I'm honestly very unimpressed and one step closer to switching over to my fury warrior. ZA is gonna make or break the deal.
You can view the data mined ZA weapon models on mmo-champion, only one looks like it could possibly be a new feral weapon, the one with the Dragonhawk on top. Most of the loot is meant to be around T5 so I'm hoping that they'll make it a DPS staff but again this is Blizzard we are talking about and their logic could quite possibly go:
Karazhan 10 man had DPS staff.
Next 10 man must have Tanking staff.
I am fairly impressed with the belt (367 armour, 29 str, 28 agi, 30 stam, 18 hit, BR sockets(+3 str)) though, I would really have loved it when I was at that level of gear. But its not much point with Deep Shadows for dps and Veterans/Natural Grace for tanking now. But for the level it is aimed at I think its a great item.
The Chest piece is a wierd one, as said above its pretty crap for tanking compared to T4 and even Clefthoof but I don't even think I'd take it for DPS above my shadowprowlers. Possibly if I hadn't bought Shadowprowler's already AND there wasn't a ton of other better ways to spend heroic items this patch but either one of these factors kind of renders it obsolete.
The wrist piece is okay for a DPS piece. For tanking I'd be loathe to lose my Veteran's due to its massive resilience going a long way to getting you crit capped in one item.
The wrists (21 str, 22agi, Y):
(assuming sotf, hotw, bok, 8agi gem)
21x2x1.1x1.03x1.1= 52.3446 AP
30x1.1x1.03x1.1= 37.389 AP
Total stats:
89.7 AP (89.7336)
1.2% crit
Compared to
[Shard-Bound Bracers] under the same conditions:
28x1.1x1.03x1.1= 34.8964 AP
42x1.1= 46.2
Gives:
81.1 AP (81.0964)
1.12 AP
So the badge loot gives 8 more ap and 0.08% crit. Not an earthshattering leap but when you throw in the higher stamina and the 10 int I think its a solid purchase should you have any serious upgrades you want from the new heroic loot. Definately going on the shopping list.
Might also pick up the boots for tanking (still rolling with Zierhut's) but I think Edgewalkers still beat these for DPS. At a quick glance they both have the same agility, the same number of sockets and two bonus you aren't going to really bother with (though if lacking hit the footwraps offer a nice option of hit/agi gem, agi gem and +3 str bonus).
So the difference is really 29 strength and the non dps stats vs 44 ap and 13 hit.
29x2x1.1x1.03x1.1 = 72.2854
44x1.1= 48.4
So it comes down to the hit rating really. If the 13 hit rating is worth more to you than the 25 or so AP then keep Edgemasters, else this is actually a pretty decent upgrade. Colour me suprised.
But to be honest the only item that screams out at me from the heroic list is the cloak, and partially only because I'm fed up of looking at Gilded Thorium.
Edit:
Browsing WoWhead it shows the new Idol to be a 85% proc rate. You can bet your lifesavings thats gonna mean a hefty Internal CD
