Elitist Jerks
Register
Blogs
Forums


Go Back   Elitist Jerks » Class Mechanics » Druids

Closed Thread
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
Old 01/15/09, 9:12 AM   #331
dukes
Bald Bull
 
dukes's Avatar
 
Dukes
Tauren Druid
 
No WoW Account (EU)
I use starfire as my main nuke, so I'm always casting it unless the eclipse ICD is <4 seconds, in which case I switch to casting wrath. I never try and make sure I cast 3 starfires after a moonfire, as the vast majority of the time wrath will always proc an eclipse prior to needing to (as you can see from the log, the average proc rate was 2 wrath crits ignoring the 30 second one), or the moonfire will be extended due to casting starfire under eclipse / within the ICD period.

England Offline
Old 01/15/09, 9:47 AM   #332
Picu
Glass Joe
 
Picu's Avatar
 
Tauren Druid
 
Neptulon (EU)
Wrath damage.

I searched through the druid forum for this, and since i haven't found it, i'm going to ask if any of you guys experienced this :

Wrath vs. Starfire, how does the damage register? Does wrath damage register on impact, or at the end of the cast?

On starfire it's easy, at the end of the cast, since it doesn't matter what range you cast it from, the animation is the same.

On wrath ... well, this is what's been bothering me for a couple of days, but haven't gotten around to test it. (i'm at work atm, when i'm home, i raid the moment i'm online).

I know for a fact that Nature's Grace procced on several occasions (don't have a screenshot) after the wrath cast ended, but hadn't hit the target yet. So, am i to assume from this that the damage is registered instantly after the cast ends? Since it knows it's going to crit before we see the actual damage on the target. Because if this isn't true, that means that wrath damage in a raid enviroment is directly tied to the range it is cast.

Offline
Old 01/15/09, 10:00 AM   #333
 Adoriele
Happy October 19th!
 
Adoriele's Avatar
 
Night Elf Druid
 
Dragonblight
Originally Posted by Picu View Post
I searched through the druid forum for this, and since i haven't found it, i'm going to ask if any of you guys experienced this :

Wrath vs. Starfire, how does the damage register? Does wrath damage register on impact, or at the end of the cast?

On starfire it's easy, at the end of the cast, since it doesn't matter what range you cast it from, the animation is the same.

On wrath ... well, this is what's been bothering me for a couple of days, but haven't gotten around to test it. (i'm at work atm, when i'm home, i raid the moment i'm online).

I know for a fact that Nature's Grace procced on several occasions (don't have a screenshot) after the wrath cast ended, but hadn't hit the target yet. So, am i to assume from this that the damage is registered instantly after the cast ends? Since it knows it's going to crit before we see the actual damage on the target. Because if this isn't true, that means that wrath damage in a raid enviroment is directly tied to the range it is cast.
Damage itself is not registered until Wrath hits. Most procs function this way as well. NG is a specific exception they coded in so that it would affect the next cast correctly. This leads me to believe that all of the relevant information is determined at that time, but doesn't take effect until it hits, but that's purely academic.

United States Offline
Old 01/15/09, 10:05 AM   #334
dukes
Bald Bull
 
dukes's Avatar
 
Dukes
Tauren Druid
 
No WoW Account (EU)
Wrath damage is done as the actual wrath 'ball' hits the target. The damage is calculated as the spell is released. Natures grace procs at the time of release, as this is when all calculations to do with the personal effects of the spell are done (crit or not crit / trinket procs), while debuffs on the target (such as E+M) are calculated at the point of impact. This is easily provable through the use of clickable trinkets and by standing at max range chaincasting wrath in order to prove the effect of E+M (or similar debuffs on the target).

As starfire is an instant spell, all calculations are done at the time the spell finishes casting.

Last edited by dukes : 01/15/09 at 10:25 AM.

England Offline
Old 01/15/09, 10:16 AM   #335
Picu
Glass Joe
 
Picu's Avatar
 
Tauren Druid
 
Neptulon (EU)
Originally Posted by Adoriele View Post
Damage itself is not registered until Wrath hits. Most procs function this way as well. NG is a specific exception they coded in so that it would affect the next cast correctly. This leads me to believe that all of the relevant information is determined at that time, but doesn't take effect until it hits, but that's purely academic.
Going by this assumption, if i am on a IIS-MF-Starfire-Wrath(on Eclipse) rotation that would mean that the closest i am to a target, DPS should increase. I definetly have to try this on Patchwerk on two resets, with WWS to show for, standing as close as i can, and at max range with this rotation.

Last edited by Picu : 01/15/09 at 10:22 AM.

Offline
Old 01/15/09, 10:28 AM   #336
 Adoriele
Happy October 19th!
 
Adoriele's Avatar
 
Night Elf Druid
 
Dragonblight
Originally Posted by Picu View Post
Going by this assumption, if i am on a IIS-MF-Starfire-Wrath(on Eclipse) rotation that would mean that the closest i am to a target, DPS should increase. I definetly have to try this on Patchwerk on two resets, with WWS to show for, standing as close as i can, and at max range with this rotation.
Not really. You're using SF to proc Eclipse, so there's no discrepancy between your cast finishing and it proccing to worry about. After that, if the bonus to Wrath is calculated at cast finish, it doesn't matter how far you are from Patch, you'll still get the same number of casts with benefit.

United States Offline
Old 01/15/09, 12:10 PM   #337
Lord BEEF
Soda Popinski
 
Lord BEEF's Avatar
 
Tauren Druid
 
Mal'Ganis
The only way standing close would increase your damage is if that lets you get in one extra wrath that hits the boss right before he dies, as opposed to him dying while it's still in the air. Not worthwhile.

Standing close to a boss can increase your damage if you manage to convince a rogue to use tricks of the trade on you.

Offline
Old 01/15/09, 12:13 PM   #338
Olddrippy
Von Kaiser
 
Tauren Druid
 
Ursin
Although with the travel time on wrath there does seem to be a nice distance to stand so that when the wrath that procs eclipse hits, you are almost done casting the next wrath but have just enough time to switch from wrath spam to starfire.

This minimizes the wasted time at the beginning of the eclipse buff by accidentally casting another wrath.

Offline
Old 01/15/09, 2:00 PM   #339
Lord BEEF
Soda Popinski
 
Lord BEEF's Avatar
 
Tauren Druid
 
Mal'Ganis
Barkskin is being taken off the global cooldown next patch.

This should allow us to use it pre-emptively against pushback without losing any dps time, and makes nature's focus even less necessary. This will be nice if we can anticipate a shadow bolt volley or whatever.

Offline
Old 01/15/09, 3:56 PM   #340
 Adoriele
Happy October 19th!
 
Adoriele's Avatar
 
Night Elf Druid
 
Dragonblight
Originally Posted by Everyone
WWS Reports
Normally, I'd say that spamming WWS reports isn't an incredibly useful thing here. There's usually mitigating circumstances, gear differences, etc. that cause disparities between reports, so comparing them isn't going to tell you a whole lot. There are two reasons I'm not taking that stance today.

1.) I also have a parse! Wow Web Stats is my raid from Tuesday. We're nowhere near the top end (just under 4 minutes for a kill), so it gives a look at that perspective for those who're in my situation where gear/guild/etc. are still holding you back.

2.) With so many of you having posted them already, I decided to do some comparisons anyway. Late last week I wrote another spreadsheet with a very specific purpose in mind: Understanding WWS parses. I may drop this in the thread for WC at some point once I get it polished a bit, but the functionality's pretty simple. You input your stats from a Patchwerk parse (actually, any parse works, but for obvious reasons Patch is best), and it gives you a listing of information including %time spent casting, average latency, and IS/MF uptime%. It takes into account haste on gear (not procs), Lust, and Haste talents/WoA. It doesn't care about damage at all, in fact. After running all the parses on this page through (including looking up everyone's armory for haste/talent numbers and using wow-heroes for a sense of gear), here are all the results:

NameGearDPSCast%Avg. Lat.IS%MF%
Hamlet2282503479.5%.396s57.5%82.6%
Dukes2256491388.0%.210s50.1%90.9%
Eilt2130411483.5%.319s43.8%90%
Rokaz2293478484.9%.289s24.6%89.5%
Superku2234450880.7%.365s79.5%85.7%
Adoriele1898365096.3%.084s80.7%85.7%
Randomsmo2312586891.2%.165s53.0%90.9%

Now, %cast adds a default .2s to your cast times for latency, so it's a little incongruous, hence why I added Average Latency to the equation (basically, time you spent not casting/number of casts). And the gear scores are, I believe, just a sum of iLevels, plus a set amount per enchant or so, so it's not really going to check how optimal the gear actually is. But, for example, take Randomsmo vs. Rokaz. Similar gear level, about 20 ilvls difference, but due to Rokaz' abysmal IS uptime and about 5% less time spent casting, there's about 1000 DPS difference (yes, that doesn't factor in luck with crits, eclipse, etc. though if I remember, neither had particularly outstanding luck in either direction).

The sheet's attached if you'd like to play with it yourself.

Last edited by Adoriele : 02/12/09 at 1:54 PM.

United States Offline
Old 01/15/09, 7:13 PM   #341
anyakaschala
Von Kaiser
 
Draenei Shaman
 
Llane
Originally Posted by Eilt View Post
Wow Web Stats - Patchwerk

Now I know that I don't have the perfect dream set yet, and I am wasting some possible spellpower because I am waiting on a few drops to get myself down to the hit cap, but here is my concern...

The WWS I see moonkins doing very well in all have them in the 4k-5k range, which is not bad. But the other end I see Hunters/Mages/Locks etc, all coming close to breaking 6-7k. So if your raid has good mages for example, they will be pushing 6k on a patch while a moonkin appears to be on top of his game at around 5k DPS. Maybe it is just my worrying too much, but this kinda scares me in an environment where we should be pretty close to other pure DPS classes.


I only put up IS if I am refreshing MF(and eclipse is not activated), or I am about to cast wrathh to proc an eclipse.
Also take into account the boss timer. What I mean by this is, as it is usually a patchwerk link, how long it took them to kill the boss. The shorter the fight, typically the higher the dps because of bloodlust/heroism having a higher percentage of uptime during the fight.

There are parses out there of 2'17" patch kills and also I'm told though not seen, one under 2mins. Thus about a 3rd of the fight with BL active. With those, I've seen Moonkins with 5.8k dps. Which, I'm assuming would mean about 5k with your typical 3-4 min fight.

Lastly, I'd also work on training your guild and your guild shamans to pre-announce bloodlust, thus giving you time to get your trees out just ahead of time. It may seem trivial, but if you think about it, they do about 6-8% of our damage on a boss fight like patch, and they are only up for 30secs. So in a true min/max setting, getting optimal use out of them is key.

Offline
Old 01/15/09, 11:12 PM   #342
Triks
Glass Joe
 
Undead Priest
 
Cho'gall
Originally Posted by anyakaschala View Post
Also take into account the boss timer. What I mean by this is, as it is usually a patchwerk link, how long it took them to kill the boss. The shorter the fight, typically the higher the dps because of bloodlust/heroism having a higher percentage of uptime during the fight.

There are parses out there of 2'17" patch kills and also I'm told though not seen, one under 2mins. Thus about a 3rd of the fight with BL active. With those, I've seen Moonkins with 5.8k dps. Which, I'm assuming would mean about 5k with your typical 3-4 min fight.

Lastly, I'd also work on training your guild and your guild shamans to pre-announce bloodlust, thus giving you time to get your trees out just ahead of time. It may seem trivial, but if you think about it, they do about 6-8% of our damage on a boss fight like patch, and they are only up for 30secs. So in a true min/max setting, getting optimal use out of them is key.
Pretty sure the 5.8k dps moonkin got like 85% starfire crit rate, aka super lucky rng,.

Here is my crappy crit rate and pretty good dps

Wow Web Stats

Offline
Old 01/16/09, 8:26 AM   #343
Gormane
Glass Joe
 
Tauren Priest
 
Aggramar (EU)
The idea to compare parses in order to find out how different rotations perform under non-ideal conditions is interesting. However, a few more common variables should be included in any such table, because they influence caster dps just as much as gear level:

- presence / uptime of 5% crit debuff
- presence / uptime of 3% crit debuff
- presence / uptime of 3% damage multiplier
- presence of Totem of Wrath (or lesser spell power alternatives)
- presence of Wrath of Air
- FF use yes/no

A few of these variables will most likely be the same in every parse, but it's best to be sure, so the comparison is accurate. In Adoriele's parse, for example, there was no Totem of Wrath, and possibly not even a Wrath of Air (only one shaman and no death knight with Imp. Icy Talons, so shaman may have opted for Windfury Totem).

Germany Offline
Old 01/16/09, 9:34 AM   #344
 Adoriele
Happy October 19th!
 
Adoriele's Avatar
 
Night Elf Druid
 
Dragonblight
Originally Posted by Gormane View Post
The idea to compare parses in order to find out how different rotations perform under non-ideal conditions is interesting. However, a few more common variables should be included in any such table, because they influence caster dps just as much as gear level:

- presence / uptime of 5% crit debuff
- presence / uptime of 3% crit debuff
- presence / uptime of 3% damage multiplier
- presence of Totem of Wrath (or lesser spell power alternatives)
- presence of Wrath of Air
- FF use yes/no

A few of these variables will most likely be the same in every parse, but it's best to be sure, so the comparison is accurate. In Adoriele's parse, for example, there was no Totem of Wrath, and possibly not even a Wrath of Air (only one shaman and no death knight with Imp. Icy Talons, so shaman may have opted for Windfury Totem).
He did, in fact, though the sheet takes care of that. Really, the sheet's only purpose is to give information about time, not damage. I just included the damage numbers in the chart because they were readily available.

United States Offline
Old 01/16/09, 1:58 PM   #345
Eothlorien
Glass Joe
 
Night Elf Druid
 
Llane
Patchwerk WWS
Here's my latest parse without obscene lag (this week's kill was avg of 500ms+. Using the spreadsheet I came up with the following numbers:

NameGearDPSCast%Avg. Lat.IS%MF%
Eothlorien????443485.8%.260s63.8%77.5%


Lagged WWS
I added this WWS to just to show how lag hinders our rotation. I proc'd eclipse with Starfire so many times in this fight because the timers were off.
NameGearDPSCast%Avg. Lat.IS%MF%
Eothlorien????382472.0%.506s71.1%75.8%




EDIT: grammar and latest (lagged WWS)

Last edited by Eothlorien : 01/16/09 at 2:11 PM.

Offline
Closed Thread

Go Back   Elitist Jerks » Class Mechanics » Druids

Thread Tools

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Moonkin DPS Spreadsheet Efejel Druids 1925 11/04/08 2:34 PM
Infraction for Moonkin Kai: Grammar Praetorian The Banhammer 0 06/02/08 6:28 PM
Moonkin Arena set in 2.4 nero Player vs. Player 30 05/21/08 4:41 PM
Moonkin DPS Calculator? Aadar Class Mechanics 87 04/16/07 2:31 AM
Raiding with ferals, moonkin, shadowpriests, etc Liandra Public Discussion 74 08/29/06 7:49 PM