Druid Changes Patch 3.1 - Page 38

Candela · 03/14/09, 6:59 AM

Originally Posted by Vinclass

I was just about to post that. lol

How about it, 360 swipe without a target req. Crazy. Combined with the changes to FFF's coefficient, tanking groups and adds should be drastically easier.

I seriously doubt that the red area is better than the green area, assuming that Swipe hits up to 10 yards away at the moment and up to 5 yards away on PTR.

Altho it seems we won't have to deal with parry & dodge on our AoE ability anymore. At least I hope so.

It still procs Primal Fury, ILotP and Savage Defense.

Green: current swipe area
Red: new swipe area
Yellow: Consecration/Thunderstomp area

nightcrowler · 03/14/09, 7:09 AM

And I also wonder if Swipe still counts as melee attack with this change (regarding ILotP, PF and OoC).

ooc procs out of everything (also when you use HS, and since swipe is a melee attack there is ni reason to don't proc ilop and pf.

Also the previous swipe range was the green one only if it can chain otherwise it was half red circle.

I stll prefer swipe the old way and a 15 sec cd roar tha puts something like a lacerate bleed on targets (call it savage roar - bear)

Candela · 03/14/09, 7:24 AM

There is usually no problem chaining it since targets which you hit will enter the red area, allowing chains to happen. So you normally cover the green area.

OoC only procs from auto-attacks in feral forms, so it doesn't matter.

Added a yellow circle which shows the Paladin/Warrior AoE range.

Currently it's a big nerf in my opinion.

tlbj6142 · 03/14/09, 8:54 AM

Why did they increase the damage (I think it is now 3x the old value) from FFF? Any one see a blue post on it? I guess they want us to keep it in our rotation even though it now last 5min? Just seems sort of odd.

nightcrowler · 03/14/09, 9:16 AM

The main problem with FFF is the usually i can't apply it in 25 men cause moonkins and Spriest have better debuffs.

♦ Kurisu · 03/14/09, 9:28 AM

Well the only way (least I think) they would consider to expanding the range is to put a cooldown on swipe thus making it like thunderclap/consecrate. Just based on your wording I'm guessing you haven't tested it on the PTR Candela (usage of assume)? The AE lacerate ability wouldn't be too bad.

Camulos · 03/14/09, 10:09 AM

So . . . damage ticks that crit from a Primal Gore enhanced Lacerate should now proc Savage Defense?

Freedom · 03/14/09, 10:21 AM

Just taking away the target requirement of swipe would be nice, it can be somewhat luck based tabbing to a target that is in range of swipe when multiple adds have just spawned.

smellme · 03/14/09, 10:37 AM

There is currently a bug on thr Ptr which causes swipe to have a reduced range.

There is currently a bug where your auto attack target is swapping when using multi-target abilities such as swipe. Please test this out in a future build. I will note what you are reporting to be tested at a later time as well. Thank you.

The problem is that when your auto attack target switches, it will mess with your effective melee range. I have noted the issue you are stating, and it will be looked into regardless.

MMO-Champion BlueTracker - [BUG] Bear Swipe

Crucial288 · 03/14/09, 10:58 AM

Originally Posted by Freedom

Just taking away the target requirement of swipe would be nice, it can be somewhat luck based tabbing to a target that is in range of swipe when multiple adds have just spawned.

Not a problem at all. Just testing this, If i have a mob attacking me in melee range, and im targetting another mob when is not even agrod,I am still able to swipe, and will hit the close by target.

Candela · 03/14/09, 2:07 PM

Originally Posted by Kurisu

Well the only way (least I think) they would consider to expanding the range is to put a cooldown on swipe thus making it like thunderclap/consecrate. Just based on your wording I'm guessing you haven't tested it on the PTR Candela (usage of assume)? The AE lacerate ability wouldn't be too bad.

I assume the 10 yard range on current swipe (through chaining).

The range on PTR is 5 yards, datamined spell on wowhead tells that way, and my own testing with rooting a mob and getting just barely out of melee range shows it aswell.

A cooldown on it wouldn't sound bad.
Like: 9 sec cooldown (obviously doing 6 times its current damage then)
This would free most of our gcds for other abilities, instead of focusing on Swipe.
And it would also apply a larger initial threat on groups.

Originally Posted by smellme

There is currently a bug on thr Ptr which causes swipe to have a reduced range.

MMO-Champion BlueTracker - [BUG] Bear Swipe

This means, less than 5 yards even? Because the range on PTR currently is 5 yards. And not through a bug, through the skill implementation of Swipe.

PrayForDeath · 03/14/09, 3:14 PM

Originally Posted by nightcrowler

Basically I was erasing all CP on a FB and RIP misses (I was sure about that, did the changed that kind of mechanic or it was always that way?), while you actually preserve your CPs when you miss a finisher.

This was changed when they added Primal Precision in 3.02.

edit: nevermind, I was thinking of energy. Please delete.

Eilt · 03/14/09, 6:00 PM

Originally Posted by nightcrowler

The main problem with FFF is the usually i can't apply it in 25 men cause moonkins and Spriest have better debuffs.

Misery should not interfere with FFF at all, as FFF is the armor debuff, the only issue would be with a moonkin keeping up iFF. I would imagine if you have issues due to the Misery debuff it would be a bug

seminarca · 03/14/09, 7:20 PM

Misery most definitely does interfere with the reapplication of Feral Faerie Fire. Needless to say, it's an incredibly annoying bug that was reported ad nauseum in beta but was never fixed.

Pzychotix · 03/14/09, 8:29 PM

Originally Posted by Eilt

Misery should not interfere with FFF at all, as FFF is the armor debuff, the only issue would be with a moonkin keeping up iFF. I would imagine if you have issues due to the Misery debuff it would be a bug

It's because of the weird interactions of buffs.

FF < Imp FF = Misery in terms of +spellhit% debuff, which means Misery takes priority over FF.

However, FF and Misery don't share the same category in terms of armor debuff, which is why FF is allowed to be applied again when FF runs out.

That's my take on it anyways.

/edit: Clarification.