intellect flask. It's blizzards way of help you not overwrite your flasks.

Is there any more information regarding HotW? According to sim craft HotW tends to favour all other stats then haste now and I'm assuming that's because of the active nerf, is this correct in general or just for my gear?

Sweden Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 10/19/12, 12:38 PM   #78
Authopsy
Glass Joe
 
Authopsy's Avatar
 
Night Elf Druid
 
Garona (EU)
Originally Posted by Regallion View Post
Can i get some perspective on glyph on shred? so far i find it extremely useless(not even situational) since incarnation makes it totally obsolete, and using it without incarnation only allows you to shred during berserk(and maybe once or twice doing TF uptime) which, with bulk of our DPS being bleeds seems like a prety marginal DPS increase.

Oh and about the guide
1. It says
But! DoC specifically doesn't boost tranq! what kind of mind games are afoot here?
2.

That one seems to give much more speed... at least to the druid using it. It actually makes me run faster than dash does!(at least in cat form)

3. As much as i LOVE having stat weights of 4pc high-ilvl gear can we get some weights for 489-496 ilvls with no pieces?

I don't think the glyph of stampeding roar gives you extra speed. You are just speckled into feline swiftness. This talent stacks with the roar but not with dash I suppose.

For the stat weights, you should simulate them yourself. The new simcraft with the GUI is ridiculously easy to use if you just want the weights. It will be more accurate for you and with a little bit of practice you will be able to mess with the priority list

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 10/19/12, 4:52 PM   #79
Jazdia
Von Kaiser
 
Jazdia's Avatar
 
Night Elf Druid
 
Mannoroth
Originally Posted by Regallion View Post
Can i get some perspective on glyph on shred? so far i find it extremely useless(not even situational) since incarnation makes it totally obsolete, and using it without incarnation only allows you to shred during berserk(and maybe once or twice doing TF uptime) which, with bulk of our DPS being bleeds seems like a prety marginal DPS increase.
It is a marginal increase, but it's still an increase, which most glyphs don't give anymore. As an example, I use it very frequently on Heroic Feng as the mechanics and our strategy force me to be in front of the boss many times when berserk or TF is up.

Originally Posted by Regallion View Post
1. But! DoC specifically doesn't boost tranq! what kind of mind games are afoot here?
Good catch, corrected DoC to HotW.

Originally Posted by Regallion View Post
2. That one seems to give much more speed... at least to the druid using it. It actually makes me run faster than dash does!(at least in cat form)
Stampeding Roar stacks with your passive movement speeds such as boot enchants, cat form, and the Tier 1 move-speed talent, if you got it. Thus you can find yourself going 210% - 245% of normal runspeed with it popped.

Originally Posted by Regallion View Post
3. As much as i LOVE having stat weights of 4pc high-ilvl gear can we get some weights for 489-496 ilvls with no pieces?
It would be nice, but it's difficult at the moment. The stat weightings I have right now aren't all perfect given the changes to HotW.
I simulate them at 100k iterations and have to do so for every talent combination, and to do so at each gear level I have to choose arbitrary sets of gear at a certain level, find the best possible set of reforges and enchants, and simulate , scaling for all stats, at 100k iterations. Given that due to our workload I haven't recently had available free time on our proton-sim computers to do the simulations, I would be stuck with doing them on my horrible single core workstation here. Needless to say that, while it's definitely possible and it is on my to-do list, it does take a little bit of time that I don't always have to spare.

This is why I placed the link to simcraft in the guide. If you (or anyone else) have a couple free hours and would like to put in the time to select multiple gearsets and make various profiles with the different talent combinations and do the simulations yourself and post the results, I would be more than happy to take a look at them and possibly update the guide with them if I can make them succinct enough. Other than that, it will have to wait until I have a little more spare time.

United States Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 10/23/12, 1:57 PM   #80
aggixx
Von Kaiser
 
aggixx's Avatar
 
Tauren Druid
 
Hyjal
Originally Posted by Regallion View Post
That one seems to give much more speed... at least to the druid using it. It actually makes me run faster than dash does!(at least in cat form)
This is because dash is slower not because Stampeding Roar is faster. During the MoP pre-expansion updates they hotfixed Dash so it no longer stacks with Cat Form, instead of increasing your run speed multiplicatively by 70% like it used to. Stampeding Roar, like pretty much every other movement speed effect in the game, still increases your run speed multiplicatively so if you're using Cat Form + Feline Swiftness + Runspeed to boots, it's actually increasing your run speed by 92%, compared to Dash which would only increase your move speed by 55%.

United States Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 10/24/12, 9:27 PM   #81
Suphix
Glass Joe
 
Worgen Death Knight
 
Argent Dawn (EU)
Maybe I am missing something. Perhaps one of you guys could tell me how this guy is seemingly able to have both Incarnation and Soul of the Forest at the same time in almost every fight? Is he really bothering to doctor the log for every fight or is this some strange bug?

World of Logs - Real Time Raid Analysis

EDIT - Actually appears he is gaining stampede not incarnation, still very strange.

Last edited by Suphix : 10/25/12 at 12:28 AM.

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 10/25/12, 2:21 AM   #82
Caltiom
Von Kaiser
 
Human Priest
 
Eredar (EU)
Originally Posted by Hamlet View Post
Coming over Moonkin thread--I'm trying to figure out some basic info about HotW DPS. I've figured out what my Agility and other stats are with it active, but I need to know how that translates into damage of Mangle, Rake, FB, and white DPS. I see the OP by and large references SimCraft for the underlying math--is anyone around here the person who manages the Cat SimCraft and/or knows the basic formulae for determining the damage these abilities do based on your attack power?
SimulationCraft mostly gets its damage formulas from the WoW InGame tooltips. There is the possibility to look at the action details in a SimC html report, where you can look at and double check if the static base numbers are correctly imported/implemented into the Simc action. Just expand a action to get to its details, and look at the numbers like base_dd_min, base_dd_max, direct_power_mod ( SP/AP scaling ), weapon_multiplier, etc.

For dynamic stuff and everything, you can usually look directly at the SimC Druid code - it's completely open source, with a lot of whitespaces and most things should be easy to read and understand even for people who never coded anything. For example rip: sc_druid.cpp - simulationcraft - World of Warcraft DPS Simulator - Google Project Hosting ( line 2021 to 2045 ), where you can see how to tick_power_mod ( the AP scaling for the dot part ) is scaled by the amount of combo points you have.

If you want to double check the attack model besides the AP scaling of a ability, you'll have to go out of the class code into the action core code of SimC - a bit more complicated. We are pretty confident that everything there works exactly as it does InGame, but feel free to check.

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 10/25/12, 4:05 AM   #83
Robosaurus
Von Kaiser
 
Robosaurus's Avatar
 
Tauren Druid
 
Khaz'goroth
Originally Posted by Suphix View Post
Maybe I am missing something. Perhaps one of you guys could tell me how this guy is seemingly able to have both Incarnation and Soul of the Forest at the same time in almost every fight? Is he really bothering to doctor the log for every fight or is this some strange bug?

World of Logs - Real Time Raid Analysis

EDIT - Actually appears he is gaining stampede not incarnation, still very strange.
PvP 4piece. I highly recommend it if you're not likely to get 502+ in 3 slots within the next 2-3 weeks.

It is quite useful for DoC as it bounces you between finishes reliably, on Beta I was using it 15s offset from TF to bounce faster. Very strong set bonus.

In other news, Displacer Beast is a nice way to pump some extra DPS out. I estimate 1.5-2% dps increase if used correctly.
Link below:
Displacer Beast is a DPS talent? - YouTube

You can use it on the following encounters this tier with relative ease:
MV: Feng, Gara'jal, Will of the Emperor
HoF: Blade Lord, Wind Lord (execute), Amber Shaper
ToES: Sha of Fear

Last edited by Robosaurus : 10/26/12 at 2:13 PM. Reason: added where to use

DoC for life. Because Wrath spam is too hard.

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 10/31/12, 5:42 AM   #84
Ilira
Glass Joe
 
Troll Druid
 
Durotan (EU)
Hi Guys!

I also have a question regarding my priority list or better what to do if...
I play with DoC and SoF and there are often moments, where I have prroblems deciding what would be the best choice.

Lets make an example:
Trinket procs are up, I have one charge left of my DoC and 5cp, but lets say 10 seconds left on my rip. If I don't clip the dot I will have problems getting it up in time and it will most probably not be an enhanced one (trinket doc).

There are several of these situations, but this is the one i am most troubling with.

Thanks
Knuet

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 11/01/12, 4:03 AM   #85
Rainman5419
Von Kaiser
 
Worgen Druid
 
Garona
Originally Posted by Ilira View Post
Hi Guys!

I also have a question regarding my priority list or better what to do if...
I play with DoC and SoF and there are often moments, where I have prroblems deciding what would be the best choice.

Lets make an example:
Trinket procs are up, I have one charge left of my DoC and 5cp, but lets say 10 seconds left on my rip. If I don't clip the dot I will have problems getting it up in time and it will most probably not be an enhanced one (trinket doc).

There are several of these situations, but this is the one i am most troubling with.

Thanks
Knuet
This doesn't really seem like a DoC problem, but more of a general energy/CP management problem. While this is sometimes unavoidable, the best answer to this is more practice. Read or reread the OP and get a feel for the CP/haste generation tempo your gear gives you on each boss. The most likely answer is that you're being less than efficient somewhere by energy capping, low CP SRing, or adding in too many FBs.

On the topic of DoC though, I haven't seen any discussion of DoC's value during Berserk. Assuming T14 gear levels and standard behavior(entering with high energy, not energy capping, standard priority) at what point is using the GCD to trigger DoC worth it, if at all?

United States Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 11/06/12, 9:53 AM   #86
Taxiwardance
Glass Joe
 
Tauren Druid
 
Magtheridon
You may want to add Spear of Xuen - Spell - World of Warcraft into the pre-raid and dungeon gear list. It is a Pandaren archeology rare, but has a 463 item level and is also Bind on Account and only requires level 85 to equip. It makes a great starter weapon for fresh 90's and a fantastic leveling weapon for ferals/guardians/brewmasters/windwalkers.

United States Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 11/07/12, 6:31 PM   #87
baver
Glass Joe
 
Night Elf Druid
 
Neptulon (EU)
Is there any highranked feraldruid thats using DOC right now? I feel that using wrath with hero + pot and crit banners from warriors is so much more dps then trying to max a rotation that noone will ever be able to do good enough to be realy worth it.

Also i would like to know if the op have updated the stats with hotw nerf? Becouse im going mastery > crit reforge and im doing more then well on the fights i can dps even when haste should be better?

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 11/08/12, 1:28 PM   #88
Smoketreez
Glass Joe
 
Worgen Druid
 
Stormrage
Originally Posted by baver View Post
Is there any highranked feraldruid thats using DOC right now? I feel that using wrath with hero + pot and crit banners from warriors is so much more dps then trying to max a rotation that noone will ever be able to do good enough to be realy worth it.

Also i would like to know if the op have updated the stats with hotw nerf? Becouse im going mastery > crit reforge and im doing more then well on the fights i can dps even when haste should be better?
Wrath is never worth using. Heart of the Wild is about 15k behind DoC on any given fight minus Wind Lord at the moment. DoC really isn't that 'hard' it's just a playstyle change that you have to adjust to.

Source: World of Logs - Real Time Raid Analysis

Last edited by Smoketreez : 11/08/12 at 1:37 PM.

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 11/08/12, 3:29 PM   #89
Abranor
Glass Joe
 
Night Elf Druid
 
Lightbringer
Originally Posted by Smoketreez View Post
Heart of the Wild is about 15k behind DoC on any given fight minus Wind Lord at the moment.

Source: World of Logs - Real Time Raid Analysis
You link all these WoL reports as your source but what are we looking at here? I agree HotW is lower than well executed DoC, but get someone without the right skill level and all your gains go out the window. Are there sims showing HotW that far behind?

Last edited by Abranor : 11/08/12 at 3:38 PM.

Offline
Reply With Quote
Old 11/08/12, 6:34 PM   #90
Leafkiller
Piston Honda
 
Worgen Druid
 
Stormrage
Originally Posted by Abranor View Post
You link all these WoL reports as your source but what are we looking at here? I agree HotW is lower than well executed DoC, but get someone without the right skill level and all your gains go out the window. Are there sims showing HotW that far behind?
No.

Unfortunately the most current feral script is not checked into Simulationcraft. It can be found here: The Fluid Druid - View topic - Experimental simulationcraft script

Last time I measured, passive HotW was about 3.8% behind DoC in the most recent simulations. Also the sims show that using Wrath spam is not a dps loss - it is close to dps neutral and it is certainly an option when fight mechanics favor it. Given that in general we are not doing Patchwerk fights, it is not always possible to have DoC procs lined up with Rips, which makes the gap between DoC and HotW even closer. Neither aggixx nor I have done sim work on more complex fights so I can't tell you by how much. If you want an idea of how close together the abilities are, run some LFRs using each one on different fights. NV is also pretty close, simming slightly better than HotW (0.3%), but by far less than the usual variance you get from RNG (which is generally +-5% on any given fight).

Offline
Reply With Quote
Reply

Go Back   Elitist Jerks » Class Mechanics » Druids

Thread Tools

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Mists of Pandaria: All Specs Carebare Warriors 539 05/11/13 10:52 PM
Mists of Pandaria: All Specs Carebare Warlocks 294 02/08/13 8:10 PM
Mists of Pandaria: All Specs Carebare Druids 723 10/06/12 3:30 AM
Mists of Pandaria: All Specs Carebare Priests 26 12/09/11 4:06 PM