Originally Posted by Selmarix
Leather PvE gear is far from optimal from a survival point of view.
Compare TBC end game PvP rogue chest with the equivalent sunwell item:
[Brutal Gladiator's Leather Tunic]
[Bladed Chaos Tunic]
Even without the increased armor the PvP item is by far the better survival item for a WotLK feral tank despite all the wasted resilience on it. The price for the resilience comes from the dps/threat stats only.
|
I definitely would not say the PvP item is
far better for tanking. Bonus armor is gone, so it's pointless to compare armor. More total effective points does not necessarily make it a better item. As we saw in BC, there is somewhat of a soft-cap on health where adding more stamina becomes even less valuable. In the end,
any agility usually ends up being a more worthwhile stat than stamina. Without the bonus armor and crit immunity from resilience, I'd have to actually check spreadsheets to see which is better. They are at least very close in value. 26 stam is probably better than 6 agi, but if you already have a large HP pool it might not be. It's definitely not enough that someone would go out of their way to PvP to get it if they don't like to.
In addition, it's not really valid to assume they will continue itemization formats into WotLK. Compare
Tunic of Dislocation and
LK Arena 1 Druid Melee Chest. Yes, one is rare and the other epic... however the ratio of agility to stamina is pretty close and expertise is a more useful tanking stat.